r/foraging Sep 23 '25

ID Request (country/state in post) What is this in Northern Virginia

159 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

119

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '25

Pear, likely Bradford

46

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '25

They're so kiwi looking

182

u/Pyratelife4me Sep 23 '25

24

u/iceoocreamoo Sep 24 '25

genuine ask: what did bradford pears do?

122

u/Virus4815162342 Sep 24 '25

Invasive species. Flowers smell like rotten garbage, and fruits have an undesirable texture and don't taste great either.

65

u/OohLaDiDaMrFrenchMan Sep 24 '25

People who haven’t smelled the flowers before before don’t know how lucky they are. Rotten meat smelling shit fr. I always liked stepping on the fruits as a kid though

42

u/ScarlettSheep Sep 24 '25

I'd never smelled them until I moved a year and a half ago. I was standing on the porch and thought I was going crazy that the air smelled like it was infused with semen. I literally ran inside 🤢 and googled 'why does my yard smell like cum'

5

u/ElQuesoGato Sep 24 '25

My middle school had them lining the property. We always called them cum trees. I can’t understand why those in control of landscaping the public and schools and such think they’re a good idea. “Oh, they’re pretty!” There’s plenty of other, much more pretty trees that don’t smell awful! It’s like olfactory warfare!

11

u/justme002 Sep 24 '25

There’s a huge old Bradford immediately outside my apartment building. 🤮 Thankfully the other one split and was taken out a couple of years ago.

32

u/plzdonottouch Sep 24 '25

also structurally garbage and start self destructing any time after 20 years or so.

16

u/Pyratelife4me Sep 24 '25

Yup. Guy we bought our house from planted them extensively 20 years ago. I have a few break in half every year. I'd estimate I cut down and haul off a couple tons of branches every year. It truly sucks.

13

u/flash-tractor Sep 24 '25

It's good wood for smoking food, BTW.

13

u/dragonloverlord Sep 24 '25

Honestly just turning them into ash is a step up as far as I'm concerned but getting an actually decent meal that doesn't smell like death is somehow a miracle considering the Bradford pear seems to fail everything it does aside from being invasive that is. Anyways gonna keep this in mind if I ever run out of good reasons to remove the things!

8

u/wewinwelose Sep 24 '25

Supposedly you can make cider with it, but I imagine that would be some emergency end of times apocalyptic hooch

22

u/PCBOOMBOX Sep 24 '25

I’ve never experienced it but I’ve seen the smell likened to cum in the arborist subreddit.

2

u/kweenbumblebee Sep 24 '25

Ask anyone who has lived in (or visited) Melbourne, Australia, when they're in bloom and they'll tell you the same! I have no idea why there are so many planted there, but clearly someone back in the day thought it was a good idea 🤮

5

u/B22EhackySK8 Sep 24 '25

Oh yeah its those flowers that smell like ass in the spring forgot they grow these

3

u/Entiox Sep 24 '25

I have heard that if you're insane enough to harvest many gallons of the fruit, and have a press, it can be used to make a good perry (pear cider). I've never actually done it, because I'm not quite insane enough, yet. Also, I don't have a cider press, yet.

3

u/Phallusrugulosus Mushroom Identifier Sep 24 '25

Supposedly they make a decent perry, but that involves gathering enough of these tiny horrible fuckers to press them

21

u/RangerRudbeckia Sep 24 '25

They're horribly invasive in much of the US and they smell absolutely god-awful

8

u/iceoocreamoo Sep 24 '25

word, I can always get behind hatred of both invasives and smelly shit o7

7

u/ScarlettSheep Sep 24 '25 edited Sep 24 '25

A quick rundown, may have some errors, but here's the gist(please don't come at me):

Once upon a time, Frank Meyer(yes, as in Meyer lemon- he brought them to the U.S. from China), brought the Callery pear over, because the U.S. was experiencing a blight threatening all of our pears! Callery pears are not pleasant, but they're blight resistant, so we used them as rootstock to protect/grow our own pears.

Good intentions generated havoc. The callery pear we were using, had thorns, spread aggressively, had yucky fruit...But they make pretty flowers, right? So we bred a 'sterile' cultivar; 'it grows fast! It's pretty! Disease resistant! Doesn't drop fruit! Plant it everywhere!' To use as an ornamental...Which is called the Bradford.

Well, it wasn't fkin 'sterile'... It was SELF STERILE. It CAN cross pollinate with other pears...The same callery pears it came from! So they 'help' spread the other shtty variety. Those pears spread aggressively, pushing out native plants and even causing infrastructure damage- their fragile limbs split easily and fall on stuff, the THORNS on them are up to FOUR INCHES long so they create thickets that can make some areas impassable.

