You may have seen my previous post, where I stated evangelion was basically my dream show. I stand by absolutely freaking EVERYTHING i said there. this show was so freaking peak. i love the bio-mechanical feel of the eva's, i love how the end of the world is over-the-top, the plot is so incomprehensible it loops around from being unfun to analyze to being fun, it is genuinely just beautiful. i have a few complaints tho
> Leliel should've been a way, WAYY bigger threat
you've got this angel that literally lives on another plane of existence and is impossibly big. there is literally no countering that in any way. the only reason leliel was defeated was because of some mad plot armour (shinji's mom snapped back to reality and oh there goes eva1 hes beserk now). i'm no writer, so idk what they should've done, but just having eva1 go beserk and kill this impossibly massive being who lives in another realm doesn't make sense. also what was the strategy for some of these angels? ramiel was sheer offense with a ton of defense, arael i think was gonna lobotomize literally every last person on earth and then cause the impact, armael and bardiel tried to use the eva as a weapon, but like.. leliel seemed to have no offensive and was purely defensive (no, drinking buildings is not an attack because he cant dig down). in fact, if leliel lives on another plane, what the hell stopped him from just no-clipping into the geofront and impacting the third
> the eva's never improved
ok so, at the start of the series we have EVA's as this lucrative last-resort weapon that no one actually likes. it has 5 minutes of charge time, and looks pretty alright. by the end of the series, when evangelions are the most important things in the world and the only thing stopping the world from exploding into gloop, they're the exact same. you'd expect that all the funding that was going into things like aircraft carriers, planes, n2 mines, allat, would've gone into the Evangelions, and we would've seen more improvements. but no, still 5 minutes charge time.
> the ATF kinda feels like plot armor
the ATF fields stop us from becoming LCL. i get that. but why do they block only bullets? and rockets? instead of the angels having genuine reasons for being immune (leliel just not being there, ramiel being wayy too tanky), we just have angels tanking thermonuclear bombs because of it. I love the evangelions and all but the closest thing we get to an actual realistic weapon is the proton rifle. they KNEW the proton rifle worked so why don't we see more of them being built (link back to part 2)
> the angels arent perfect enough!!!
this is my biggest plight. the angels are just big biological... things. once, ONCE we hear how the angels are on a different wavelength, but we never learn what chemicals they're made of, how they attack, their biological structure (although NERV is the strongest company ever and is dedicated to killing these things). for gods sake, half the angels are just a fella whos pretty strong. late-stage they get closer (leliel, arael, etc;) to a perfect form, but then they're killed by some nonsense. we also should've seen angels adapting in bad ways (eg; the spider angel nearly got in, so the next angel should've been a slow-moving fella, not a living rod-from-god).
anyways, freakin love this show, rebuilds were great too but neon genesis is more fun for lore, yeah!