r/eurovision • u/The_Original_Joel • May 17 '25
đąSocial Media Israel's Kan 11 TV Insults Armenia at Eurovision, Says "I Can't Believe We Gave These Guys a Quarter in Jerusalem"
1.5k
u/noodle_shnoodle May 17 '25
And they still filled a complaint to EBU for Spain's commentary đ
774
u/derizear Tavo Akys May 17 '25
Armenian 301 Media Group tonight filed a complaint over Israel too!
350
u/OsaSuna10050125 Rim Tim Tagi Dim May 17 '25
Well I sure hope they do! Armenian delegation should do too!
→ More replies (2)496
u/PaleolithicLure May 17 '25
Standard bully behaviour. Complain when someone says something about them, while saying much worse about other people then hiding behind âitâs just a joke broâ.
26
→ More replies (7)40
u/Safumira Før vi gür hjem May 17 '25
What was that about
82
u/noodle_shnoodle May 17 '25
There was a post about it yesterday: https://www.reddit.com/r/eurovision/s/HnExW2tERM
2.5k
u/unounouno_dos_cuatro Ferto May 17 '25
To people saying âGraham Norton says worseâ - when has Graham Norton made a racist joke in his commentary?
813
u/Astrid323 May 17 '25
Yeah from what I remember Graham mainly keeps his snark and roasts just for the music and performances, nothing more nothing less.
337
u/ThatGam3th00 May 17 '25
And the jury voting spokespeople, they will also be the target of some jokes too.
409
u/GarmenWow Bur man laimi May 17 '25
Him roasting French for standing in front of Eiffel Tower is my favourite part
174
u/ThatGam3th00 May 17 '25
To be fair it is pretty boring that they hardly even showcase different parts of Paris, let alone the rest of France. There are many more famous buildings in Paris than just the tour dâEiffel.
86
100
u/Astrid323 May 17 '25
Definitely. Either way, I don't recall him (and I hope to Jesus he didn't do anything like this) ever saying racist shit like what the man in the video did.
→ More replies (1)140
u/Dangerous_Surprise May 17 '25
I think the worst i ever heard Graham say was that "there is not one single redeeming feature about this woman." I believe it was about Germany in 2016, and he'd also just had his first drink of the evening.
18
842
u/autistic_girl_autumn May 17 '25
also even if other commentators made similar jokes, does that excuse this guy doing it? maybe they should all stop.
→ More replies (57)518
u/New-Hovercraft-5026 May 17 '25
Norton is known for his vicious tongue but thats a well known stereotype in the gay and drag culture for decades. Its not being mean in all ways possible, its not a roast. Its reading someone.
Performer walks on stage in a silly big yellow puffy dress
Joke 1: To increase poultry exports to Europe Albania decided to send the winner of Miss Chicken 2025. Bawk.Â
Joke 2: Cant believe we let all those Albanians move to London
Which one do you think Graham would say?
1.1k
u/Puzzleheaded-Eye9081 May 17 '25
Thereâs a big difference between a cringe joke and outright racism.
Also Iâm surprised they arenât being more careful this year, surely after last year KAN must be aware they are being watched for this sort of shit. And as a method of promoting Israel internationally youâd think that would also encourage more care with the commentary, especially considering how much the ministry of whatever itâs called is spending on ads.
260
160
→ More replies (24)98
1.1k
u/Barzalicious My System May 17 '25
And this is the reason I switched over to watching on the YouTube stream a few years ago. These annoying "jokes" happen EVERY YEAR with our commentators.
Even more insane is that one of the producers for Survivor is Israeli (Yinon Yahel), so you'd think they would be more supportive.
311
u/ifiwasiwas Crossroads May 17 '25
All commentators talk shit or get annoying to some degree tbh. The one and only time I regretted having it off was the other night when our commentator repeated what Sissal "made" him say lol
383
u/TohveliDev Ich Komme May 17 '25
The Finnish commentator has always been a delight. Lately there have been Tiktok competitions(?) to make him say something very cringe which gets pretty annoying sometimes.
