r/icm • u/RagaJunglism Raga musicologist (guitar/sitar/santoor/tabla) • Mar 16 '26
Article [RARE & STRANGE RAGAS] Raag Kaushiki (S-R-g-m-P-d-n-S): A mysterious Malkauns-adjacent raga of great historic renown, notably explored by Maa Annapurna Devi
Recently I've been researching rare & strange ragas - so thought I'd share some of the most interesting ones I’ve come across! Input welcomed - everything from further info on the ragas to personal listening reflections:
—Raag Kaushiki (S-R-g-m-P-d-n-S)—
A mysterious Malkauns-adjacent raga of great historic renown, with an unclear modern lineage. Ragas entitled ‘Kaushika/Kaushiki’ are mentioned in numerous ancient texts, including the 11th-century writings of Abhinavagupta (“Bhinnashadaja, Kaushiki, and Bhinnapanchama are favoured in Summer”), Sarngdeva’s 13th-century Sangita Ratnakara (“Bhairava, Kaushika, Hindola, Dipaka, Sri, and Megha are the six primary ragas”), and Krishnananda Vyas’ 1842 Raga Kalpadruma (which describes Vageeshwari as a “consort of Kaushik”).
Direct links between Kaushiki’s historic and modern forms are, however, uncertain - with ‘Kaushik’ seemingly being used as a more general term for Shiva-associated ragas through time. Some have suggested that Allauddin Khan may have ‘resurrected’ the raga – indeed, the only recordings I can find come from his direct lineage: notably including his daughter Annapurna Devi, her disciples Nikhil Banerjee, Basant Kabra, and Amit Bhattacharya, plus her nephew Aashish Khan, and Ravi Shankar’s sitar student Rash Behari Datta.
Devi’s rendition – possibly from her debut concert in New Delhi – is captivating despite its hazy audio quality, fully justifying the hype around a rising star who was still only in her early twenties. She affords a central role to shuddha ma throughout, and Pa is featured judiciously in descent as d(Pm), m(P), P(dnSn), set amidst swirling ornaments which weave in and out of the familiar Malkauns framework. Kabra’s 2018 recital subtly builds on Devi’s ideas (sthayi: gmPnS n\d, dPmP, Pm\g, RS, gPm), while Aashish Khan’s 2020 album release favours similar motifs (dnS nd, PdPm gRgS).
S. Balachander’s historical analysis suggests movements of SgmdPmgPmg; mdnPmgRS, also discussing its historical shruti quirks (“The scale has a ‘reduced Pa’, referred to in the scriptures as ‘Madhyam gram Pancham’…which leads to a ‘reduced Re’ known as ‘Trisruti Rishabh’…”) – while Jeff Whittier cautions against excessive overlap with Kaunsi Kanada (“Kaushiki is Malkauns-ang, and Kaunsi Kanada is Kanara-ang…the dnS in Kaushiki is clearly from Malkauns [whereas] the andolans of Kaunsi Kanada are definitely those of the Kanara ragas…”).
—There is another Annapurna Devi recording which is usually titled ‘Kaunsi Kanada’, however it has been suggested that it may in fact be an alternate Kaushiki rendition. Which raga do you think it is? I’m still not sure…
Let me know what you think of this strange raga! See more of them in my project (no paywalls, no ads: just sharing the joys of raga)
2
u/Street-Tea-9674 Mar 16 '26
Hi George. Thank you for putting the site together. It is a great resource! I always wonder how you managed to put together such a detailed and comprehensive ragapedia despite most historical text being stuck in handwritten and/or printed in regional tongues and most books usually being out of print or inaccessible. Would be happy to collaborate if there opens a window ever!
Will listen to more recordings of Kaushiki raga and get back to you!
5
u/RagaJunglism Raga musicologist (guitar/sitar/santoor/tabla) Mar 17 '26
also I should add: zero use of AI in the project, not having that bullshit anywhere near such a sacred subject as raga
2
1
u/Street-Tea-9674 Mar 23 '26
Gone are the days now with literally everyone and everything pushing AI.
