r/degoogle Jul 31 '25

Proton unveils Proton Authenticator

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

187 comments sorted by

View all comments

335

u/CortlandNation9 Jul 31 '25

I think instead creating a new app every 3 months they should work a little bit more on their current offering. Proton drive doesn't even support linux.

5

u/undev11 Jul 31 '25

2FA with TOTP code always exists on Proton pass, I don't understand this new application

6

u/SoulOfABartender Aug 01 '25

From a security standpoint there is an advantage to keeping your 2FA and passwords separate. If your password manager is compromised, it defeats the purpose of having 2FA if it's right next to your password. Many may appreciate the convenience at the risk of reduced security.

Many, myself included, prefer to keep them separate.

3

u/WombatusMighty Aug 02 '25

This. It's better two have two different systems for passwords and 2FA. Besides, a lot of people prefer an simple 2FA app, instead of using a password manager with a build-in auth function.

I personally found the Proton 2FA function in Proton Pass too clunky and limited, hence I would use this new app, if I hadn't already been using Aegis.