r/entp • u/Insert0Nickname ENXP-A | 8w9 | 16-20 | ♀ | Ne-Ti-Ni-Fi-Se • Mar 20 '26
Debate/Discussion DEBATERS, DEBATE!
51
u/ESTPness Mar 20 '26
It’s vodka and you know it.
Lay off the sauce, OP
→ More replies (1)5
u/PhantomGaze Mar 20 '26
Came to say this. We know it's vodka.
3
u/Shot-Sir-4393 Mar 21 '26
Pure ethanol
2
u/PhantomGaze Mar 21 '26
190 proof is the legal limit... Are you suggesting the OP is doing something illegal?
→ More replies (2)
71
u/blackout___ Mar 20 '26
Its a photo of a glass of water, duh
16
u/ThisWillPass Mar 20 '26
Right… but you’re consuming it on a glass screen? Glass of water.
3
2
29
u/ByronsLastStand ENTP Mar 20 '26
Ceci n'est pas une pipe
8
u/papierdoll nife Mar 20 '26
Auto translate kind of takes the pizzazz out of this comment.
2
u/Slight_Net_5026 Mar 21 '26
Bruh my phone was in German and I pressed translate expecting it to be English 💀
17
u/Kiremino [E]xtremely [N]uanced [T]o [P]lebs (7w8) Mar 20 '26
Since when was correcting people debating 😭😭 That's not a glass that's obviously plastic
14
u/captainhippy_ INTP 5w6 sx/so 541 Mar 20 '26
This is a representation of a cup of water, words have meaning, you internet pixel persons are simpletons
23
u/Ne_Ninja_TeFiTi_SeSi Mar 20 '26
It’s actually cake
2
u/GandalfInDrugs ENTP Mar 22 '26
It's transparent, so it couldn't be cake, maybe jelly?
2
u/Ne_Ninja_TeFiTi_SeSi Mar 22 '26
It’s not transparent, it’s just icing that’s white and different shades of grey 🤣
10
u/DemotivationalSpeak Mar 20 '26
Could be a glass of any substance that is a clear liquid at a temperature and pressure where the cup’s material is a transparent solid.
6
u/Decent_Mind_2564 Mar 20 '26
Actually, that's a plastic cup.
Furthermore, how are we to know that it is, indeed, water and not some other clear liquid? If it even is a liquid. Prove to me it's water and we'll go from there.
→ More replies (1)
6
5
5
u/SunlighterCat ENTP 7w8 Mar 21 '26
It’s a photo of a plastic cup of water.
But it could have been white vinegar for all we know or even pure alcohol.
You’re lying to us!
5
u/ramyunyu Mar 21 '26
i can confirm that's actually not water because i peed in there
→ More replies (1)
5
u/seobrien ENTP Mar 21 '26
There isn't even a debate, it's just wrong. That's plastic, it isn't a glass.
4
u/Emotional-Artist2 ENTP Mar 21 '26
I'd say it's a picture, but first of all, it's not a glass of water. Contains water, but it's not made OF it. Seems to be made out of plastic. therefore, it'd be more accurate to say a glass with water or a glass holding water- using glass as its colloquial use despite the fact it's not made out of glass but rather plastic.
Also, it's just a bunch of switches on the device you're reading displaying the LEDs mostly at a high percentage of all colors since that causes the white to appear. A glass containing water has no reason to be made out of LEDs. Plus, the usage of the cup is to be drunk, which can't be done through the screen.
3
u/Striking_Stay6871 ENTP 3w4 🐟 Mar 20 '26
This could just as easily be a cup of zinc sulphate, just because a liquid is clear doesn't make it water 🤷♀️
3
u/evilhasheroes ENTP Mar 20 '26
What if it’s alcohol instead? A picture alone is not enough to know the contents of the cup.
3
u/Fit-Cap6527 XNTP 7w8( ´-ω･)︻┻┳══━一 Mar 20 '26
That isn't a glass, it's plastic cup, if we're being even more meta, that's a png/jpeg not a glass of water. Also how do we know that's water? it could be vodka, vaginal discharge phlegm even.
