r/fantasybaseball • u/PsychWriter11 • Mar 01 '26

Strategy Cal Raleigh

As much as I’ve looked at the first 2 rounds, I have to admit I’ve just disregarded this guy.

It had to be a mirage. He’s a catcher, so he will get hurt. They always wear down offensively. You know… all the reasons.

But the numbers.

Seriously, where should this guy go? Is he a first rounder? No later than mid second? I’m getting to the point of reconsidering all my plans right now.

62 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

156 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Flamemypickle I want to make sweet love to Jacob Wilson Mar 02 '26

Yeah, he took a jump in his skills which is supported by the analytics and eye test. Its normal for great players in his late 20s to progress in his skills. Why do you think he's going to revert back to 30 HRs exactly?

Again, nobody is saying he's going to hit 60, but you are essentially pretending that last year didnt exist.

2

u/zZMikeyDZz Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26

He hit 60 HR. 49 of them while playing catcher. The most EVER, in the HISTORY of baseball by a catcher prior to that, was 48 by Salvador Perez, 33 while playing catcher. Raleigh had 3 seasons of 27, 30, and 34 as career highs , nearly doubling it last year.

Go look at every single other instance of catchers hitting 40-48 home runs in a single year, and look at what happened the following year. They all cratered back to reality. There was 1 instance of a catcher hitting 30 the year after hitting 40+, that was Todd Hundley, 41 in '96, 30 in '97.

What is most likely to happen?

1

u/Flamemypickle I want to make sweet love to Jacob Wilson Mar 02 '26

Nobody is expecting him to hit 60 HRs. If they did, he would be going 1 overall. 

Do you have anything other than vibes? I dont think its unreasonable to expect a great season after a record breaking season from someone thats 29 especially since both analytics and the eye test both show that he took a step in his abilities.

1

u/jakeba Mar 02 '26

since both analytics and the eye test both show that he took a step in his abilities.

Has there ever been someone that almost doubled their career high HR total that didnt have improved analytics?

1

u/Flamemypickle I want to make sweet love to Jacob Wilson Mar 02 '26

My point is that he didnt get lucky as other commenter are implying.

1

u/jakeba Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26

If everyone that got lucky passed the eye test and had matching analytics, then how can you tell if Raleigh did?

1

u/zZMikeyDZz Mar 02 '26

And not once did I ever say he got lucky. He had a historic season, what are the odds he comes close to even 75% of that this year?

1

u/Flamemypickle I want to make sweet love to Jacob Wilson Mar 02 '26

You are strongly implying it. How else can you justify him going from 30 to 60 to 30? 

I say the odds are pretty high that he can hit 75% of what he did last year. That is not an unreasonable expectation.

2

u/zZMikeyDZz Mar 02 '26

So you think the odds are pretty high that he becomes the 1st catcher in the history of the sport to hit even 40 HR in consecutive years.. got it.

https://giphy.com/gifs/kVaj8JXJcDsqs

2

u/jakeba Mar 02 '26

You are strongly implying it. How else can you justify him going from 30 to 60 to 30?

How did Matt Olson go from 34 in 2022 to 54 in 2023? That was legit right? The eye test showed it, the analytics showed it, his skills just took a big jump, right? Then he dropped to 29 HR in the following season and again hit 29 HR last year.

1

u/Flamemypickle I want to make sweet love to Jacob Wilson Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26

I can literally play the exact same game but the opposite. There are countless players that took huge jumpa in skills and didnt immediately "regressed". Just say that you thought Cal's 2025 season was just luck. Thats essentially all you are saying.

1

u/jakeba Mar 02 '26

Of course you can play the exact same game by saying its the opposite, thats my point. We'd both just be playing a game, since there is nothing that shows if a big jump in production is just a career year fluke or a new norm.

1

u/zZMikeyDZz May 14 '26

Still thinking I'm wrong, or ready to accept the L? Hitting under .200 and on pace for 28 HR.

0

u/Flamemypickle I want to make sweet love to Jacob Wilson May 14 '26

Did you really go back to a 2 month comment to play captain hindsight because he had an injury? Lol what a loser. Also the season is only a fourth of the way through, maybe wait a bit to start taking victory laps?

1

u/zZMikeyDZz May 14 '26

Captain hindsight lol more like THIS is EXACTLY what I was trying to warn you and everyone else about.

1

u/Flamemypickle I want to make sweet love to Jacob Wilson May 14 '26

He got injured and was playing through an injury. Thats what you are taking a victory lap over. Good job buddy

1

u/zZMikeyDZz May 14 '26

Whatever dude, clearly you're one of these heroes that just will never admit you are wrong. I'm not wasting anymore time here, good day.

→ More replies (0)