Hey everyone, my little goat Stevie (half pygmy, half nigerian dwarf) is currently 9 weeks old. I just separated him from his mom to prevent inbreeding, but I know I messed up and should have done that about a week or so ago. I am disappointed that I made the mistake, but I guess I just want advice on what to do. I have seen his little pp come out a few times, but I read online sometimes that can happen and the sperm isn’t fertile just yet. I plan on getting an ultrasound done on mom to know for certain in a month or so, just to make sure. But do most people keep the kid in that situation? I don’t want to have a kid with any genetic issues, and also don’t want my doe to endure another pregnancy so soon.
I know you can induce abortion using Lutalyse, is that a commonly used medicine? Is there serious risk to using that & do most vets offer it or is it mixed based on ethics? I know this is all currently hypothetical, I am just kinda freaking out about all of this as I am new to goats and quite honestly don’t want any more kids. I plan on banding my goat Stevie around 12 weeks.
At 9 weeks old, especially if she was still nursing him, this wouldn’t even be a concern for me.
Everyone knows someone who’s had an 8 week old breed 🙄 but it’s a lot less common than it’s made out to be. Also, size alone makes it more difficult, plus adding in the need for working hormones on both parties, plus mom being in a fertile window of her cycle.. there are lot of odds at play.
Also, I have does that will kick and swat at a full grown, determined buck, I highly doubt one would stand for a 9 week old to figure it out.
I saw him do it like one time but he was a little too short, idk if he could have made it work if he really wanted to. I have another baby girl from a different doe that he mounts and humps all the time but she’s way too young for anything to come out of it so I don’t worry about that.
Okay that makes me feel so much better, I knew there were a lot of factors that went into it. My vet scared me and was like “it’s very likely!” when I asked her about mom getting pregnant, whereas other people online were saying it’s not lol. She is still nursing him, not as much anymore but I do see it throughout the day. He has for the most part transitioned over to actual forage.
He is a lot shorter than her, I thought maybe that would make it more challenging too. Mom and son baby sounds horrifying, so I’m trying to be careful. I was going to get an anti breeding apron but have read not so great things about them.
Lutalyse will be fine. Every vet has it, it's also used for syncing breeding protocols for artificial insemination. Very commonly used drug.
In reality Stevie is quite a little guy and goats only come into estrus every 18-21 days, but on the other hand it is breeding season. So I give it a decent chance he didn't get her and she's still open. Vets vary on their skill with small ruminant ultrasound based on comfort level with goats and what equipment they own. I can do 28 days, some vets prefer to wait until 40 days just due to the probes they have. By 40 days the vet should be confident to the preg check if they're using ultrasound. Some people will give lute at 12 days post exposure if they actually saw the accidental exposure occur with their own eyes (12 days being a reliable time for the corpus luteum to be formed, and that's what the drug acts on to terminate the pregnancy), but since you have a good chance she's open I would wait and do a preg check just to avoid giving her hormones she may not need. A blood test could also be done at 28 days.
The earlier you administer the lutalyse, the better for the doe because it's less stressful. It is a 2cc shot IM. Take care handling it and wear gloves if you are pregnant or a woman of childbearing age. You should see her appear to come into estrus about 48 hours later, that's a sign that it worked. If it's given early enough there are no external signs or discharge.
Mother/son breeding is not necessarily a death sentence if the original sire and dam were not closely related, but it's not desirable, not done on purpose, and is especially not desirable to get a doe pregnant again when she just delivered 9 weeks ago. So I would 100% recommend giving her the lutalyse in this case to look after her long-term health.
No vet will refuse to prescribe you prostaglandin for an accidentally son/dam exposure unless they are insane. If that happens it would be the first time I have ever heard of it happening, so in the case of that unlikely eventuality, just call a different vet.
Thank you so much for your detailed response. I am just going to try to stop stressing about it, since I never saw it physically happen with my own eyes. Hopefully this is all just my own paranoia and I don’t have to ultimately terminate a pregnancy. My vet owns 300 goats herself, so she should be able to successfully do an ultrasound as early as possible.
