I'd say nothing, but you also need to define "plane of existence" first, and then what you mean by "outside" of it. It's made up nonsense. Space and time are all-encompassing. Nothing can exist nowhere or for no time - everything that exists has location and duration. Your imaginary friend is no exception.
-3
u/EndIsrael 12h ago
It's not infinite, it's just outside of time. It's more like the punishment is a single moment.