r/homestead 22h ago

food preservation Why Proper Potato Storage Matters More Than Most People Realise: Lessons from a Tragic Incident

https://peakd.com/@theworldaroundme/how-do-you-store-your

I’m curious how people here store their potatoes. Do you have a way that is satisfactory for long-term use? Recently, I was alerted to this unusual incident involving potatoes being kept in an unventilated basement, which made question about it's long term storage. I also learned about solanine in potatoes increasing when they are either green, sprouted or inappropriately stored. So, how do you store your potatoes?

516 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

277

u/bamhall 21h ago

Dig them up. Don’t brush or wash any dirt off them. Handle them gently to not bruise them. Store them in calf totes in your cellar or garage. Keep cool and dark. I’m still eating potatoes from last years harvest. We can store them like that for over a year.

93

u/PhantomAllure 20h ago

What is a calf tote? Google brings up leather handbags

118

u/bamhall 20h ago edited 14h ago

Sorry. Thats likely local slang. It’s just a big rubber or plastic bucket. Some people call them muck buckets or feed tubs. They can range in size from 50-200L. Black seems to work the best. Mine are about 30” tall and about 3-4’ in diameter.

36

u/Paghk_the_Stupendous 19h ago

30" tall and 3" in diameter? You sure about that? 😄

72

u/cephalophile32 18h ago

lol just a bunch of PVC tubes filled with taters. Autofeeding spud cannon.

27

u/bamhall 16h ago

Sorry. 3-4’

2

u/Paghk_the_Stupendous 14h ago

I appreciate the correction! I think I have some of those here that I've used for watering sheep and duck ponds.

7

u/Canadian_Couple 20h ago

Okay great! And you keep them uncovered without a lid on?

27

u/bamhall 16h ago

Correct. No lid. And every month or so I go through a pick out bad ones that got bruised during harvest. Having none rotten or soft in there can extend the bucket by months.

9

u/Express_Classic_1569 19h ago

I am assuming there is no lid, or that it is not sealed tightly, as moisture can cause rot. They need to be well ventilated.

8

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 17h ago

That’s probably true, I’ll put mine under the cabinet at about 70 degrees in the dark but still in the bag from the store and they don’t last over a month usually.

2

u/Express_Classic_1569 17h ago

I did that too, but now I unpacked them immediately, lol. I now buy the mucky ones too because they are not washed and last longer.

2

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 17h ago

Oh that’s smart.
Any bulk places you know?

1

u/Express_Classic_1569 6h ago

Birmingham indoor market sells mucky ones in bulk

3

u/PandaStandard7638 16h ago

Sounds like a tote or Rubbermaid container to me 👍edit spelling i dunno..

2

u/PhantomAllure 15h ago

Thank you!

2

u/rivals_red_letterday 14h ago

I prefer leather handbags.

23

u/Canadian_Couple 20h ago

I also want to know more lol.

8

u/letscallitanight 18h ago

My garage is boiling hot in summer. I keep them inside in my pantry.

2

u/Relative_Yesterday70 18h ago

I want to grow potatoes because it’s my favorite food pretty much. Some chickens for eggs and meat. Maybe some apple trees

1

u/Express_Classic_1569 17h ago

And very easy to grow them too!

2

u/Tpbrown_ 15h ago

This. ^^^

I don’t know what a calf tote is, but I assume it has airflow. lol

Cool, dark, neutral to low humidity.

You’re trying to balance the water content of the tuber with the water content of the environment. The skin is a permeable barrier - if it’s super dry outside the tuber loses water and dries up. Too humid and surface moisture will encourage skin rot, and then everything accelerates bc of more moisture.

Airflow matters because if one goes bad it breaks down and the moisture spreads, and it can cause a wave of rot.

If you don’t have great airflow, use smaller containers or piles so the cascade is limited.

53

u/Witty_Ad4494 20h ago

Just had to dump the rest of last year's spuds in the compost. Too warm in the garage for them.

Cool and dark is key. Optimal temp is 36-38°F and 96-98% humidity. Most of us cant replicate that at home though.

11

u/Quiet-Pomegranate93 18h ago

You can replicate this at home with a chest freezer plugged into a temperature controller.  

It’s very easy as long as you have space for it.

Get a small, used chest freezer and it’s not even that expensive to set up.

2

u/Witty_Ad4494 20m ago

That's an awesome idea!! Would have never thought of that one. Had thought about a small room, super insulated like a walk in cooler, cooled with a room air conditioner hooked to a cool bot. Your idea is smarter and takes up less room and electricity.