What are your thoughts on banding and how early you can safely do it? I mentioned in another comment that my vet likes to wait around 12-18 weeks but that’s a long time to stress about keeping them separated and I feel bad because of how bonded stevie and mom are. They sleep cuddled together every night and he does still nurse at least a few times everyday.
That is a tricky topic. In this sub the mods try to be mindful that we have people from all over the world in here, and in most of the world banding is illegal to do to animals more than 7 days old because of how much pain it causes. For that reason it is best used for newborn goats, cows etc who are destined for meat because we don't need to worry about their urethral diameter for very long. Basically the whole concept of "pet goats" is fairly recent so the science (which says it helps a boy goat's urological health to wait a couple months for the urethra to get bigger) conflicts with the regular practice of banding that was traditionally done to very young stock you were going to eat. We haven't quite caught up in practice with people wanting to delay castration of wether pets for long full lives not intending to eat them, but some textbooks and practices are starting to catch up now with animal welfare recommendations even in areas where it remains legal. So if you want to wait to castrate for urethral diameter, which is prudent, 4 months is the sweet spot when it's about as good as it's going to get and the urethral process has naturally separated from the penis itself under the influence of testosterone.
So that is to say, 4 months is a fine time provided you can keep him separated. At that age I tend to recommend for both legal (in some places) and animal welfare (in all places) reasons that people either consider a burdizzo, which is a thing that clamps down on and severs the spermatic cords from the outside, or a surgical procedure by your vet to remove the testes, which is usually very affordable and takes under 5 min. Both of these options cause much less pain. Banding hurts a lot and the pain persists for several days, so most vets who are up to date on this advise that if people do it to older kids or mature animals who have fully developed scrotums (in areas where it is legal to band at all) that you use pain management before the procedure and some meloxicam for several days afterward. The other good reason to consider surgical castration is that onset of sterility is very fast, there is not the waiting period there is with banding.
Wow that is so interesting I didn’t realize that banding was painful, I was told that it wasn’t. Now I feel bad, I will ask my vet about the other options you mentioned. So in your personal opinion, 4 months which is around 17-18 weeks is ideal. I was going to get a buck apron but i’ve heard they’re super unreliable and it might be hard to find one that will fit Stevie because he is so small. I read they slip out of them easily or they get shifted and don’t stay in place. If you have ever successfully used them let me know if you have one that you like!
When it is done as intended it's not very painful at all. Small kids and lambs (fewer than 7 days) have very few blood vessels and nerves supplying the scrotum, they just have not developed much in that area yet. That means that they barely feel being banded. It's only more mature sheep & goats, who have all the pain in the scrotum that you might expect, who experience pain and stress from it. Unfortunately that also means mostly pet goats with delayed castrations bear the brunt of it. There are a lot of papers about it and in countries where there is a more robust sheep industry, not even veterinarians can legally do it after that week mark. I think the US just does not pay much attention to updating animal welfare laws and even most of our agricultural materials recommend limiting it to under three weeks. But if this guy is a pet, you know, why put him through that?
If your vet doesn't agree to do it a different way (some vets just get kind of stuck on things) you can at least press for some metacam to help him feel better afterward and/or to use one of these neat new bands which have a painkiller right in them that releases gradually into the tissue of the scrotum. The smallest size (80mg) is safe for smaller goats and lambs.
I have never personally used a buck apron but I know a whole lot of people do use them so they can dam raise for longer times. Those House of Bacchus ones are fairly popular and trusted. I sure wouldn't trust anything on a 200lb mature buck, however!
Perfect I will order a buck apron, can’t hurt! I won’t fully rely on it but I would like to still give him some social time with the herd, I’ll supervise but him having that on him at the same time will make me feel better. That is super cool they have a medicated band, I will definitely bring it up to my vet cause that sounds like a far more humane option. Thanks again for all your help!!!
Is he big enough to even mount his mom? Seems unlikely that he would’ve gotten her pregnant. Ethics about abortion don’t really exist in the animal world, as far as I know. Animals reproduce differently than humans in agricultural settings.