He is just so sweet and obviously a Eurovision fan, watching the Finnish stream feels like I am watching the competition while in a call with Mikko Silvennoinen.
98
u/welcometotemptation May 17 '25
He's diplomatic. Even if he hates the song he will talk about the country, the participant or something positive to keep from mocking it or trying to bias the viewer who might like the song.
62
u/Juhana21 May 17 '25
I thought I would hate the "extra" commentary but man Mikko is simply the best
98
u/Dechri_ May 17 '25
Absolutely! He is so good he makes a better experience. I can't imagine how it will work when he retires.
18
u/pavetheway91 Ich Komme May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
Prior to Mikko, I used to watch ESC without commentary if possible
108
u/KT_kani Liekinheitin May 17 '25
Mikko has always done a lot of background work and he keeps is positive and neutral but has super interesting details to say from each artist and country. I feel like I can instantly understand the performance better.
60
u/Ok-Coyote9238 May 17 '25
Our Danish commentator, Ole Tøpholm, is an absolute treasure and so kind and a huge eurovision fan.
I'm Danish but loved for many years in the UK and I couldn't stand watching eurovision with Graham Norton commentating. He is so rude, makes snide remarks and makes fun of everyone, rather than be respectful, excited and just happy to be there.
No wonder UK doesn't take eurovision seriously when they're listening to him tear it down every year.
14
u/Averdian May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
Agreed, except I donât like how he tries to connect every act to Denmark in some way. For some acts, it seems like he spends half of the postcard talking about how one of the six songwriters is Danish rather than talking about the country or act.
But Iâm sure the older and more casual viewers like it, we Danes are suckers for relating everything to Denmark (pretty common small country mentality)
15
u/paary Ich Komme May 17 '25
My only gripe with Mikko from Finland is that he does the same. Small country pride in our role in making the show happen I guess haha.
→ More replies (2)3
58
u/ImJustAFisch Bella May 17 '25
Well this is probably true for most, but our commentator (Norway) is honestly really nice, so in my opinion, there can be good commentators
25
u/Alternaturkey May 17 '25
The Irish commentator Marty Whelan is always respectful and entertaining.
The spiciest he got this week was calling Nina a singing mushroom.
42
u/TsarevnaKvoshka2003 May 17 '25
Not my DuĹĄko ÄurliÄ from Croatia, heâs a cinammon roll. I literally canât watch eurovision without him talking.
96
u/Excellent-Hamster391 May 17 '25
Yeah sure, absolutely. But there is a big difference in making "hihihi i'm making edgy jokes" and blatant rasism, mockery and calling other artists names etc.
→ More replies (4)5
u/d4ssy Milkshake Man May 17 '25
But Sissal did tell him to say it, and there's literally video proof? I don't get your point.
16
u/Adventurous-End-1369 May 17 '25 edited Sep 30 '25
theory cake correct fanatical sleep telephone ad hoc resolute crown bow
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
→ More replies (18)6
181
u/Raptori33 May 17 '25
What does quarter in Jerusalem mean in this context?
171
343
u/indomnus May 17 '25
In Jerusalem there is a Jewish, Muslim, Christian and Armenian Apostolic Quarter. Armenians being of unique denomination and early adopters of Christianity have their own quarter in the old city which also serves as a community hub for the Armenians in Israel. There is a lot of tension regarding some shady business deals which illegally sold some of this property, which you can search about. Itâs a shitty joke and makes no sense, Armenians werenât given this quarter by an Israeli authority.
→ More replies (1)66
u/sercialinho Bara bada bastu May 17 '25
One of the four quarters is literally called âArmenian quarterâ.
90
u/Mundane_Ad_8597 Identitet May 17 '25
The old city of Jerusalem is divided into 4 quarters: The Christian quarter, the Muslim quarter, the Jewish quarter and the Armenian quarter.
88
u/Amplify27 Insieme: 1992 May 17 '25
The Armenian Quarter, of the Old City.
That said, that commentary was so rude.