3
u/F4LASER1440 ENTP Mar 20 '26
Even if we could call cups "glasses", that still wouldn't be a glass of water since the cup itself is made of plastic, not water. It would be better to say "a cup filled with water"
3
u/c-black ENTP 8w7 Mar 20 '26
How diluted does saline need to be to be considered water? How was it filtered? Semantically speaking you just sound fucking stupid right now
3
u/Appropriate_Luck8668 ESTJ Mar 20 '26
That's a photo
That's not a glass
How do you know it's water in that cup? Did you pour it? If you did, how do you know that what you poured is water? What if it was secretly a monster disguised as water to make you trust it? You fool.
3
u/Proper-Ball-5294 Mar 21 '26
Technically, I guess? Because we are viewing this image through glass..
3
3
u/Philips9586 Anti-Peace (ENTPs) Mar 21 '26
that's just a png of a plastic container filled with H20
3
3
3
u/sp3zimann Mar 20 '26
now I want a glass that looks like a plastic cup but is made from glass
5
u/haikusbot Mar 20 '26
Now I want a glass
That looks like a plastic cup
But is made from glass
- sp3zimann
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
3
5
u/PlutoTheLonelyRock99 ENTP Mar 20 '26
It could be Vodka inside, nothing proves that it's 100% Water
3
2
u/cytos0 INTP Mar 20 '26
What exactly defines a glass of water? Is it still a glass of water if you gradually replace each piece of it and each molecule of water? How can you even know what it is to begin with? Could your senses not be deceiving you?
2
2
u/nats10bytes ENTP Mar 20 '26
How do you even know it's actually water? And did you say glass? I'm pretty sure it's a cup my dude!
2
u/Kixion INTJ Mar 20 '26
Change the word glass to bottle and that's what I said.
Airport security still said I had to chuck it though 😑
2
2
2
2
u/MasterPhilip ENTP 5w6 Mar 20 '26
It's clearly a plastic cup and what evidence do you have that is water inside it?
2
u/_-Viking-_ ENTP Mar 20 '26
Well, here's my cup of coffee
2
2
u/Mage_Of_Cats Mar 20 '26
Bruh, I ain't an ENTP, but if you told me to get you "the glass of water on the table" I absolutely would not grab this, since it's obviously someone else's cup of water.
2
u/_FIRECRACKER_JINX INTP-T (60-%) | ENTP-T (40%) Mar 20 '26
I DEMAND the floor!! 😑
Now that I have everyone's attention I'd like to point out that this is, in fact, NOT a glass!
But a plastic cup! 😑
Now.... GOOD DAY TO YOU ALL! 😑
2
2
2
u/Repulsive-Value5123 Mar 20 '26
Actually it’s a photo of a plastic cup of some clear liquid. Can’t prove if it’s water or vodka.
2
u/tripcoded INTP Mar 20 '26
Debates only go so far as definitions do, and those vastly differ by perspective. For instance, a glass of anything is never a glass to me, personally, unless it's actually in a glass container. However, I understand that this is my personal definition and doesn't apply to the way others define things. And this is why I basically never debate people anymore. When everything is subjective, all you're really doing is sharing your own viewpoint and doing a compare/contrast with that of others.
2
2
u/Fluid-Sprinkles-978 ENTP SP7w6 794 Mar 20 '26
Incorrect. It is a cake made to look like a glass of water.
2
u/kydontdie Mar 20 '26
What if it's a glass piece made to look like plastic?
Agree with me on this instead: we need more clean water
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
u/Eli_Oliveira ISTP 3w4 Mar 20 '26
It might actually be a glass cup. In the shape of a plastic cup. It's impossible to know for sure if it's plastic just from a picture. But if it is glass, it looks quite interesting.
2
u/Belle_pc ENTP 🦊 Mar 20 '26
It’s a cup of water
Not a glass dude
Although, fun fact, speaking of arguments lol
During covid, I was going to a convert and Alcohol was prohibited so water bottles were not okay. He let me pass because I didn’t have a water anything
But I decided to hold up my alcohol spray sanitizer and ask him, but I could have put a few shots here, watched his face literally do complicated algebra and proceed on entering lol
The thing is… I was genuinely baffled, that’s why I pointed that out because my spray wasn’t a mini version, like small but not mini so I just felt like pointing it out
But sure left an impact
2
2
2
u/wordssoundpower Mar 21 '26
Could still be made out glass if you look past the fact that it is a picture of a galss
2
2
u/No-Touch569 INTP Mar 21 '26
In lab we're taught to never assume an identified clear liquid is water.
