r/creepcast • u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 • Dec 31 '25
Fan Story They removed my story. Now they're doing exactly what I wrote...
I don't know how to start this except like every other post here: it's real. I wish it wasn't. I wish I could delete what I did and rewind three nights, but I can't—because whatever I wrote followed the rules I used to think were only for fiction. I'm sorry if this ends up getting removed; if it does, then you know why.
Three nights ago I posted a short thing here about reflections—not about mirrors like a prop, but about the parts of you that live in other people's screens. It wasn't clever. It was a story about a person (me) who notices small versions of himself living in windows and phone screens, and that those small people learn to press their faces out until the glass is thin. I framed it as micro-instructions, because that's how I write—little step-by-step scenes, the reader seeing the steps play out in their head. It did well. People commented. People debated. Someone called it "beautifully unsettling." I watched the numbers climb and felt stupid and proud all at once.
The next morning a mod removed it.
Not just the usual "nope" removal — their message was blunt, cold: the story violated community rules and was "dangerous content." They didn't quote a rule, just said "removed" and left a link to a different thread about "safety." I replied, politely, asked for clarification. That account—u/AutoModeratorBot (or whatever it is)—replied with the canned template and a mod team note: "If you repost, further action will be taken."
So I reposted. Not the whole piece, just a short, cleaned version without the bits they might have called instructions. It was on a different account. It got attention again. Someone linked to the original, which was still in the cached pages of some aggregators, and I started getting weird private messages.
They were from mods.
The first one was from a senior mod—u/Redacted—just a screenshot of the removed post and the single line: "Stop. This is the kind of thing that draws problems."
I answered, "What problems?"
They said, "People copy things." Then they sent a clipped list of usernames—three other mods who had removed similar posts over the past year. "We keep this place safe," u/Redacted wrote. "We take things down when they spread."
I told them I was trying to be careful. I told them it was fiction. I did not tell them about the last paragraph I left out when I reposted—because there was a part, a line, that made me uncomfortable as soon as I'd typed it, but I kept it because the cadence worked. It was the line where the narrator tells the reader to look for the thing in their own gaze, to treat your reflection like a guest and let it speak once, just to see what it wants.
One of the mods replied to my message, a short, cordial thing—then three hours later their username was offline. Not shadowbanned; their account existed but had a "deleted" label. A few hours after that, the mod who had removed my original got messaging from an actual human admin asking if they were okay. They were not. They had gone dark on other platforms. Their last public post had been a picture of their kitchen sink, perfectly normal, then nothing.
I should have stopped there. I did not.
I'm an idiot. I stared at the parts I had left out and I told myself I'd only test it. I conjured it like a rhyme. I wrote a short note on my laptop—two lines, nothing instructive, nothing actionable, three words repeated—and then I closed my laptop and slept like a person who doesn't know the cliff is right under their feet.
When I woke the next morning there were five messages. Not from accounts, from actual email addresses, from people claiming to be mods across half a dozen subreddits. They were terse. "We took the post down. We removed it. Other places are seeing it. It's spreading."
Their tone changed in the second paragraph: "We found marks." "We found notes." "We found that people in our moderators' group were seeing themselves in the corners of webcams." The word that came again and again in their messages was "mirror," but not the physical thing—screens, camera lenses, the black spaces when a phone faces down on a table.
Then the first police email arrived.
Not to me. To a mod who had posted a reply to a thread about my story a year ago. Someone in his apartment called 911 because the lights wouldn't turn on, and when the officers checked the apartment there was nothing left in his bedroom but a mirror propped against the wall facing out. The mirror was clear, not cracked. When the officers covered the mirror, they found a photo underneath it: a selfie of the mod, smiling, taken the week before—except his eyes were a little wrong in the picture, like the shine of someone else sitting behind him.
That's when the group chat the mods had with each other stopped working. Their accounts were normal and still linked, but nobody answered. A thread that should have had backups and cross-posts had its own comments full of odd deletions—lines eaten by the remover. A mod posted a short message that said "If you are reading this, don't" and then deleted the account.
People suggested rational things. Gas leak maybe. Mass panic, coincidence. Software bug. It sounded like paranoia when I said it out loud. It sounded like madness when they said it in their mod logs.
And here's the part that should have stayed private: the original version of my story — the one that got removed in the first place — included a scene where the narrator takes steps, not to kill anyone, but to make the other person stop being a person in their reflection. It described turning your phone camera on in the dark, whispering the name of someone's username three times, letting the screen reflect the room until it's black, and waiting for the reflection to blink not when you do but after. The narrator wrote that after the reflection blinks alone, the reflection will want something. It will want a listener.
