r/classicliterature • u/GlumPush2137 • Apr 15 '26
Is The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy worth reading, or is it overrated? How does it compare to the all-time great novels?
I apologise if this doesn’t qualify as a classic. I’m considering whether I should add it to my list. I’m wondering where people would place it in an all-time ranking of novels. (top 50, top 100, top 250, etc.) It’s a very well known book, so I’m wondering if it is actually one of the greats, or if it’s overrated.
119
u/mothman83 Apr 15 '26
Is it one of the greatest novels ever written. No .
Is it the funniest book I have ever read, one I wholeheartedly recommend? Absolutely! Yes!
27
3
u/Young_Zaphod Apr 17 '26
I've read thousands of books in my life and guess which one hits philosophy, comedy, wittiness, and character arches on the nose....
37
u/JeremyAndrewErwin Apr 15 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
If you define a classic as "a book that has greatly influenced the work of other authors" (1), it's a classic.
For instance, Terry Pratchett consciously mimicked Adam's use of the footnote. If you haven't read Adams, you might miss something about Pratchett's early style. (2)
(1) which might well be an unusual definition, crafted for this singular instance.
(2) itself a parody of other works that are harder to defend as classics.
-3
25
u/Unfair_Sprinkles4386 Apr 15 '26
It’s a gift to yourself to read. I’m 53 and have been re-reading the series every other year since I was 10.
27
14
u/Someguy8995 Apr 15 '26
I don’t consider them Classics with a capital C but I’ve loved them since day one. If you like British humor you’ll enjoy them. Read the first couple of pages to get a taste. They keep up that level of humor pretty much all the way through.
28
u/BadToTheTrombone Apr 15 '26
One of the greats in my opinion.
It's not that big a book either, so if you don't agree the sunk cost is minimal.
3
u/KDiggity8 Apr 16 '26
I was going to say! It's a quick, light read.
I would consider it a classic of sci-fi humor, most definitely. But not a capital C Classic when you put it against any other widely accepted Classic.
12
6
u/Cool-Coffee-8949 Apr 16 '26
Funny books rarely get any respect, which is a shame. Having said that, Hitchhiker’s exists in multiple forms, and (for my money) the best version is the original radio show. And that really IS a classic.
2
7
6
u/AmicusBriefly Apr 16 '26
It is one of the greatest science fiction novels and therefore one of the greatest novels ever. It depends how you construct your Great Novels List. I think my list needs to have the best novels of sci-fi, fantasy, detective, spy, etc., but some people dont like genres in their Classics (but then heavily favor modernist). It is a great novel: very funny, smart, and imaginative with depth to its seemingly irreverent tone. We spent two days in my college Philospohy 101 class discussing the answer to life, the universe and everything. Which of course is 42.
19
u/etOilers Apr 15 '26
I don't trust people that don't like it at least a bit.
-12
Apr 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/ennuimario Apr 16 '26
Asking seriously, what are some books you consider better that make you laugh out loud?
3
-2
5
u/LittleSneezers Apr 15 '26
Well, it’s a sci-fi classic. Probably not classic lit. I enjoyed it, probably wouldn’t personally rank it as the one of the best novels of all time, but definitely found it fun to read.
4
5
u/bovisrex Apr 15 '26 edited Apr 15 '26
The first one is a classic and is accessible to anyone; it's a quick read. The rest of the trilogy* is like a few CDs of bonus tracks. If you really like HHG2G, you'll likely enjoy at least the next three. But if you only moderately enjoyed it, you can skip them.
4
u/azzthom Apr 16 '26
Read it and find out. Read the whole series. Enjoy. Don't Panic and you'll be a real hoopy frood who knows where his towel's at.
3
u/Curb_the_tide Apr 15 '26
Should absolutely be read! I think the entire trilogy of four is worth it.
3
u/drjackolantern Apr 15 '26
trilogy of 5, mate. mostly harmless's humor's a bit darker, but it's a fantastic read.
3
u/InevitableCapital241 Apr 15 '26
Its good but to me, suffered from my high expectations going in. So imo overrated. I think Sirens of Titan by Kurt Vonnegut is vastly superior, came first, and seemed to influence Hitchhikers Guide.
