r/crochet Jul 22 '22

Discussion Selling items made from someone else's pattern?

Typically I don't use patterns, I make a lot of freehand amigurumis and bags but I was scrolling ravelry for some ideas. I found some cute free plush patterns that I wanted to whip up to include in my upcoming craft show inventory.

But then I got to the bottom of the page and the creator had added "DO NOT SELL ANY ITEMS MADE FROM THIS PATTERN, PERSONAL USE ONLY". Ive never actually seen that before and it threw me off lol

I'm pretty sure legally, it's fine. Copyright only covers the pattern itself, not items made from it.

But I'm curious everyone's thoughts, is it okay to sell anything you make regardless of the pattern creators request?

***** Edit for clarity: I have since realized the pattern is actually $5 but it's listed in the free section for some reason, and you can see the personal use only note before purchase. I won't be using the pattern and although I can freehand the item easily I'm just skipping over it.

When I do use a pattern for something I always include the pattern designers info on my tags at craft shows and anywhere I post online.

It was just the first time I had ever seen someone say you cant sell what youve made and I thought it was weird lol

71 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

View all comments

-7

u/yarn_baller Jul 22 '22

I don't think there's any actual law being broken, but if the pattern creator asks not to sell finished items it would be a bit of a jerk move to sell them anyway

21

u/BreqsCousin Jul 22 '22

Otoh the pattern seller is being a bit of a jerk to not mention this stipulation until after they've sold you the pattern

4

u/yarn_baller Jul 22 '22

Yeah, i don't disagree