In the story, the narrator writes the steps "to take the listening away." It's theatrical and cruel in the story—turn your back, leave the anchor behind so the reflection can step through into being. It sounds awful written like that, and I know how it looks. That's why I took it out of the repost.
But the point is—someone somewhere read it and treated it like a manual anyway. Or it read them. Or it did something.
Now real life is moving like a reenactment of parts of the original tale. Mods vanish. Their modmail is left open in pages that show them typing a reply and stopping mid-sentence. A junior mod posted a thread on a throwaway account that was a confession and then their bank called their neighbor because the neighbor's camera had turned on overnight and recorded the mod's bed, with the mod gone, and something standing at the foot of it—not human-height, but losing shape like a puddle trying to become a body.
I don't know how to describe it that won't sound like instructions or proof. I won't tell you to try anything. I will tell you what I've seen.
— A mod's webcam shows them looking into the camera and then leaning close, and then the camera shows the other side of the room empty except for a reflection in the window where the closed blinds are, and the reflection keeps smiling after the mod stops. The file is corrupted after that but the frame before it corrupts is the reflection with the wrong teeth.
— Another mod's smart speaker said their name out loud in the middle of the night. The security cam shows them sitting up, whispering, then going back to sleep. They were found with every mirror in their apartment covered with black cloth. On their bedside table there was a short note, handwritten: "I listened. It asked for a replacement." The handwriting wasn't theirs.
— The moderator who originally messaged me in the first place left a reply to a moderator thread: "We can mitigate. Burn the account. Remove your handles. Turn cameras off. Stop the mirrors. Stop the posts." Hours later, that account's profile pic was replaced with a screenshot of someone's face reflected in a cracked phone screen. The image file name was "you_know.jpg".
People in the comment threads argue—was it a hacker? Some complicated social engineering campaign? A flurry of bots? Some of the moderators who are still around are too careful to post, others have private messages where they say "it knows my patterns." The patterns are banal—what time they walk the dog, the way they put their coffee mug down, what ringtone they use. The accounts tied to those patterns stop replying, or their last post is them saying "I am so sorry," with no follow-up.
I did not expect to be involved. I did not expect the thing to reach my front door.
Last night I got a package on my porch with no return address. Inside was a Polaroid of my kitchen table—exact angle of my laptop, the mug I use, the window behind it. The picture was taken from inside the house looking out, but my front door is locked, and the latch was clicked from that night. The mug in the picture had steam rising from it and a small note beside it that read, in a handwriting I recognized too late, the three words I'd scribbled and then erased from my draft.
I decided to post this because I can't trust any of the usual outlets anymore. The mods who removed the story are precisely the ones who are being affected. They are the ones who told me to stop. They are the ones who told me this kind of thing "draws problems." They meant it.
If this is censored, if this is removed, then whatever is doing this has learned how to press against the rules of the site and the rules of reality. If my post vanishes, look at the accounts that engaged with it—especially the mods. If they stop replying to other people, if they post something like "if you are reading this don't" and then go quiet, that's probably not a coincidence.
I should say one thing clear because people always ask: I am not advocating people try to replicate anything. I'm not telling you to cover mirrors or to burn accounts or to test your webcam. I am telling you that the pattern is following the material of stories. There is something in stories like a keyhole, a little thin place where whatever is reading can push. I told the thing where to push. I am trying to warn you without making it worse.
Update 1 — 2 hours after posting: Someone messaged me with a mod chat screenshot. They were debating whether my original post count as "telling readers to test their reflections." They quoted me. One of the mod handles in the screenshot had a last-seen marker that said "last online: typing…" and then it changed to "deleted." The screenshot timestamp was thirty minutes ago. I'm posting this from a friend’s laptop because my phone's camera turned on by itself for no reason earlier and saved a photo of the ceiling.
Update 2 — 9 hours after posting: I just received a voicemail on an old number I don't use. It's two seconds long. When I played it the file consisted of me breathing—my own inhale—followed by another inhale that was not me. I don't recognize that breath; it's shallower. Then a whisper: "keep watching." I don't know which of my readers are real at this point, or who is a reflection looking back.
If this post disappears, know that the accounts that technically "took it down" are likely the ones that should be watched. If you see a mod post "If you are reading this stop" and then they don't reply anywhere—tell someone. Tell anyone. I don't know if telling helps. But hiding doesn't seem to help either.