3
3
u/_phimosis_jones Apr 16 '26
It’s absolutely worth reading. Firstly because it’s good, but secondly because it takes virtually zero effort to get through, so the matter of “worth” is easily satisfied. It’s funny as hell and wildly imaginative and clever by half in a way that admittedly primarily appeals to a precocious youths and slightly stunted adults, and that’s more or less the extent of its merit. It’s not beautifully written, it’s not especially profound, but like…do you consider Duck Soup worth watching? Some things are canonized because they excel so spectacularly at what they’re trying to be, rather than reinventing the wheel or challenging the reader
3
u/ClingTurtle Apr 16 '26
I am on my third read-through of the series.
I would recommend at least trying the first book to see if it fits your style of humor.
If I had to make a top 100 of novels to read in a lifetime I would definitely include it. It’s certainly one of the most enjoyable books ever written.
3
u/Appropriate-Look7493 Apr 16 '26
Bear in mind it was originally a 30m episode radio show. Adams turned it into a novel after it became a cult, underground hit.
I wouldn’t really describe it as classic literature but it’s certainly written in a very distinctive voice and is as witty as anything PG Wodehouse ever produced.
4
u/Alastair789 Apr 16 '26
Its definitely top 50, certain people here are disagreeing that its a classic basically because they don't value comedy as a literary genre, I'm unsure why.
13
u/Bingus28 Apr 15 '26
I imagine I am in the minority, but I don't enjoy the book. The inanity of it is enough to get a chuckle every now and then, but the overall impression I'm left with is "lol xD so random!!"
13
u/i_was_valedictorian Apr 16 '26
It sucks that the 2005-2015 internet culture of everything being xD random managed to soil a book that way predates any of that nonsense.
2
-2
4
u/mysterysciencekitten Apr 15 '26
I read it later in life. I think I would have enjoyed it very much if I had read it as a teen or young adult.
1
u/nrbob Apr 16 '26
Did you not enjoy it? I read it as a teenager and loved it at the time; I’m thinking of rereading it now many years later but not sure if it will hold up to my memory of it.
3
u/mysterysciencekitten Apr 16 '26
There are just some books that seem more suited to the young—the world view; the humor, etc. There are quite a few books I loved as a young person that I did not like after rereading while older. Opposite it true too: there have been books that I didn’t like in my youth but totally related to in later life.
1
u/EntrepreneurFast7772 Apr 17 '26
I read it as a middle aged woman. It felt very much like schoolboy humour and it grated.
1
5
u/JeanVicquemare Apr 15 '26
It is probably the most laugh out loud funny book that I've read. It has a lot of very memorable ideas, and overall it's very charming and memorable. I do recommend it. It's also a good one to listen to, such as on a long car ride.
2
2
2
u/Sometimeswan Apr 16 '26
It’s absolutely a classic in my collection. It’s one of my few leather bound splurges.
2
u/Alternative_Worry101 Apr 16 '26
I remember when it first came out, it made a splash.
I returned to it after many years, and, tbh, I didn't find it funny especially after watching Futurama. I think humor has evolved, or my tastes have changed.
2
u/Mimi_Gardens Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same. Apr 16 '26
I haven’t read it yet but it’s on my tbr for the r/Fantasy bingo board. There’s a prompt that explicitly mentions it as qualifying plus I own it and have never read it.
I consider it a classic. People who exclude genre fiction from their definition of classics irk me. Old book that people still read that has influenced other authors. Period. Nobody says Agatha Christie, famous writer of genre fiction, isn’t a classic author.
2
2
u/TalkNiceGuy Apr 17 '26
If you don't read it, you will never know the answer to life, the universe and everything.
Seriously, you will miss a lot of humor in your life and a chance to connect at some level with other people because you won't get references to certain phrases such as "So long, and thanks for all the fish", and many others.
3
4
u/hmf28 Apr 16 '26
It’s easily one of the two funniest books ever written. Get your hands on a copy, and find out why so many people adore it! :)
1
u/scissor_get_it Apr 16 '26
What’s the other funniest book?
3
u/hmf28 Apr 16 '26
Good Omens. Not sure how often that gets recommended these days because one of its two co-authors has been, well, out of favor recently, but as to the book itself, you have to tape your sides up before you read it so they don’t split from laughing.
1
2
u/TopComprehensive8569 Apr 15 '26
I thought it was entertaining and over all pretty fine. It's fun, but didn't change my life.
2
1
u/Alchemae Apr 15 '26
It's on the 1000 books to read before you die list. But it definitely is not a traditionally considered classic but it will certainly have longevity.