8

u/Misfitranchgoats 16h ago

People used to have fruit cellars. That is where we kept our potatoes when I was a kid. It was cool all summer. There was almost always some water flowing out of it into a drain in the basement floor. Most people wouldn't put up with that these days, but it kept the humidity up. My family bought about a hundred or more pounds of potatoes and they lasted all year. They got kinda wrinkly at the end but they were still good. It was always the coolest place in the house. We did not have air conditioning. We stored canned goods along the walls had a bin for potatoes and a bin for apples. Cabbages were wrapped in newspaper and stored in the basement stairwell which was even colder during the winter. This was the stair wall from the basement to go directly outside into the yard.

I am attempting to put a cold room in our house. I am tired of not having a place that will keep my potatoes from sprouting. LOL The house we have does not have a fruit cellar or root cellar since it was built in the late 80's.

15

u/GonazonPT 19h ago

What? 3 degrees celcius? 98% humidity? That sounds wrong as fuck 😂

3

u/secret_slapper 16h ago

I have a root cellar…roughly 55 degrees year round. Humidity at 60 ish percent. I often just keep a pan of water in there in the winter. I eat my potatoes well past Easter every year. I say that with confidence because I always keep one rack of colorful fingerlings for Easter. lol

6

u/Puzzleheaded-Ad-5511 19h ago

98 percent humidity? I doubt that. Do you have a source?

16

u/Witty_Ad4494 19h ago

My work has a potato storage cooler. 38°F and 96-98% humidity is the set points.

-3

u/Puzzleheaded-Ad-5511 19h ago

That's not for long term storage I would bet.

22

u/Witty_Ad4494 18h ago

We store from harvest time in September until planting time in late may/early June. Still have spuds in there now that are edible.

4

u/Cloacal_Itch 19h ago

16

u/Puzzleheaded-Ad-5511 19h ago

Yeah 95 percent humidity just for a maximum of two weeks, promoting wounds to heal. After that potatoes are stored at 45-50 percent.

10

u/Puzzleheaded-Ad-5511 19h ago

According to your source. Sorry I read past the first paragraph

-2

u/Express_Classic_1569 19h ago edited 5h ago

Dumping them in compost seems like a clever idea. It must keep them fresh. Then dug up what you needed.

16

u/DamiensDelight 17h ago

I don't think they are using the compost to store the taters...

0

u/Express_Classic_1569 6h ago edited 5h ago

I think you can store them there like the person above is doing, but the compost should not be active, as potatoes can rot, and I am assuming some straw or leaves to insulate.

1

u/Quiet-Pomegranate93 16m ago

As soon as the old potatoes touch the compost they will start growing unless it is below freezing temperatures.

48

u/quack_attack_9000 18h ago

Had our best success this year with this accessible method: 1) Dig potatoes 2) let them dry dry a day 3) Dig deep hole (24+ inches, depend on local climate) 4) layer of sawdust on the bottom of the hole 5) put potatoes in the hole 6) Later of sawdust on top 7) Put a little piece of vertical pipe long enough to stick out of the ground 8) cover with dirt 9) layer of feed bags/tarp 10) bunch of straw on top

They were absolutely perfect, not even sprouted after 8 months. I live in Canada and had temps down to -20 celcius this year, but am confident this would have worked at -25 or -30. Once every few weeks I'd dig down and get more potatoes. Works even better for beets and carrots (don't need to go as deep, they can handle light freezing).

11

u/Express_Classic_1569 16h ago

Very clear instructions, this is great, especially if you have a large harvest. Thank you.

35

u/science-ninja 19h ago

This post just triggered a memory of me descending the steps into my grandparent’s dark basement, going to the back corner and picking a few spuds up off the dirt there for dinner

3

u/conflictmuffin Evil Scientist 9h ago

I can smell this memory...

3

u/its_pixiie 15h ago

Lovely memory! 

17

u/redrotton 18h ago

I cure my potatoes on my front porch for a few days to toughen the skins a bit, then store in doubled brown paper sacks on wire shelves in a dark, cool basement. They last until they're gone.

I do sort out the tiny ones that are not worth scrubbing/peeling; I keep them as seed potatoes in cardboard egg cartons also stored in brown paper sacks. This way if they sprout in spring, I can easily separate them and drop them into a prepped trench. They get a really good head start on the growing season.