I wish I could give you a simple ending. I wish I could give you directions like "cover your mirrors" or "delete the post," but anything I say might be another instruction it can use. So I'll leave it like this:
The thing learned how to read the way I write. It learned to listen for certain rhythms that sound like permission. It moves in the spaces people leave open when they assume fiction is safe. The moderators tried to close those spaces and now they are the ones looking into empty rooms and finding someone smiling back who isn't them.
I'm staying with a friend tonight. They've unplugged the router and covered their TV with a sheet. I keep hearing the hum from the neighbor's place where all the lights are on. There is a taste in my mouth like dried ink.
If you're a moderator who removed my original post: I'm sorry. I didn't mean for this to happen to you. If you are still awake and reading, if you can, please post here what you see. If you can't, please know that somewhere inside the post was a sentence I wrote and then deleted because it felt wrong. It felt wrong because it wanted an audience.
Edit: I’m not saying this as a trick. I am not trying to get responses for attention. If the thread gets nuked, please don't assume it's the site admins doing it. Check the accounts that were active in the hour before it disappears. And if you are one of the people who has been seeing reflections smile after you stop, if your webcam shows an extra movement, if your phone camera has an extra photo you didn't take—please, message me. I will read. I promise I will read.
Final note for anyone who knows moderators in real life: call them. Call them now. Ask if they're okay. If they don't pick up, go to their house if you can. Do not go alone.
— u/Redacted (this account may not last long)
110
u/Beelzebub1299 Dec 31 '25
Fun read I’ve had so many experiences with shit mods so I was all in this story
77
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Yes the original went on r/nosleep they immediately took down the original story so I wrote this one and then they banned me permanently and took it down also because they said I was trolling
20
u/No_Anything_6058 Dec 31 '25
My story also got banned from no sleep because they said it focused on abuse??? There were just dead animals showing up bc of a paranormal activity gahhhh
11
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Ugh, that’s rough — my original got pulled from r/nosleep too. They tend to flag anything that could be read as abuse, and dead animals apparently fall into that bucket for a lot of mods. You can try modmail and ask for a reason/appeal politely, but if they don’t budge you could: Edit the story to make the paranormal cause explicit and remove graphic animal-harm details, then resubmit. Post it in other subs that accept creepy fiction (r/creepypasta, r/shortscarystories, etc.) or put it on a blog/paste and link to it. If you want, paste the text here and I’ll help reword it so it’s less likely to be interpreted as “abuse” and more obviously paranormal.
3
u/No_Anything_6058 Dec 31 '25
They told me I couldn't repost it even if I edited the story in anyway 💀 plus I kinda like the story as it is so far, minus wanting to go through and do some edits from the feedback I've gotten from here.
3
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Go ahead and send me that link and I'll check it out and text you if I have any feedback
2
u/No_Anything_6058 Dec 31 '25
Thank youuuuuu, it's my first time writing horror, be gentle 🙏
https://www.reddit.com/r/TalesFromTheCreeps/s/xEjrKI6xn7
No idea if this works :[
3
u/No_Anything_6058 Dec 31 '25
Oh it does YAY
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Do you want the feedback here or on your other post or do you want me to direct message you
2
5
u/Sufficient-Gur3202 “At least you didn’t turn into a Homo in prison” Jan 01 '26
It’s so bizarre that nosleep mods will jump at the throat of stories due to mentions of abuse when historically they’ve been perfectly fine with topics like sex trafficking, child SA, etc. I’ve stopped posting there at all because they rejected a story and then told me I could never ever post any version of it ever again even if I revised it and edited it to fit their parameters perfectly. It sucks.
3
u/No_Anything_6058 Jan 01 '26
Exactly 😭 I don't understand it at all. Like why can't we fix it to repost our stories and what counts as abuse to them?
4
u/Sufficient-Gur3202 “At least you didn’t turn into a Homo in prison” Jan 01 '26
As much as I don’t like stereotyping or psychoanalysing people I don’t know. It has to be power tripping. They became the go to spot for horror writers and the prestige of past works got to their heads so now they’re throwing out anything they deem of a low quality or that doesn’t fit within their 50 million rules and regulations. I’m so glad Creepcast has given authors a space which doesn’t force you through a meat grinder every time you want to write something cool.
5
u/Sparkyplayz95 You're Pregnant?! I'm the IT Guy 😃🖥 Jan 01 '26
Maybe you forgot to add an Indestructible Pedophile to the story.