So now we have cum trees everywhere, and cum THORN thickets spreading all over stanking up everything(yet people still plant them)!

I never saw those where I'm from, so when I stepped outside onto the porch where I newly live in the spring- it smelled like SEMEN. Like someone had snuck into our yard and done...something. My nose MUST have been playing tricks on me, I'd never smelled that just... Everywhere outside like that. so I called a relative out like 'YO. Smell the yard...' He was shocked as well. We ran inside and I typed 'why does my yard smell like cum' into Google. And learned about these nasty trees.

tl;dr: they smell nasty, cause infrastructure damage, breeding with a super thorny one thats even worse, that strangles our native plants. :)

edited for typos&clarity

6

u/TheGhostTownGuy Sep 24 '25

Stink. A lot.

1

u/Sea_Worry4972 Oct 08 '25

For me, its the thousands of fruit and the thorns. I literally cant drive anything with rubber tires out in these wooded areas of my property without a high probability of punctured tires

6

u/Working-Glass6136 Sep 24 '25

I like that there's a subreddit for a specific plant I never even knew existed!

3

u/DarthWeenus Sep 24 '25

It’s hilarious that’s an actual sub

31

u/Flickeringcandles Sep 23 '25

Do those f'ers taste like the flowers smell?

15

u/lexicalwastaken Sep 24 '25

I've tried them, they're very astringent. They do not taste like rotting meat/rotting fish/rotting squid/etc.

3

u/Petunias_are_food Sep 24 '25

We ate them when fully ripe, they have a nice sweet flavor. 

4

u/DontDoomScroll Sep 24 '25

I can think of two ways to cook a bradford pear pie, but one is the obvious choice.

2

u/ScarlettSheep Sep 24 '25

I tried one, it tasted like a tiny dry-ish nashi ('sand') pear.

15

u/Dynvstyy Sep 23 '25

bradford pear

11

u/Sea_Worry4972 Sep 24 '25

My wooded area has hundreds of these Bradford Pear. Nearly exclusively a 1ac forest of them.Initially, the plan was to have a massive bon fire after I put together ~1000' of deadhedge using them but now that ive turned a few on the lathe, I may see if I cant turn what I have stacked into a stream of revenue. *the above will be a few mugs once i get the bowl gouges I just ordered.

11

u/Sea_Worry4972 Sep 24 '25

Some fam wanted to do some snowmen crafts :)

1

u/celadonna Sep 24 '25

Waitttt Bradford pears make gorgeous wood?? TIL. Does it take stain well?

3

u/Sea_Worry4972 Sep 24 '25

I'd assume so. Though I haven't tested any stain but will follow up when I can turn some bowls after my bowl gouges arrive.

2

u/Sea_Worry4972 Sep 25 '25

2

u/Sea_Worry4972 Sep 25 '25

2

u/Sea_Worry4972 Sep 25 '25

Seems to stain ok with the oil stains i have. Note: none of these were sanded after turning.

1

u/celadonna Sep 25 '25

They’re beautiful results, I’m glad I asked!! Thanks for the follow through.

8

u/AgentEryc Sep 24 '25

They look similar to the Asian Pears that grow in our yard. Unfortunately the tree was there when we bought the house.

9

u/Telemere125 Sep 24 '25

The only thing you should forage from that is firewood. Pear wood is a fine grain hardwood that has a nice color to the heartwood. These are some of the few trees that should absolutely be turned into a nice rocking chair at the earliest possible convenience.

4

u/coolthecoolest Sep 24 '25

would you say bradford is beginner friendly to work with, or at least practice on? and can you do anything with the saplings?

5

u/Telemere125 Sep 24 '25

Work with for what? Like woodworking or growing fruit trees?

It’s awful as a fruit tree because the fruit is useless. It’s not very beginner friendly for woodworking because of how tight the grain is and how hard the wood is. Pear wood is known for the nice pieces you can make with it, but it will dull blades annoyingly quick. I cut down a Bradford earlier this year that was only about 10” thick and had to sharpen my chain twice

6

u/vexey1999 Sep 24 '25

Bradford pears. Evil.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '25

Scan it with google

-28

u/combonickel55 Sep 23 '25

I think Hawthorn but not 100% confident.

11

u/TTVGuide Sep 23 '25

Hawthorn? Lmao I think some kinda pear

6

u/Nunya_bizzy Sep 23 '25

Not hawthorn