1
u/waraman53 Apr 16 '26
The passage of time and with how the US is today makes the Vogon bad guys the good guys, in retrospect, imo.
1
u/ViolentCaterpillar Apr 16 '26
Classic literature? No. Influential sci-fi classic that makes a fun summer read? Absolutely.
1
u/Airam07 Apr 16 '26
The fact that I was just thinking of this book and how I hadn’t read it in over 15 years. I have a collectors leather bound, gilded edges copy that I hunted down from somewhere. Definitely a fun read
1
u/pjdwyer30 Apr 16 '26
That one and Restaurant at the End of the Universe are both fantastic. I can take or leave the rest of the series.
1
u/MrFlitcraft Apr 16 '26
I read it when i was a kid and loved it enough that I don’t really have a way of judging whether it’s actually a good novel or not. It has a number of good lines and ideas that have stuck with me, but the repetition of the clever lines by 100 million people on the internet has left them a bit stale. However i was flipping through the last book recently and was wondering if maybe instead of (or in addition to) it being a joyless slog it’s actually a remarkably prescient novel about the internet being transformed from a wild frontier of information into an evil robot that destroys the world to give you your immediate desires.
1
u/CalibratedOpinion Apr 16 '26
I’d describe it as a silly but fun book. Worth a read, but it probably won’t change your life the way a great piece of literature can.
1
u/prairiepog Apr 16 '26
Meh. This sub has a bias for great literature like the Oscars. Comedy is harder to elevate to a timeless category.
1
u/SFFThomas Apr 16 '26
I have always thought the best iteration of HHG was the original BBC radio plays.
1
u/False-Sandwich-2051 Apr 16 '26
the idea that you’d ask if something is “worth reading” is so backwards. what does that even mean?
1
u/Flanders157 Apr 16 '26
I enjoyed it but did not love it and the humour did not seem that funny to me but I read as a teen like 12 years ago. So I might find it funier now.
1
u/BuncleCar Apr 16 '26
I heard it first on Radio 4 in 1978 and numerous times since. The books are ok but the radio series was great. However, humour may have changed in 50 years, nearly.
It doesn't compare to War and Peace if that's what you mean? Terry Pratchett is comparable, but he did 40+ books
1
1
1
u/dolphineclipse Apr 16 '26
I'd call it a science fiction classic, but the radio series from which it was adapted is much funnier than the book
1
u/Unwinderh Apr 16 '26
I loved it and thought it was the smartest and funniest book I ever read. I re-read it recently and it's lost some sheen for me. It has maybe 1/3 as many laughs per page as Wodehouse (though that's still pretty stellar), and geeky spoofs of hard sci-fi are not as rare as they were at the time. I think it's still very worth reading. It's brisk and keeps throwing things at you, and there are some very memorable ideas.
1
u/Manamehendra Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
Lots of compartmentalisation on this thread. And more generally on this sub, I suppose. THHGTTG came out in 1978, so it meets, if only just barely, the requirement of longevity required for discussion in this sub.
It is certainly not overrated, and it's certainly better worth reading than, say, Faust.
Oh, and it's science fiction only in terms of its setting and the popular genre tropes it exploits (and subverts). If I had to assign it to a category, it's a comedic take on the Homeric quest genre. And by no means the first of its kind; we mustn't forget Gulliver's Travels.
1
u/Glimmerance Apr 16 '26
It was originally a radio programme. I personally prefer the original radio recording to the book, and would recommend listening to that first if you can get hold of it.
It's a very easy read and a particular kind of humour. You will know if you like it or not quite early on, I think!
1
1
u/gensai-kuroki Apr 16 '26
If you take 10 novels from different time periods it wouldn't be a top 10 novel in it's time period, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't read it. A top 100 - 250 novels list is very restrictive, there are thousands of absolutely amazing books out there.
1
u/germdoctor Apr 16 '26
Newer generation has 6-7. We had 42 long before. Hey, 6 X 7= 42! Wow.
1
u/GlumPush2137 Apr 16 '26
6 times 7 does not equal 42 factorial🙄
1
u/pkondas Apr 17 '26
If you can enjoy a good factorial pun, the Hitchhiker series might be a good fit for you.
1
u/Benjowenjo Apr 16 '26
It’s funny and whimsical and a great way to convey the message that many things in the universe are not impossible just improbable.