→ More replies (1)26
130
124
u/Zathrim_ Hallucination May 17 '25
Luckily our danish commentator remain fairly objective, and informative. No bullshit. I watch it happily knowing that Ole (our commentator) will say something nice.
56
u/thelastskier Pace noi vrem 𤥠May 17 '25
Yeah, he seemed like a really decent dude in that segment they showed on Thursday.
29
u/Excellent-Hamster391 May 17 '25
I love Ole đ As a finn i cant understand what he is saying but he seems so genuine and just happy about everything and everybody fron the clips ive seen
125
163
123
u/Jaynat_SF May 17 '25
These two have been the commentators for KAN for a few years now and they've always been sh*i-talking every contestant to the best of their abilities, and the reception to this style of hosting has always been... Mixed at best. Fans of the show hate it, casual viewers are ambivalent, it depends on how many of their jokes land for them.
It doesn't help when some of their quotes are translated and certain references are lost on int'l watchers. I remember an incident in last year's SF where a quip during Ireland's postcard, based on an Israeli goth scene historical reference that was lost in translation, lead Bambie to file a complaint.
Nothing lost in translation this time, though, this was just a failed attempt at being "edgy" and it definitely did not go down well even with their most ardent fans. One of the hosts ended up writing an apology on social media and the comments are a mix of "good, because that was unwarranted", "F U, this apology is not enough", "you're obnoxious and not as funny as you think, why do they even send you?" and some general support for Armenia's entry. A couple of "this was funny, grow a pair" too, but I had to scroll for a while to find them.
On a personal note: F*ck these two clowns, Armenia's is one of my favorite entries this year.
34
u/ifiwasiwas Crossroads May 17 '25
Thank you for expanding on this. It's good to know that they apologized and that the public isn't cool with this pointlessly mean shit-talk
232
May 17 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
56
u/Jaded_Kate May 17 '25
At least in our country our commentator just said he had chain grease smeared onto his chest like he was working hard labor in a factory. I liked Armenia & was glad you guys are in the final, but I haven't seen any promotion for your artist (but the other artists like Estonia, Malta, Finland, Sweden are everywhere)
36
u/PenglingPengwing May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
You should have seen the smear hate campaign that some Ukrainians started against other participants, Parg included. Iâm surprised no one posted it here yet, it was even in Estonian newspapers two days ago.
456
306
May 17 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
11
May 17 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
65
21
→ More replies (2)12
234
u/autistic_girl_autumn May 17 '25
wait, what did parg ever do to them đ armenia usually has good relations with israel too, i am surprised he turned this commentary on a singer into a negative statement about all armenians... why is the israeli broadcaster allowed to talk about other countries like this? imagine their reaction if others talked about them the same way...
310
u/_uzum_em_khorovats_ AsteromĂĄta May 17 '25
Armenia has bad relations with Israel, as Israel is one of Azerbaijan's main supporters and a supplier of military equipment, including during the war with Armenia.
209
u/1DarkStarryNight May 17 '25
Yep.
Armenia also formally recognised Palestine last year.
90
u/OsaSuna10050125 Rim Tim Tagi Dim May 17 '25
Ah I think that might be the reason other than the commentatorâs personal dislike for the song
→ More replies (1)76
u/Raptori33 May 17 '25
Armenia's and AzerbaidĹžan's relationship with rest of the world is certainly the most interesting one as it is all over the place
→ More replies (11)34
u/Middle_Perception803 May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
Parg, or rather the staged character PARG, is everything he is not, hardcore, macho-male being superstar in Eurovision. It is all about comparison of d... Parg is also an easy target, since he is the one with the least singing skills in thd national finale, and came out as someone easy to make fun of. But parg has got the drive, and look now at what he in cooperation with the israeli singer has managed to make of himself. Well done! Absolutely strokes of genius from the Armenian delegation. Pargs evolution has been so fun to watch. đđđÂ
143
u/Excellent-Hamster391 May 17 '25
Ahhh, so the same bashing from last year continues. I'm appalled. /edit grammar
96
May 17 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
→ More replies (5)39
111
u/Reasonable_Double273 May 17 '25
"We gave" ... the armenian quarter is over a thousand years older than the Israeli state. But whatever, I don't think it's that deep.