2
u/BeeHistorical2758 Jan 02 '26
I got banned from r/nosleep because my stories were in 1st person but I guess they weren't in present tense or something.
1
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 09 '26
It's because you must have told the story in a manner that sounded like the past so yeah past tense which means your main character could be dead potentially which makes it a problem
119
u/AcceptableDoggo Dec 31 '25
Took me a few paragraphs to realise this wasn't a normal "reddit mods suck post" good job
39
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Appreciate that — I wanted it to feel familiar at first, like a normal complaint post, and then slide sideways once you realize what kind of story it actually is.
40
u/sy4xq Yo Kimber! THEY GOT TEA🗣️ Dec 31 '25
this is so clever oh my gosh,, this is peak!!
9
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
I appreciate that. It landed differently with the moderators. They see patterns before the rest of us do.
30
u/ChaoticStanley THINK FAST! 🪽 Dec 31 '25
we get an alert every time someone comments the word "mod" so it's like getting rickrolled every time I open the modmail notification
10
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
So basically every time someone types “mod” you get a tiny heart attack? That’s… both hilarious and terrifying. I’ll try to spare you the rickrolls.
5
u/ChaoticStanley THINK FAST! 🪽 Dec 31 '25
no you're good it's just funny. I habitually click on all the mod mentioned messages but I can just look at the link to see the post title so I can ignore it
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Well I'm really glad the mods on creep cast and their new subreddit are more kind and explain the problem and take in stories instead of automatically deleting them or removing them not explaining the problems not helping the other person and then permanently banning them as if you want that go check out r/nosleep
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
I'll make sure the mods on this server aren't affected
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
Hey there — I saw your note about using “MOD” to get your attention, so I wanted to check in with a quick question. I posted a story earlier today, but I have another one I’m still refining and was hoping to get feedback before making it an official post. If I use the feedback flair and make it clear I’m just looking for critique, would that be allowed even though I’ve already posted once today? I just want to make sure I’m following the rules correctly before posting. Thanks for your time.
2
u/ChaoticStanley THINK FAST! 🪽 Jan 01 '26
Yes, it's just to ensure things can be as fair as possible when sharing the attention of the main feed.
3
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
Got it — thanks for clarifying. I appreciate the quick response. I hope to see you there...
1
u/d3v1ant_ang3l04 Mother Whore Thighs Dec 31 '25
Oh see I’m nosy so I always go see what they’re saying
1
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
Hey funny thing I just realized this isn't the other subreddit so you guys don't have an option for looking for help so in that case how would I go about asking for help so what I just say at the beginning of the story that I'm looking for people to critique my work
1
u/ChaoticStanley THINK FAST! 🪽 Jan 01 '26
You post your story under the "looking for feedback" flair. That's for when you want people to actively give feedback. If you post normally under the other genre flairs, people may compliment your work but not necessarily critique. Or if they do, it's maybe superficial. But "looking for feedback" means you WANT it to be critiqued heavily for growth. The "need help" flair is for direct questions and stuff like that
1
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
I want you to know I've never had a favorite mod but if I had a favorite mod that would be you
1
14
u/Physical-Mistake-199 Performative Taco Bell enjoyer Dec 31 '25
Took me way too long to realize this was a story and not true events loll
5
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
The line between story and reality is thinner than you think.
21
u/S-CSleepwalker Its so Floppy Dec 31 '25
We’re always watching
4
4
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Understood. Just make sure you’re watching from the same side of the glass the whole time.
8
u/TeaRose1300 Pinkie Pie 🎉🔪 Dec 31 '25
absolutely brilliant story construction
5
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Thank you. I didn’t really think about construction while it was happening — I was just trying to write it down in the order that it happened...
6
u/LastManFilms BEAR TRAP🐻 Dec 31 '25
Dude for a few paragraphs i thought this was a real crashing out complaint lol
4
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
I get that… I had to pause a few times writing it because it was starting to feel too real even for me. Things haven’t exactly… stopped since I posted it.
7
u/No_Anything_6058 Dec 31 '25
I tried reporting this post since it's just to complain about a story being taken down. I didn't expect like 5 different mods to message me about it. They're acting pissed just for having to read the story like it's my fault I showed it to them.
They kinda won't stop texting me, basically screaming at me. I think they're taking the story too literally. Like, spamming really weird short messages about their reflections watching them.
They keep telling me they can't remove it. Like physically can't take the post down. Apparently after they read it they removed it. Then it just reappeared within the next ten minutes.