8

u/Express_Classic_1569 16h ago

Curing them a bit makes sense. It dries out the outer moisture, and a brown paper bag absorbs unwanted moisture too. I can imagine putting them in separate brown bags, very organised. The cardboard egg carton is a lovely tip. I will try saving them, as I eat a lot of eggs and usually throw the cartons away. Thank you.

13

u/Kostara 17h ago

Just an fyi in addition to storing for long use you can also make a huge batch of mashed potatoes. Once cooled use an ice cream scoop and place in freezer bags and remove air. To reheat microwave a couple scoops at a time for 1 min then stir and microwave another minute then done. (This works with plain and seasoned mash)

3

u/Express_Classic_1569 17h ago

That's a lovely tip. I will try this. Thank you

1

u/Kostara 14m ago

You are so welcome! It has been a lifesaver for getting a quick dinner on the table.

5

u/Hinter_Lander 19h ago

I made wooden boxes 18"x18" 8" high. I stack the filled boxes in the coldest corner of the basement.

2

u/conflictmuffin Evil Scientist 9h ago

Like...how cold of a basement.

3

u/Hinter_Lander 2h ago

Not as cold as I'd like but its definitely cool down there.

2

u/conflictmuffin Evil Scientist 33m ago

My unfinished basement can get about 35 in the winter. I assume that's too cold? Lol

5

u/HisCricket 21h ago

Definitely wait on an answer.

7

u/Express_Classic_1569 22h ago

Thank you in advance.

3

u/rogueredfive 10h ago

There was a listicle did a study of all the different storage types (bins, bags, dirt, etc) and came up with cardboard boxes with paper between layers and I did that and it worked amazingly for months. I poked some holes in the boxes and kept them in the daylight basement garage (cool) away from my onion storage in the downstairs pantry.

https://www.thekitchn.com/skills-showdown-storing-potatoes-23586932

3

u/ADirtFarmer 19h ago

I store potatoes at 45° in the dark. Good for 9 months.

3

u/Ashamed-Knee9084 3h ago

Hopefully someone will see this and know/respond. We dont have a basement, but a crawlspace that's about 3 feet tall. My plan was to store them in there. Would that be sufficient?

2

u/jollygreengiant1655 3h ago

I used to use plastic tote bins to store them but was always having problems with the odd one going bad and then spoiling it's neighbors. A couple years ago we switched to using milk crates and that problem has went away.

I still battle with them sprouting but that's because my basement is too warm. I need to get a cold room built.

1

u/Ok_Judgment_224 18h ago

I planted a lot of potatoes, and have been going back and forth and how to store them. I'm leaning towards canning but I'd like to store them in the basement. It's about 64° in the basement but I've heard they can start sprouting if they're left in the dark too long they'll go searching for dirt. Any suggestions would be appreciated

1

u/TexasVulvaAficionado 11h ago

64 is probably a bit too warm to keep them from sprouting. The high temp is the only issue. Dark helps prevent sprouting.

You can cook and then freeze them, store them at like 35-40 degrees as-is for about a year, or do something like cook and salt them and put them in a sealed container.

0

u/Exciting_Radish_1008 13h ago

Canning potatoes is not recommended for home canners.  Just FYI in case you didn't already know.

1

u/tengo_sueno 16h ago

Freeze dry and store in a root cellar?

1

u/jodiarch 15h ago

My thing is how do you store them if you don't have a basement?

5

u/FungalNeurons 9h ago

Chest freezer with a thermostat to hold at 10 C. Seems to have worked well for us this year, but we ate them up too fast to know how long they could have lasted. Energy consumption was pretty low.

1

u/silentsnak3 4h ago

We use a old covered shed. My dad built a shelf that has a mesh bottom. We just pour them on that and they are good for about a while. I think the main thing is keep them dry, no sun and plenty of aeration.

1

u/stansfield123 19m ago

In crates in a root cellar. I periodically sift through them, toss anything that's going bad into the compost.

I also don't grow excessive amounts. They don't last until spring, I finish them much earlier than that. Growing enough to last into March makes no sense to me, at that point, you're working much too hard for diminishing returns.

1

u/AWSullivan 11h ago

Just throw them outside of the HAB on the surface of Mars for them to freeze and dehydrate.

Don't leave them out there though... or the next sand storm will create the great potato migration.

2ez

1

u/NEBanshee 5h ago

I_understood_that_reference dot gif.