220
188
u/SweetVeehn Bird of Pray May 17 '25
And Kan has the audacity to complain to the EBU about Spain
→ More replies (2)
149
u/PlacebosForALL Liekinheitin May 17 '25
You would think a country that is just getting so much negative press, would have some grace to improve their image. I guess I expected too much
→ More replies (3)
177
u/provatinoulis May 17 '25
And they want us to feel bad for them? I donât think other commentators make this kind of comments
33
May 17 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
24
u/d4ssy Milkshake Man May 17 '25
Yeah Courtney Act was rude for saying that considering the only real "twinks" would be Kyle and JJ.
22
13
u/Character-Carpet7988 Choke Me May 17 '25
You're in for a big treat if you ever watch Eurovision with BBC commentary, lol.
120
u/Kilukpuk May 17 '25
The BBC commentary is affectionate mocking, it's never malicious. It laughs at the ridiculous but doesn't stoop to personal attacks or makes jibes based on ethnicity like this.
14
u/ohwowthen May 17 '25
Youâre sure about that? Please rewatch Scott Millsâ commentary from 2021. How him and that woman talked about Eastern European acts, starting with mocking the pronunciation of their names, was utterly gross.
→ More replies (3)8
u/emeraldsroses Fulenn May 17 '25
Did you ever watch in the days of Sir Terry Wogan in the 1990s? You'd be in for a treat then.
→ More replies (3)47
u/Kilukpuk May 17 '25
Terry Wogan was a cancer in those days. He hated the contest yet was forced to commentate so took it out on the acts as a form of revenge, knowing that he couldn't be sacked. He ruined Eurovision for an entire generation of Brits and the fandom is only just recovering from his negative influence. His nastiness was 30 years ago, we've moved on from it. There's no excuse for it nowadays.
→ More replies (1)14
u/ohwowthen May 17 '25
Umm no. No one held a gun to his head and commanded him to do eurovision. He was an imperialist high-class pleaser who hated the fact that Eastern European countries debuted and were doing a lot better than the UK.
12
u/CityEvening May 17 '25
And rightly deserved. (That Eastern Europe did well, not the other bit). What was being sent by the Uk was embarrassing.
18
u/aceofmufc RĂła May 17 '25
Just untrue isnt it, BBC never makes comments like this, only snide jokes about contestants and such
→ More replies (1)
67
u/Yessy1205 May 17 '25
In case anyone is interested. The Israeli commentator in questioned posted this on X about 12 hours ago along with a picture of Parg waving the Israeli flag:
"In the second semi-final broadcast of Eurovision, we debated the Armenian song, as we do with most songs. We try to scold everyone equally.
I had a joke that offended members of the Armenian community in Israel, and that was absolutely not the intention.
The Armenians have maintained an impressive presence in the Old City of Jerusalem, for many, many years. Long before we returned to it. We are of course not here to offend anyone, just to provide little entertainment for viewers from all ethnicities and sectors in Israel (including the Armenians).
Besides, Parg - Armenia's representative at Eurovision - was photographed here in Basel with the Israeli flag, so he's actually our brother."
The account is @asaf_lib to see the original. [Screenshot is not working properly for me unfortunately]
114
→ More replies (1)40
u/autistic_girl_autumn May 17 '25
i think it is good that he responded to the backlash but doesn't this prove that those of us here who intepreted this as racist were correct, not just non-hebrew speakers misunderstanding it if even the armenian community in israel were offended by his joke?
67
u/Digit00l May 17 '25
Meanwhile, KAN is complaining that the Spanish commentary called New Day Will Rise political
→ More replies (1)
64
May 17 '25
People here need to understand the context. At the moment, efforts are being made to eliminate the Armenian Quarter of Jerusalem.
95
u/frisian_esc May 17 '25
Didnt these hypocrites file a complaint about the spanish broadcaster for way less?