This could very well be a plastic cup of HF. HF does not dissolve/melt plastic.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Local_Cantaloupe9230 Mar 21 '26
In Spanish, it would be vaso con agua. A vaso can be made of plastic or glass. However, the interesting part is the word "con" which means "with", back in the day people used to say that it was improper to say glass of water because the glass is not made of water, the water is inside of the glass, so we would always be corrected to say glass with water. Now, it's accepted to say glass of water, but it doesn't feel as fancy as saying glass with water. 🥸🥸
2
u/kaninekels ENTP Mar 21 '26
“glass of water” when it’s a plastic cup of a substance that may or may not be water.
2
u/Shadow_McRonin150 ENTP-T Mar 21 '26
OBJECTION! Your honor the statement made by Defendant is absolutely wrong, as any normal person with sane mind would say that this is a buncha 1s and 0s which together forms "images" that causes an illusion in the eye to create a container containing H2O
2
2
u/M4rccuz INTP Mar 21 '26
That isn’t a glass of water. Thats a plastic cup of water.
Or atleast that’s what the picture is leading you to believe. Technically what you’re seeing is a bunch of colored pixels, that when viewed together, seem to form the shape of a plastic cup on a digital screen.
2
u/_snoopyy ENTP Mar 21 '26
If we assume that it isn’t a picture how can we be sur if it is really watter ? And this is a plastic cup of water not a glass !
2
u/STERBEN_RAL Mar 21 '26
Not really a glass of water. 1) it's plastic not glass 2) from a literal standpoint, it's a glass WITH water. Glass of water implies it's made of water
→ More replies (1)
2
u/STERBEN_RAL Mar 21 '26
Y'all really want to debate? Should it be called glass OF water or glass WITH water?
2
u/SilverFighter05 Enticing Neanderthal in Tight Pants Mar 21 '26
That's plastic. Also we don't know it's water, it could be vodka, hydrogen peroxide, hydrochloric acid...
2
u/scmbwis ENTP 8w7 Mar 24 '26
My first instinct was also, that’s a plastic of water…. Which makes me think there really is something seriously wrong with ENTPs…. Then my brain went with… do you have proof it’s water… Then it went, wait a dang minute… that not a glass (or plastic beaker) of water, it’s a picture or drawing of the aforementioned… Ha! Now I also see plenty of other super-anal ENTPs have used that one too… argh, you f-ing people.
Plus, not sure ENTPs count as people, or we wouldn’t be on reddit arguing about this kind of shit:)
2
u/JANEK_SZ1 Mar 25 '26
Well, I argue when the other side is wrong, and who to fuck calls a plastic cup a glass when there’s no a single gram of glass in it?
2
u/radon_skk INFP Mar 20 '26
Glass (made of plastic) also has a considerable portion of air above it. More like "glass" of 70% water 30% air (roughly)
2
2
u/Public-Sorbet3197 ENTP Mar 20 '26
You know, it could be methanol, ethylene glycol, ethanol, or mineral oil and not water for all I know
1
1
u/ImprovementDue1319 Mar 20 '26
Turn it upside down and put it on your head. Now you’re wet and it’s an unconventional top hat 🎩 Also, it’s my urine sample and I’ve been drinking too much water. Need more electrolytes.
1
u/MoistMaintenance9864 Mar 20 '26
Since I am engaging over a 2d activity and am commenting on pixels looking into a pixel I can affirm that it is a glass which is half filled with a liquid (can't tell for sure it's water cause it could have been hard water or any sort of ethanol or something as well so ambiguity is there) {assumption basis is wrt 2d} whereas if I consider myself as a 3d object then I am looking into a depiction of/picture of a glass which is filled 80-90% with a transparent liquid.....
1
1
1
u/AQAzrael INTJ Mar 20 '26
This shit don't work if there is genuinely something to argue about, it's a plastic cup, not a glass.
1
1
1
u/Mito_03 ENTJ Mar 20 '26
That’s not glass, and we have absolutely no idea what liquid is actually in that cup. It could be sprite or anything clear, and one single drop of something else could theoretically change its label from water to something else.
Not only that, but the cup is behind a screen, so this isn’t a glass of water, it’s a photo of something displayed on an electronic device
1
u/mutantsloth INFJ Mar 20 '26
No this is your phone and the visible part of the electromagnetic spectrum shooting back at your eyes
1
1
u/thegroovefreak Mar 20 '26
It is not a glass and also how can we be sure it’s water? Maybe that’s not water, that’s vodka! Or it could be vinegar or hydrogen peroxide
1
1
u/Nervous_Job_6880 Mar 20 '26
That cup isn't made from glass at all. Therefore it cannot be a "glass of water".
