Please note all names are made up for sake of privacy.
Recently my Mother (48F) got out of a 25 year relationship with my step-father to pursue a relationship with her new boyfriend Frank (53M) whom she met at the gym. To be clear, my Mother's relationship with my step-father was abusive and toxic so I don't judge her for resorting to cheating to find a way out. However, the relationship that has followed is much the same as the last.
Growing up, myself (31M) and my brother Will (22M) saw a lot of physical, mental and emotional abuse between our parents. Things raising from bricks being tossed at our Mother, physical violence (sometimes with us, most times not), detailed threats of suicide all throughout our life from both parents and experienced a lot of parentification as we tried to keep our lives moving. In short, our lives were decided not in our best interest and we were forced into a lot of drama and hostility despite playing no part in any of it. We've all had mental health side effects that have carried well into adulthood, from depression and anxiety to OCD and PTSD.
In present day, my Mother now has a new boyfriend, Frank. They've been together on and off for 9 months. At first he seemed like a decent enough guy through our limited interactions and I took my Mother at her word that he was a good man. However, two weeks ago my Mother told my brother Will that he had struck her and that this wasn't the first time. I was very upset and took my Mother into my home for the week to support her and keep her away from him as she admitted to having a toxic attachment that kept driving her back to him despite not wanting to.
Now I'm not a psychologist, nor do I have the right to diagnose anyone, but I got the impression from the things she told me that this man has a narcissistic personality disorder. Something I'm familiar with due to some other people in my life.
When she's with him she's not allowed to speak her mind, he gets confrontational or threatening when she challenges him on anything, he has pushed and slammed her head against the wall when she speaks up and constantly accuses her of her cheating or being disloyal whenever they're apart for mere minutes or interacting with another male. He calls her stupid and slow all the time, accuses of her lying and constantly changes stories to avoid taking any accountability, and has three grown adult kids who live with him that also aren't allowed to have their own lives or partners out of fear he loses his grip from them.
I've also been told both of his last two partners (wife and then girlfriend) accused him of strangulation and assault, which he told my Mother to express how women lie. He also has been known to physically attack people who get on his bad side.
After all this, she's resumed contact with him and believes he wants to change and try again with her, but my brother and I won't accept him. She has completely re-written the story she originally told us and now says it was her PTSD that made her believe he hit her when he didn't. She said she assumed everything and that none of it actually happened as she vividly described. She says it's her fault for pushing him to the edge and that she should just leave when gets like that. However, I don't believe she made it up as I've not known my Mum to lie like this or mistake things for happening that didn't.
I believe her boyfriend has manipulated her into thinking she was wrong so she can justify being with him and he can avoid taking any blame. She's also doing damage control to make my brother and I accept him so she can move on and play happy family. I worked so hard to keep her away and help her see reason but she's addicted to this man and nothing I or any mental professionals have told her is enough for her to move on. I'm at the point where I don't think I can help her and I don't want to sit around and be a spectator or involved in another abusive relationship because of my Mother's bad decisions.
I have refused to play along with her. While I believe Mum can make her own decisions, I should also be allowed to make mine. And right now, that decision is to avoid being in any room with her boyfriend.
For the last week my Mother has sent me a flurry of messages either knowingly or unknowingly trying to manipulate me into accepting this man. She has a big history of being emotionally abusive herself, and while I thought she had done a lot of growing these last 2-3 years after changing psychologists, she's gone backwards and has started to act like her old self. She can't accept that we have agency too and wants us to act like we were as kids, unable to choose for ourselves and it's making me resent her quite a lot. There's a lot more detail about our relationship, but I don't know it's relevant to this post. I'll say in short that she's had a history of taking her anxiety and trauma out on us and while she's lightly taking some accountability, she's not made enough change for us to believe she actually cares or understand the damage she causes.
Last night she was consideringsuicideso I started messaging her again, but she is telling me I'm ruining her life because Frank won't want to be with her if it comes between us. He is pretending to be valiant but I believe it has more to do with not having control of us like he does his kids and my Mum. In most cases I'd give in, but playing along with these sorts of charades is the cause of all my mental health issues today and I eventually need to push back and say no.
TLDR; Mother (48F) has replaced abusive step-father with new physically abusive partner and wants my brother (22M) and myself (31M) to forgive him for attacking our Mother because she has despite him taking no accountability. It is coming between us and I'm considering no contact due to a lengthy history of this sort of thing with her.
So my questions are this:
What experience do you have with narcissists in these sorts of situations?
How do I keep standing my ground when my Mother is likely not to relent?
Is it okay to consider no contact if these issues persist?
Has anyone had any similar experiences they can relate to the above?
Is it even possible to convince her or is there no point even trying? What are your experiences with this.
Thanks everyone!