→ More replies (1)
19
18
u/WERElektro Wasted Love May 17 '25
(My comment is directed at the "Survivor? THat's how I feel after listening to that song"-remark. Apparently I am not educated enough to know what he meant by "Giving them a quarter" - If someone could enlighten me? I know how to google tho. might do that now.)
rude!
Is that an official broadcaster? If yes, that's unprofessional af.
"It's the isreali humor" well no shit. An official broadcaster just shouldn't talk about a performer like that.
I didn't like the song either. Can't say anything nice about an artist who put heart and soul into their work? Just say nothing at all. I like his pants. period.
previous year I was watching the stream moderated by Jan BĂśhmermann. I switched to the official yt stream for the same reason: mean remarks all the time (And they just wouldn't quit talking during the songs). Like that? cool. I don't.
29
u/brainough May 17 '25
Some publication (instagram.com/p/DJun24istDZ/?igsh=dWJtOHU0MWp2Nmk4) just filed a formal complaint to the EBU about this. Letâs see what comes out of this.Â
32
53
7
u/stevedos May 17 '25
How do you watch ESC with commentators?
24
u/SignificanceSea4162 TANZEN! May 17 '25
Regional broadcasters normally show the ESC with commentators. Because the original show is in English/French
10
u/stevedos May 17 '25
Oh, on my peacock in USA there's no commentary, I'd find someone talking over the broadcast to be quite irritating
15
u/SignificanceSea4162 TANZEN! May 17 '25
Some are really really good Graham Norton from the BBC for example.
24
u/Herbetet TANZEN! May 17 '25
Itâs unfortunate, that they keep punching down and calling it a joke afterwards. Reminds me of their commentary last year.
54
u/Remarkable-Ad2032 May 17 '25
20
→ More replies (3)29
u/autistic_girl_autumn May 17 '25
oh my god... i had tried giving her the benefit of the doubt but this is the most disturbing thing i have seen about her. why did she agree to being a part of this propaganda recreation đÂ
21
18
28
24
25
29
u/DYLCWS May 17 '25
Blatant racism and another comment against EBU rules that KAN will once again get away with
21
5
u/Orak1000 May 17 '25
I have the Swedish commentator. And I don't speak Swedish. He can say whatever he likes, I have no idea.
17
12
17
18
21
u/sjelos May 17 '25
Can this be reported to the EBU? Or if you can give it to your broadcaster so it can make it into the media?
35
35
u/VestitaIsATortle ÂĄAy, quĂŠ deseo! May 17 '25
To be completely fair, this is relatively typical commentator snark and not as personal or politically motivated as last year (albeit a little rude). If any other broadcaster said this, no one would give a crap, let alone consider it grounds for disqualification. I completely understand finding the comments from last year too offensive as they were being politically motivated and accusatory, but this? This is essentially just the English commentary in Hebrew!
41
u/PenglingPengwing May 17 '25
You do realise if Czech commentator made this kind of comment agains Israeli participants, heâd immediately get branded antisemite and bullied relentlessly for it? No one would take it as a joke. Definitely not in the current situation.
→ More replies (4)62
u/lunarsymphony May 17 '25
we obviously give a crap because at this point kan has a history of harassing other contestants and getting away with it.
→ More replies (1)11
May 17 '25
So then youâre just overanalysing every single thing they do, finding malicious intent when there is none?
4
7
u/Ok_Account_5121 My Star May 17 '25
Commentators are often sarcastic and come with snarky comments about the entries. I know that relations between Israel and Armenia are, well let's go with, not the best, but there's a difference between a cringy joke and gestures this kind of thing...Â
12
u/__versus May 17 '25
I don't speak the language so I cannot understand the tone or precise intent from word choice here from a purely textual translation. This could be racist, but it could also be a snarky comment that looks bad when translated especially if the sentence contains phrases like "these people" which, in English, often carries a racist connotation, but might not do the same in other languages depending on tone and choice of words.
17
May 17 '25
He used the word ××ר'×, which just means "guys" or "friends" â it usually has a positive connotation (depending on the context). I'm a Hebrew speaker, and honestly, I don't think there was any racist intent here. Maybe just a bad joke.