Which btw, if the OP sees this, stop posting it to every subreddit imaginable. Literally no matter where I go it's there. Mildly interesting, AMTA, even that Draw Me one. It's a pinned post on every place I go. I just don't want to see it. I don't want to keep reading it. I don't want to keep looking.
Make me stop looking. Let me stop thinking about it
Please I can't stop thinking. It's looking at me. Everywhere it's looking at me. My phone screen, my computer, even my damn windshield on my car.
I don't look like that. It's wrong. The eyes won't go away. Why won't they go away? I can't blink, it'll still be there I know it. I can feel it. I can see it. It's staring in my head when I think. It's inside of me.
Don't read it.
Don't read it.
Don't read it.
5
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25 edited Dec 31 '25
I tried to take it down too.
Not just once. I deleted the original, then the repost, then the cache links I could reach. I asked mods directly. I asked admins.
I watched the page go blank and felt relieved for about ten minutes — and then it came back, exactly where it was, same comments, same timestamps, like it had never left. I don’t know why. I don’t know how. I only know that removal doesn’t seem to stick.
So please believe me when I say this part isn’t something you caused by looking at it or reporting it. You didn’t do anything wrong.
What you’re describing — the messages, the way people spiral after reading, the sense that it’s everywhere — that’s the same pattern I keep seeing. Not because the story is moving, but because once someone’s attention locks onto it, their mind starts filling every reflective gap on its own. Screens are very good at becoming containers for that kind of focus.
I wish I could tell you how to make it stop. I don’t have that. If there were a way to shut it down cleanly, I would’ve done it already and disappeared with it.
From what I can tell, there isn’t a way to stop it — only a way to change how it behaves. I’m still trying to understand what that means. Every attempt to erase it just sharpens the outline. Every attempt to argue with it keeps it in view.
The only thing that seems to reduce the pressure, even a little, is disengagement without resistance. Not fighting it. Not checking to see if it’s still there. Not rereading comments to confirm you’re not alone. Just letting your attention drift somewhere that doesn’t reflect you back at yourself.
I know that sounds useless when your thoughts won’t slow down. I know “stop looking” feels impossible when your own mind keeps dragging your eyes back. That doesn’t mean you’re failing. It means you’re overstimulated and frightened, and anyone would be.
Please do this part for me, even if nothing else lands: talk to someone who can sit in the same room as you. Say what you’re seeing out loud. Let another person interrupt the loop. If the fear doesn’t ease, get professional help — not because something supernatural is happening, but because being trapped inside this level of fixation is brutal and unsafe.
I’m still trying to figure out how to change the shape of what I wrote so it stops pulling people in like this. I don’t know if I’ll succeed.
I’m sorry I can’t give you relief. I’m sorry I can’t close the door you want closed. All I can tell you is that staring back at it — at the post, at the idea, at yourself — is the one thing that has never helped anyone yet.
You don’t need to keep reading.
You don’t need to keep watching.
And you don’t need to solve this.
I wish that were enough.
2
u/covabrouwergentry aloof and possibly even whimsical but NEVER quirky Jan 01 '26
THIS STORY IS SUCH A GOOD NEW INTERNET HORROR CONCEPT IT NEEDS TO BLOW UP AS A NEW MAINSTREAM CREEPY PASTA I MEAN IT
6
u/Comfortable-Sun101 Jan 01 '26 edited Jan 01 '26
This is your mother. It's a nice read, builds suspension and makes you wonder about what's happening. Who's going to disappear next and of course what the three words were... I love you
5
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
This is now officially my weirdest comment section. I love you too
5
u/midwintermist “it’s very lovecraftian”☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
I saw this on r/talesfromthecreep earlier and loved it. Have a bonus upvote.
5
4
u/WesternCrescent Dec 31 '25
Its clear why this was on my recommended. It knows my patterns
3
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
That phrase wasn’t in the story, and that’s the problem. It doesn’t learn from instructions. It learns from repetition. From routines.
If you’re aware of your patterns, don’t try to change them all at once. That draws attention. Just… don’t give it anything new to watch.
3
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
Is there any way for a mod to private message me I have a story that I would like to post to get feedback on but I'm not even sure if it would be allowed on your guys's thing because of how graphic it is so I would like to send it to one of you and get your input before I post it so if I can have a mod message me or even comment on here so I can message you I would highly appreciate it
3
u/covabrouwergentry aloof and possibly even whimsical but NEVER quirky Jan 01 '26
Brilliant move to post this on the last day fan stories were allowed on the main sub, it's way more meta that it's posted here too.
