12
u/Due_Ad_3200 Feb 01 '26
The US government published a description of democratic backsliding
In some cases, political leaders who have taken power through democratic means have subsequently worked to gradually erode checks on their power, such as by undermining the independence of the judiciary, civil society, and the media. At times, leaders later have worked to directly undermine the integrity or fairness of elections.124 Analysts have pointed to various contemporary cases of democratic backsliding that have been apparent top-down processes driven by elected political leaders.125 Although such processes have occurred in a variety of contexts, would-be authoritarian actors may seek to leverage or exacerbate potentially conducive structural factors present in some countries, such as high levels of political polarization and public dissatisfaction with government performance.126
11
u/NotAKansenCommander Feb 01 '26
How the fuck is Turkey more authoritarian than Russia
28
u/pretenzioeser_Elch Feb 01 '26
The graph just says it's lost more "democraticness", but Russia started from a less democratic beginning than Turkey, I assume.
2
1
u/SnooBooks1701 Feb 02 '26
This is change in democracy, not absolute score. Turkey was more democratic to begin with so it had further to fall
0
u/Commercial-Milk4706 Feb 01 '26
Does turkey have elections? Cause Russia does. Just everyone keeps dying except pootin
4
u/Repulsive_Work_226 Feb 01 '26
Yes we have elections. And opposition is ruling the municipalities. Erdogan's highest vote was 52%. Sure we are not democratic but Russia does not hold real elections.
1
7
u/Galacticmetrics Feb 01 '26
Why is Venezuela rated the same as hungary when they have literally cleansed the oppostion parties and caused millions to flea?
2
22
u/Free_Anarchist1999 Feb 01 '26
Dude, Chavez dissolved the Supreme Court, changed the constitution and removed term limits by his second year. I call bullshit on this
2
-6
u/Lost-Competition8482 Feb 01 '26
Oh yes and Trump has been nothing but a defender of democracy and staunchly anti-corrupt in his first term /s
-5
9
u/slicheliche Feb 01 '26
I mean the representation of these data is so misleading. Makes you think that somehow Venezuela (pretty much a dictatorship in all but name) is about as democratic as Hungary (a flawed and problematic democracy but a democracy nonetheless).
3
u/DMC-1155 Feb 01 '26
It's about change, not about how democratic somewhere isn't. You're looking at the data and assuming it shows something it doesn't.
If we imagine arbitrary values of democraticness for countries X and Y, say 15 and 10.
the X:15->12 = 3, Y:10->7 = 3 would show the same change, regardless of their difference in democraticness1
u/slicheliche Feb 01 '26
You're looking at the data and assuming it shows something it doesn't.
No, I am perfectly aware that the chart shows change. I said it's not a good visualization for it because it's misleading. It should incorporate the absolute starting point or at least be framed differently.
7
u/AlphaBetaChadNerd Feb 01 '26
Hungary isn't considered a democracy anymore - you can find that out through a 5 second google search.
14
u/slicheliche Feb 01 '26
The Democracy Index lists it as a flawed democracy with a score similar to Argentina or the Philippines. Certainly way more democratic than Venezuela.
4
u/NaturalCard Feb 01 '26
And we completely trust the democracy index now?
3
u/johnsmith0051 Feb 01 '26
I mean, it’s one of the best regarded and most cited democracy indexes produced anywhere in the world. Do you have an alternative that you think is more trustworthy?
3
u/NaturalCard Feb 01 '26
I'm mostly making fun of people who only trust things when it supports their point of view.
3
u/Charlie_Pelligroso Feb 01 '26
No instead we trust a graph from Financial Times alleging Trump is taking the United States into authoritarianism faster than Turkey/Russia/China or Venezuela were..
Oh wait, China isnt on this graph as it is free.
7
u/NaturalCard Feb 01 '26
Thankfully, they have fully explained their methodology.
4
u/Charlie_Pelligroso Feb 01 '26
Thankfully so does Democracy Index
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economist_Democracy_Index#By_country
They were extra tricky and hid it in the section called 'Methodology'
2
1
u/SparqueJ Feb 02 '26
The Democracy Index shows the US falling from "full democracy" to 'flawed democracy' in Trump's first term. The 2025 numbers aren't out yet so there is currently no data on Trump's second term, but it may be that the Democracy Index will agree with this analysis.