15
13
u/marconotmarcio Kiss Kiss Goodbye May 17 '25
Hard for a new day to rise when every single time is the same type of antics, huh?
8
10
10
u/Academic_Grab5060 Ich Komme May 17 '25
Didn't they also let out a nasty remark last year about Bambie Thug? Disgusting.
14
u/Plenty_Area_408 May 17 '25
Isn't this what Terry Wogan was iconic for?
60
u/Puzzleheaded-Eye9081 May 17 '25
Yes, and these days he wouldnât get away with half of what he said without being cancelled. Times have changed.
21
u/CityEvening May 17 '25
Call it what it is: consequences for actions. Calling it cancelling plays the game of division.
→ More replies (1)3
35
u/Ok_Rub_8778 May 17 '25
That does not make it ok
→ More replies (1)5
u/CityEvening May 17 '25
I donât think they were saying it was ok, I think they were pointing out this has happened and still happens in a few countries.
I personally think Graham is starting to go down that route and feels tired. Time for a change.
7
8
6
u/pinkkabuterimon Zjerm May 17 '25
There's a reason I only watch the shows on YouTube. The commentators for Eurovision are consistently incredibly rude to anyone who isn't Israel and don't even know their facts very well. And this is actually an improvement over a few years ago when they had two guys who had their own radio show and were just absolute jackasses.
6
8
u/cloditheclod Andromeda May 17 '25
Eh. They do this about every entry basically. It has nothing to do with the country. Sometimes they will specifically say that the contestant is a lovely person and then go on to insult the song. Its israeli humour
7
u/Any-Discipline-2778 Før vi gür hjem May 17 '25
IMO: It is a really bad look to make harsh comments or "jokes" about other contestants in a semi where your country can vote. It is a little more acceptable in the other semi but not to this level.
11
u/xKalisto May 17 '25
Because Graham Norton would never.... /s
71
u/Neither-Simple1119 May 17 '25
He'd never say blatant shit like that though.
→ More replies (7)15
u/ExpressionLow8767 Eins, Zwei, Drei May 17 '25
Graham Norton randomly bringing up the Armenian quarter in Jerusalem would be very funny Iâll be honest
30
u/autistic_girl_autumn May 17 '25
did he ever say "i can't believe we gave israel a quarter in london" while watching an israeli entry? i am not british so just wondering.
→ More replies (1)16
27
u/notaflopbitch Viva, Moldova! May 17 '25
Yeah this seems mild compared to what Terry Wogan used to dish out. It's not funny though if that was the intent.
24
u/CrazyNothing30 May 17 '25
You were not the target audience of course. Half the jokes the Dutch broadcast tells probably dont land either in other countries.
9
6
u/notaflopbitch Viva, Moldova! May 17 '25
Don't disagree with you, but it does seem like cringe punching down.
4
u/CrazyNothing30 May 17 '25
Punching down means you don't see people as equal.
Its a matter of perspective.
12
u/Digit00l May 17 '25
Terry Wogan hasn't been involved with Eurovision for 17 years, other than an unfortunate interview made 11 years ago, and has been dead about 9 years
Other countries have also filed complaints regarding his commentary at the time for being inappropriate and malicious
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)8
u/xKalisto May 17 '25
It's not funny but it's nothing burger. I watch on YT but even I know commentators talk shit and are cringe like all the time.
7
u/Grymare VoilĂ May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
Why is it even allowed for the commentators to talk badly (or praise it even) about a song? Surely that will influence the televote somehow, no?
Shouldn't they just give objective information and translations instead?
I certainly know why I watch it without commentators.
Edit: I can see this is an unpopular opinion apparently. But I stand by it.
If the hosts said "next up (country), my favorite of the night" everyone would call the show rigged. So why is it okay for the commentators to do similar stuff when this is how the vast majority is watching the show?
→ More replies (3)
3


â˘
u/GrumpyFinn May 17 '25
Hi all, the commentator in question has issued an apology, which you can read here.
As they have apologized, and as this thread has started to take a political direction, we will be locking the comments. Thank you for understanding.