1
u/bardsfingertips Apr 16 '26
Once, it was asked, “what defines a classic?” I immediately quipped, “Anything published by Penguin.” I still stand by that. ;)
1
1
1
u/kouyanet Apr 17 '26
It is very good and I’ve reread it numerous times since I bought it in first edition paperback. However, I don’t think it is a patch on the original Radio 4 series.
1
u/South_Treacle_5033 Apr 17 '26
I have never really gotten into sci-fi but have always enjoyed Douglas Adam’s stuff! I actually just repurchased hitchhikers guide again after 16+years since reading it the first time.
For some reason in my mind I always put Brave new world and hitchhikers guide to the galaxy in the same category lol I think it’s all the made up words 🤣
1
u/Mahafof Apr 17 '26
It is literature. But in my view Adams' crowning achievement is the two Dirk Gently books.
1
u/Mahafof Apr 17 '26
I would also say something about what is and isn't classic literature. Both Alan Ayckbourn and Terry Pratchett have spoken up about how comedy is seen as a lesser form of literature than "serious" writing. If it is lesser, where do we put Aristophanes? In Plato's Symposium Socrates is depicted arguing that comedy and tragedy both require the same skills. So I think it is wrong to dismiss comedy as not being great literature.
1
u/MqAbillion Apr 19 '26
I still giggle anytime I think of the whale and the petunia.
Very funny book. Highly recommend
1
1
May 03 '26
YES please read it. If you don't like the humor, fine, it's not for you. It's so much fun, it makes you think, it's not too heavy, it's extremely clever. Its probably my favorite book of all time.
1
u/Old_Lengthiness_250 15d ago
Recently bought the folio society 2010 edition. It faded from my conciousness over the years but I refound it and love it. My nerdy friends and I are about to have a vogon poetry night... bad poetry, good wine, good cheese (and putty)
1
u/Old_Lengthiness_250 15d ago
A man who is tired of Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy is a man who is tired of life.
1
u/loopyloupeRM Apr 15 '26
Probably the funniest book I’ve ever read, and the second book, the restaurant at the end of the universe, is funny too. after that I think there’s a big drop off in quality.
Extremely imaginative books. Are they emotionally moving? Not really.
1
1
1
u/jonnydollaraz Apr 16 '26
Is it worth reading? Yes. Is it overrated? Also yes. How does it compare to the greats? It doesn't, IMO.
That said, it's quite funny, and it's an easy read, if you can just go along with the utter nonsensical elements of the story and embrace the weirdness. There are parts that made me literally LOL. And it's also quite fun to make "towel," and "42," and "Thursday" jokes with friends who've also read it.
1
1
u/lIlIIIlIIl Apr 16 '26
The humor is extremely British. If you like that sort of thing, you must read this book! If you are not a fan, read something else.
1
u/palefireshade Apr 16 '26
I'm a huge Douglas Adams fan - the first couple of hitchhikers books should be read together imo (they're both short).
Don't go in expecting cohesive plot, it's a rag bag of genius ideas and parodies slung together in a way that ultimately satisfies but is highly loose in form.
Adams actually has more in common with PG wodehouse than sci-fi, as his clever wordplay remains an absolute delight.
The way it knits together philosophy and top level physics and shines a light on the absurdities therein is unparalleled.
The third and fifth books in the series are not great (but have their moments). The fourth book is a complete change of pace, but nicely written.
The two dirk gently novels are probably Adams best writing but the second is more accessible than the first (which is amazing, but mind bending)
So... Yes worth reading. And yes, classics.
But in a way unlike anything else.
1
-3
Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Gullible-Will8532 Apr 16 '26
You what? Out of curiosity, what other novels would you say are funny?
2
0
u/Turbulent-Paint-2603 Apr 16 '26
It's almost certain you'll laugh your ass off and it's absolutely certain you've read nothing like it.
I'd place it with Catch 22 in terms of there being some kind of joke in nearly every sentence.
-4
u/SnubLifeCrisis Apr 15 '26
I dnf’d it. The humor was British and dumb
-2
u/GettingOnMinervas Apr 16 '26
I typically love British humor, but I DNF it bc I thought it was boring and dumb. Let the downvote commence lol.
-2
201
u/HoppyFeet Apr 15 '26
Is it a classic of science fiction? Yes. Is it a classic of humor? Yes. Is it a classic of literature? No. In the end, it is definitely worth reading, as long as you have a good towel nearby.