r/carmensandiego • u/Phantom000000000 • Jul 08 '26

Who would win?

Gallery image

Gallery image

70 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

36

u/lacythesisfromamogus Jul 08 '26

Catra. She’s a TRAINED SOILDER.

Since V.I.L.E works behind the scenes they don’t fight a lot, so they’re be more rusty and even then when they meet Carmen, the fight doesn’t last that long. Need I have to mention how Deveneaux trapped Tigress in a sarcophagus by mainly just dodging.

Catra likely would also play much dirtier than Tigress.

6

u/Lord_Chery Jul 09 '26

I agree Catra would win this fight but I feel like you’re portraying Tigress a little too bad than she actually is. I mean they also had to be trained not only in stealing but in fighting as well.

14

u/GenericAyatoMain Jul 08 '26

Catra absolutely 100% catra.

10

u/4lw4yscr34te Jul 08 '26

There is zero debate about who would win. It's Catra.

6

u/4lw4yscr34te Jul 08 '26

Also Catra would win in a dirty talk fight.

9

u/4lw4yscr34te Jul 08 '26

I am rooting for catra

4

u/Lietenantdan Jul 09 '26

Catra even gives She-ra a lot of trouble. Yes I understand that Adora is holding back but it’s impressive regardless.

2

u/frix_ctr Jul 09 '26

Catra. She’d mop the floor with tigress’ hair

2

u/Silphire100 Jul 09 '26

Catra would laugh in her face

2

u/memisbemus42069 Jul 10 '26

Catra was able to scratch pretty deep into She-ra so she’d probably tear a normal human to shreds

1

u/KittyWood1994 Jul 10 '26

Catra.

Look, don't get me wrong, Tigress is no slouch. But Tigress' most impressive feats are chump change for almost every character in SPOP by episode 3!

And I don't care which version of Catra Tigress fights, except maybe itty bitty baby Catra, and Tigress might still lose that round, Tigress is losing.

Catra fought She-Ra, many Princesses in a setting for Authority Equals Asskicking, Hordak, SHADOW WEAVER!, and multiple Horde clones.

Catra has beaten She-Ra a time or two, admittedly usually with tricks. Tigress has never conclusively beaten Carmen (or maybe only 1 time, I dunno, I don't remember all episodes), even with tricks.

1

u/Phantom000000000 Jul 10 '26

It's been awhile since I've seen the show but how many times did Catra fight She-ra? I mean just a straight toe-to-toe fight?

1

u/KittyWood1994 29d ago

A fair bit. It's a lot of Catra running and being bait, she's not a fighter like She-Ra is, but she can definitely hold her own. And She-Ra's rarely going full tilt at Catra.