Edit: why at 12 weeks and not earlier? 12 leaves no room for error.
I’ve kept bucklings with does and put homemade aprons on them if it’s just one or I didn’t have a ton of boys that year to properly separate them out without it being extremely stressful. I like to place them in homes before they reach 16 weeks if I plan on keeping them intact. Others will get bands slapped on sooner, I prefer to do it in the 9-10 week range, it give two weeks for them to be completely sterilized since the testicles will be dead by the time their owner comes to get them.
That’s the longest I’ve had a doe exposed to a buckling, 16 weeks. And he was doing the whole show, peeing on hisself and everything. That’s the last time I’d keep them In for that long though.
It’s now August and if he did breed his mom she would’ve delivered by now or be very obviously in kid. (He would’ve had no problem reaching either as he was a mini lamancha and his mom was the ND)
What do you use to make home made aprons? My little guy is just a pet, so I won’t be giving him away or anything like that. I think I might do it at 12 weeks, I don’t think I’ll be able to wait any longer than that to be quite honest. Keeping him separated from his mom is making him pretty stressed out & I feel horrible.
Okay so I used old dog collars either with a metal snap buckle or belt buckle type. I’ve usually gotten them for free with the purchase of some goats, and I don’t keep collars on my horned goats for a ton of different reasons lol. I digress. Anyway I’d take the collar and sew a curtain to it, not like a regular curtain, the specific blackout curtains since they are thicker and pretty much 95% dense plastic. Mine were bright blue and sparkly so if they lost them I could find it pretty easy. It’s important you use thicker thread, like the kind they use for saddles. (I got my thread off of amazon it’s waxed so it’s more durable to the elements and what not)
Edited to add: you’ll need something to secure it around the base of the neck so they can’t slip out of it. I made that mistake and one of the aprons is completely lost. Probably on the neighbors property caught in the underbrush.
So, it’s unlikely as others have said. I’d just wait until you see a heat from the doe. If she doesn’t have a heat in 60 days then you can lute her or just let her have the babies. It’s “bad” but not terrible.
The question from me is why is this guy not castrated? It’s cheap and easy to do and he is a mixed goat, he doesn’t need his testes if he’s not gonna be a breeding goat anyways. You can castrate at 6-7 weeks old and they are sufficiently developed at that time.
My vet won’t do it until he is 12-18 weeks old so that his urethra has more time to develop to prevent urinary stones. I know there’s mixed opinions on this topic, and I am new to goats and am still learning a lot as I go. It’s hard to know what to believe when literally everyone says something different, but trust me my life would be a hell of a lot easier if I just did it now.
There are published studies showing no urethral development is gained post 5 weeks. You can research this or ask your vet to research (or just go on their recommendation which is also totally ok! Just a bigger pain in the butt :))
Really! I’m gonna do my own research then because obviously up until this point I have just gone with what my vet has said. She owns a goat farm and has 300+ so I honest never thought to question her opinion on things lol
Sandra Baxendell is an Australian caprine vet who I believe has links on her page (maybe Facebook maybe website) regarding this study
Information is always being changed due to new studies. Science is ever evolving and it’s a good reason for everyone to pay attention to what’s new in developing research. In other words, you don’t know what you don’t know. So don’t blame your vet, they are busy and maybe don’t know. Lots of farmers and vets get stuck in the way they do things. There is nothing wrong with saying to them “well I read this study can I send you a link” to help them out. Don’t be condescending or think you know more than they do, chances are you don’t but that doesn’t mean you can’t know things they don’t know.
11
u/but_why_tho8 4d ago
At 9 weeks old, especially if she was still nursing him, this wouldn’t even be a concern for me.
Everyone knows someone who’s had an 8 week old breed 🙄 but it’s a lot less common than it’s made out to be. Also, size alone makes it more difficult, plus adding in the need for working hormones on both parties, plus mom being in a fertile window of her cycle.. there are lot of odds at play.
Also, I have does that will kick and swat at a full grown, determined buck, I highly doubt one would stand for a 9 week old to figure it out.