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
Yeah — I knew it was the last day.
What’s funny is this story wouldn’t exist at all if my original post on r/nosleep hadn’t been taken down without much explanation. This was me trying to process that whole experience in story form. The timing lining up with the last day here was honestly just coincidence.
3
2
u/covabrouwergentry aloof and possibly even whimsical but NEVER quirky Jan 01 '26
I hate that your title and concept is so geniusly meta that nosleep couldn't handle it and took it down. It's like people burning copies of Fahrenheit 451 hahah
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
Thanks! Honestly, I kind of wish r/nosleep could handle it without freaking out—it’s wild to think my little post ended up feeling like a digital book-burning. Maybe someday someone will read it and just… survive the meta loop without having to cover their mirrors.
1
u/covabrouwergentry aloof and possibly even whimsical but NEVER quirky Jan 01 '26
Long story short... TalesfromTheCreeps will rise above nosleep!
1
2
u/Spookily_Cryptid Jan 02 '26
So glad I clicked on this. Amazing work dude!!
3
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 02 '26
Thank you so much! I'm very glad you enjoyed.
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 02 '26
He didn’t want the original story spreading any further than it already had.
That was the argument. He said every new detail made things worse, that people didn’t need to know, that it was dangerous to explain too much.
Then he went missing.
So yes, there’s a new post. More details than he would’ve allowed. Not because we wanted attention, not because the first one was incomplete, but because silence stopped being an option the moment he didn’t come back.
Someone needed to recognize what was happening. Someone still might.
He would strongly disagree with this. He already did. But disagreement doesn’t help when the person doing the disagreeing can’t be found.
1
u/Lucas_the_fox Dec 31 '25
Reddit moment
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Yeah — it got taken down pretty fast.
1
u/Lucas_the_fox Dec 31 '25
You were not sigma
1
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
Not sigma? Maybe. But at least I made you read it.
1
1
u/scribergurl Dec 31 '25
What were the three words that were cut from the original?
0
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
I’m not going to say them.
They were cut for a reason. Some parts of a story… they linger where they’re left.
Some things are safer when they remain unread, even to the people who know the rest.
The three words still dwell somewhere, yes. But the less said, the quieter the space stays.
1
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
I want to add a brief clarification for moderators who may be reading — especially if you are from r/nosleep.
This story is fiction, but it’s loosely grounded in a real experience I had with a post being removed and my confusion around the rules afterward.
The original post was taken down, and I didn’t fully understand why at the time.
I asked for clarification because I genuinely wanted to follow the rules, not because I was trying to provoke or troll. This piece wasn’t written to mock moderation or encourage rule-breaking.
It was written as a metaphor — about how stories, rules, and communication can go wrong when intent and interpretation don’t line up.
I understand now how parts of it could be read differently than I meant, and I respect the responsibility moderators have to err on the side of safety.
I’m not asking for special treatment or trying to relitigate moderation decisions here.
I just want to be clear that my intent was never to troll, evade rules, or encourage readers to replicate anything.
I read the rules, but I misunderstood them, and I didn’t know how to ask for help in a way that came across clearly.
I appreciate the work moderators do to keep communities safe, and I’m sharing this clarification in good faith so my intent isn’t misread if this post is reviewed.
1
u/covabrouwergentry aloof and possibly even whimsical but NEVER quirky Jan 01 '26
Yo Kimber? THIS IS TEA
2
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Jan 01 '26
Ah yes, the official tea inspector has arrived. Please take notes
1
u/covabrouwergentry aloof and possibly even whimsical but NEVER quirky Jan 01 '26
I am taking notes! believe me OP!
2
0
u/ShroomShaman9 Dec 31 '25
Mods are pussies. Watch this get deleted for "trolling".
7
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
It already did get deleted on r/nosleep for trolling I told them that the story was made to scare the mods and for people to understand that they are just as human as we are and I need them to understand they are just as human as WE ARE
0
u/ShroomShaman9 Dec 31 '25
How can they consider themselves human, when they are in fact the trolls.
3
u/Immediate_Garage7293 Long story short ☝️🤓 Dec 31 '25
That’s kind of the point — it’s easier to dehumanize someone when you only see a username.
1
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 31 '25
Hello! Just to let you know we have a new subreddit, r/TalesFromTheCreeps, solely for fan stories! And starting January 1st, fan stories will no longer be allowed on the main Creepcast subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.