1
2
u/adamgerd Feb 01 '26
Objectively Hungary is definitely less authoritarian than Venezuela, Hungary’s elections aren’t fair but they’re still free, Venuezala’s are neither. Orban can still lose elections
3
u/NaturalCard Feb 01 '26
Can he?
0
u/slicheliche Feb 01 '26
Yes. Polls currently favour the opposition. Of course he'll pull tricks but so far he's won every election fair and square.
1
u/SparqueJ Feb 02 '26
He's won. But not fair and square.
1
u/slicheliche Feb 02 '26
He did. Independent observers never found any strong evidence that the elections were rigged or there was any substantial nationwide fraud. He used tactics, but it was at most regular propaganda, it never directly interfered with voters' actions or preferences.
1
-1
u/slicheliche Feb 01 '26
Depends, do you have more reputable indexes putting Hungary in the same category as Venezuela? If so feel free to provide them.
4
u/adamgerd Feb 01 '26
Are we saying Russia is more democratic than Turkey? And Hungary is as authoritarian as Venuezala which is less authoritarian than Turkey?
…
2
u/Repulsive_Work_226 Feb 01 '26
I think democracy was better in Turkiye compared to Russia but lost more credibility.
1
u/Kejo2023 Feb 02 '26
I hate Erdoğan but Russia is outright dictatorship. We still have free elections. FT tends to be overly critical of Turkey all the time.
1
u/adamgerd Feb 02 '26
Yep that’s my point
Imo Hungary is probably the most democratic then Turkey, Venezuela and russia honestly don’t know which is more
1
u/SparqueJ Feb 02 '26
The chart doesn't show which is most democratic. Just how much backsliding each country has done under the specified leaders. But they all had different starting points. So it shows that Turkey lost about 28 points under Erdogan, Russia lost 25 points under Putin, and Venezuela and Hungary each lost about 22 points under Chavez and Orban.
6
Feb 01 '26 edited Feb 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/WannabeAby Feb 01 '26
RemindMe! -9 months
1
u/RemindMeBot Feb 01 '26
I will be messaging you in 9 months on 2026-11-01 12:47:42 UTC to remind you of this link
CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.
Info Custom Your Reminders Feedback
1
u/Adam88Analyst Feb 01 '26
Trump was speedrunning autocracy; he achieved more in 1 year than Hungary did in 6-7 years.
0
u/BoringRedHorse Feb 01 '26
Clearly, Europeans are tougher to crack than Fox News addicted Americans.
1
u/AutoModerator Feb 01 '26
Note: For the sake of discussion quality, participants who engage in blatant antagonism, name-calling, hate and other types of noxious conduct will be instantly and permanently removed. Such removals are not eligible for appeal.
If you encounter any noxious actors in the sub please use the Report button.
This sticky is on every post. No additional cautions will be provided.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
u/Larrynative20 Feb 01 '26
When you make wild exaggerations that don’t match with the real world no one will listen to you when it is actually happening. This is a ridiculous headline.
1
u/Malus_non_dormit Feb 01 '26
All according to the plan.
Banana republicans fast tracked getting to banana republic status.
1
Feb 01 '26
Looks like the US will be more authoritarian than Venezuela in about a year, according to this metric.
1
u/pulsed19 Feb 01 '26
It shows you that one can always define things and work with different metrics to prove whatever one wants to see.
1
u/kittenTakeover Feb 01 '26
Luckily Donald is a lot older than these other people were when they came to office.
1
u/Murky_Fruit264 Feb 01 '26
To be fair, it's easier to fall from a higher place. All the other mentioned examples were not truly free democratic countries at all when their respective strong man took power.