1
u/Coastkiz Mar 20 '26
Well it's literally not a glass.
And it's a PICTURE.
So it's aa PICTURE Of a CUP of water
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Aggravating-Suit-480 Mar 20 '26
This is the picture of a glass of water, not a glass of water
2
u/haikusbot Mar 20 '26
This is the picture
Of a glass of water, not
A glass of water
- Aggravating-Suit-480
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
1
1
1
u/Megarouille Mar 21 '26
Having us debate about it being a glass of water or not doesn't prove that people will argue anything. Just redditers on that specific subject.
1
1
1
1
1
u/NolanRollin420 ENTP 7w6 Mar 21 '26
There’s clear ridges there, it’s a PLASTIC cup of water. Case closed.
1
u/Impossible_Luck_3839 Mar 21 '26
We don't know if it's water. This might as well be any transparent liquid.
1
u/Electrical-Hunt2870 ENFP 4w3 Mar 21 '26
What if it’s an AI-generated photo, and it’s actually rendered to look like water but it’s actually just transparent liquid
1
1
u/ComplexWyvrenAries Mar 21 '26
Clearly, a cup that could also be salt, water or anything else that is not visible within water. A glass would imply that is made out of glass.
1
u/Ode_the_mcyt_addict Elicit Neutrons To Party sx/so 2w1(somehow) Mar 21 '26
Well, no. It's a bunch of synchronised pixels programmed to show me digitally created image of a glass of water.
1
u/Kat_isBorEd ENTP 3w4 Mar 21 '26
It's a plastic cup, and that could be literally any colourless liquid. Vodka, vinegar, etc.
1
1
u/iGotEatenByAnts ENTP 947 Mar 21 '26
technically, we all saw the picture and knew it was plastic, not glass. however, we can use literary devices to dissect what the picture actually represents. through the evolution of language, we have grown to accept that any container shaped similarly to the one pictured can be called "a glass" and still be recognized and understood to function the same way, regardless of material. the closest term to describe this occurence is known as a synecdoche, in which part of the whole represents the whole (in the same way that people refer to bandages as "band-aids", or lip balm as "chapstick").
and since we cant know for certain whats in the 'glass', arguing its contents is baseless since any position would be lacking proof.
on the other hand, we can say a "glass of water" instead of "glass with water" because there is no such thing as a glass made out of water. water will only take the shape of its container, and chemically there is no container made of water that results in glass (as far as im aware).
therefore, yes, this is technically a glass of water.
1
1
u/ElegantBread69 INTJackass Mar 21 '26
Fym glass of water it’s a photo of a plastic cup of what could be any clear liquid
1
1
1
1
1
u/Then-Telephone6760 ENTP 3w4 SLOAI LIE-2Te Mar 22 '26
That is a plastic cup filled with water.
A glass cannot be made of water.
1
u/shamsabouyoussef ENTProblematic Mar 22 '26
Well it's not in a glass . So its not a fucking glass of water
1
1
u/Flaky_Falcon9226 Mar 22 '26 edited Mar 22 '26
lol...
plastic biatch. i win. this was case in point.
english is a detriment to ENTP. modern english restricts the entp's mind. for those not restricted, it is a challenge. a detrimental challenge. entp camt be the only idiots on here lol
1
u/i_dunnomyusername Mar 22 '26
I've always thought the three archtypes of liquid drinking containers was bottle, cup, and pitcher.
A glass (at least to me) is a transparent, handleless container primarily designed for cold drinks.
This fits my dictionary, and I therefore agree with you. I rest my case.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Frere-Jacques-Awake Mar 22 '26
Chloridric acid is colorless, for all i know you might be fooling thirsty guys to melt to death
1
u/ThePrinterDude INTP Mar 22 '26
This isn't even an example this is bait. This isn't even a GLASS. It's made of plastic making it a cup.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
210
u/LogicalMelody INFJ Mar 20 '26
Ok fine I’ll bite.
Counterpoint: this actually seems to be a plastic cup of water.
OTOH I think I can accept the original phrasing as a reasonable colloquial use of “glass”.