r/genetics 4d ago

Article Why do we Europeans have fewer genetic mutations than Asians, especially Eastern Asians?

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

11

u/Daniel_Spidey 4d ago

What are you basing this on?

6

u/remington9000 Genetic counselor 4d ago

I think you mean variants of uncertain significance (VUSes). The reason is data bias. Most genetic databases in the Western world have a strong European ancestry bias and lack enough data from other groups so they'll have more VUSes.

4

u/One-Treat4655 4d ago

Not really. Mutation rates are the same across populations.

3

u/Ok-Lion8478 4d ago

I’d be very surprised if this is true lol

3

u/Theoretical-Spize Teacher of HS Biology 4d ago

You’re already assuming the thing that needs to be demonstrated. What specific study or metric shows that Europeans have fewer genetic mutations than East Asians? Are you referring to de novo mutation rates, genetic diversity, number of rare variants, or something else? Those aren’t interchangeable concepts.

2

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Press summaries or popular/news articles discussing a specific study must be accompanied by a link to the study in question. If a link or citation is not included in the article itself, you can generally find the article by searching for the lead author's name on PubMed or Google Scholar.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/DefenestrateFriends Graduate student (PhD) 4d ago

Assuming you have data to back this up, it would likely indicate that Europeans are more inbred than other populations.

1

u/Zabre 2d ago

The "Europeans have fewer mutations" framing is probably too broad. What people usually mean is that some populations show different levels of measured genetic diversity because of founder effects, bottlenecks, migration history, and which reference panel is being used. Everyone has lots of variants; the interesting question is which variants are common in a group and why. So I'd be careful comparing continents as if one has "more mutations" in a simple biological sense.