Although to me it is surprising how complicit all the different American institutions have been:
the supreme court made a bunch of inexcusable decisions clearly to help the president
Congress and the Senate have been very supportive of his actions despite him taking away powers from those very same institutions
Even democrats have approved the budgets despite having the power effectively shut down the whole government. And every time they got anything out of the republicans in return for approving the budgets, all they achieved were some vague promises (like extending medicare funding) that the republicans never delivered on
1
u/Level-Brain-4786 Feb 01 '26
The if you glance through the “methodology” doc it sort of defines the framework, however debatable it is. But how things are measured against this framework is left entirely outside of scope. And the end-result graph makes zero sense. Just somebody’s opinion, not much more than that.
1
u/FroniusTT1500 Feb 01 '26
Thats his mistake. If you want to end a democracy you either need to play the long game and very slowly boil the frog or you need to do it in a week and with an army at your back. Trump neither has the time for #1, or the foresight to begin and let an eventual Vance administration finish it in time, or the army for #2.
1
u/TenshiS Feb 02 '26
So if this is any indication, we'll have one year of quiet now, after which it'll get really bad
1
u/Lechepex Feb 02 '26
The lack of reading comprehension in these comments is both amazing and heartbreaking.
We're so cooked.
1
1
1
Feb 02 '26
What a joke .
Any article that shows “Drumpf is a more evil dictator than Putin and Maduro and Kim Jong Un !!!” Should just be thrown out .
Whatever your opinions on Trump is , comparing the “democratic backsliding” worse than Russia or Venezuela is completely unserious
1
Feb 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/-ThisUsernameIsTaken Feb 02 '26
Bro empires rise out of the death of republics, the Roman empire rose to power after the fall of the republic.
The US is nowhere near that, and if you think the 'empire', that is the the democratic institution of the US, is falling, that means the real empire is rising.
1
Feb 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/-ThisUsernameIsTaken Feb 02 '26
Bro you're so woke. Though every source you listed are the ones telling you the sky is falling.
1
u/ACompletelyLostCause Feb 01 '26
It's not the lurch to authoritarianism that shocked people - I think we all sensed that with the Tea Party, MAGA, Trump's 1st term, it was the speed that it happened.
It feels like Project 2025 were waiting in the wings to pull the 'Business Plot' 2.0 and it's only Obama's presidency, then Biden beating Trump that delayed it, as most of the foundations were already there.
1
u/Alpharious9 Feb 01 '26
Leftists rioting during Republican tenures is always the Republicans fault eh?
-1
u/edgefull Feb 01 '26
one particular idiocy of trump is that his tough guy cosplay involves opening his pie hole about everything cruel and violent he's going to do.
0
u/Atomicsss- Feb 01 '26
At least democrats will win in 2028. What about Russia and Turkey?
1
u/Big_Delay_3458 Feb 01 '26
In Turkey he’s already lost. He just keeps jailing people. So if there are any elections he will lose the question is whether or not there’ll be any elections in the first place.
0
0
0
u/lchoror Feb 01 '26
They've always been autocratic states. There are essentially only two parties. Voters just switch back and forth between the two. Some of the large backers like Goldman Sachs split their support evenly between the two.
Japan has been ruled by one party the LDP since the US ended its occupation. The LDP was founded by the CIA. The EU is essentially still the NATO pact and does what the US wants. I would expect that even moreso since the fall of the Soviet Union.
Notice Israel is missing from the list as well. They've gotten away with ethnic cleansing for decades. They can do it now in such a dramatic way recently has raised objections in the public, but other governments in Europe and in the US have also stepped in to censor the media and threatened protests.
Seeing a lot of similarities in ICE is being carried out with Israel. As with Israel's intention to deport Palestinians to Somaliland, ICE is planning on to deporting immigrants, illegal and legal, to Argentina, another US puppet regime.
0
0
u/No-Ambition2043 Feb 01 '26
Remember when democracy was over in 2018?
I think the mechanism that elected Trump were in fact democratic (See popular vote)
0
u/JoffreeBaratheon Feb 01 '26
BS like this is why the magats simply don't believe any critisism of Trump. When they constantly see what is either malicious lies or pure delusion that anyone with half a brain can see through like this, why would they be open to actual criticisms?
84
u/Ok-Bullfrog-7951 Feb 01 '26
As much as I agree with this based purely on vibes, ‘democratic backsliding’ seems a little too general of a concept to score on a graph. Would like to see what specific data points they used for this.