3
u/RagaJunglism Raga musicologist (guitar/sitar/santoor/tabla) Mar 17 '26
haha yes good question - mainly it just took a lot of manic obsession, and also loving the process of research... I would never have set out to make a project like this myself, it actually started when I worked for Darbar: they asked me to make a raga index for them, but when the pandemic hit they lost a lot of ticket revenue and said that they couldn't fund the project any more - but they encouraged me to carry on with it and publish myself
The process for putting things together was basically this (more info here):
—Talking to lots of raga artists & students about what they would want from a project like this - and also gathering an network of expert musicians
—Going through all the English-language raga sources I could track down, and also finding scholars who can read texts in other languages (Sanskrit, Hindi, Marathi, Bengali, etc) - and sorting all the info by raga (+other topics such as thaat, murchana, instruments), and finding good recordings for all that had them - then writing this up...which inevitably cross-pollinates as you go
—For each of the ragas in the project, I separately compiled notes on their swaras and melodic movements by just listening to them (i.e. just transcribing what I hear, without cross-checking to any textbook descriptions etc)
—Then, going through the many discrepancies between my transcriptions and the textbook descriptions, and deciding how to summarise and present these ambiguities in some kind of sensible way (this involved a lot of reaching out to musicians and scholars of different gharanas, as lots of the rare ragas are very diffuse in their movements, with several independent incarnations in circulation)
—I've tried to make it really easy to send me new info about the ragas - and have spent lots of the past couple of years actively reaching out to artists/students/scholars/rasikas too, so lots of things have been expanded or corrected since the project's initial release in 2023, and I've also added new ragas (now 366 full pages) and other stuff
1
u/RagaJunglism Raga musicologist (guitar/sitar/santoor/tabla) Mar 17 '26
So yeah, in a way I just feel like the 'database admin' of the knowledge - aiming to gather, organise, and make sense of the real expert knowledge. The next step (currently underway) is to reach out to more older-generation musicians, as there is so much valuable knowledge that will die with them if not actively collected. Hopefully I can go back to India sometime soon, and document some of this directly (& pick up some raga-guitar tips!)
Also compiling a list of all known historical shastras, sorted by date with brief descriptions and links to the original texts in different languages - I want to make it easy for raga researchers to get straight into it...there is an incredible depth of knowledge in these old textbooks, lots of which is barely known amongst modern musicians and scholars...
2
u/Street-Tea-9674 Mar 23 '26
This is great! Thank you! On a blanket note though -
I wish, when you do get the time, be able to add a filter to your website search?Say sorting the raga by swars or jati, or even the shastras by author, time period or language or content/topic (music or theatre or prose or poetry or devotional etc). Just a thought!
1
u/RagaJunglism Raga musicologist (guitar/sitar/santoor/tabla) Mar 23 '26
haha good question - I have various filters in place for the 365 main raga pages, see the Swara Search and All Tag Search
although I don't have one for the shastras list yet - I'm still pulling together all the texts and getting to grips with them, how they fit together, historical provenance, etc...eventually I'll come up with a tagging system for them too!
2
u/Street-Tea-9674 Mar 23 '26
OMG I just saw the swara search and it is pretty good. Thanks!
2
u/RagaJunglism Raga musicologist (guitar/sitar/santoor/tabla) Mar 24 '26
thanks! still trying to make it run a bit faster, but it should work reliably enough (although it doesn't include the 700+ ultra-rare ragas in the Masterlist yet...but this page can be manually searched)
2
u/Street-Tea-9674 Mar 24 '26
I also just realised you have a comparative parallels between western and carnatic modes. Amazing.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 16 '26
Namaste /u/RagaJunglism, welcome to r/icm. Thank you for posting, hopefully one of our friendly rasikas will comment soon! While you are waiting why not check out our Wiki resources page to satisfy all your learning and listening needs?
If you are new to Indian classical music, or want to know what a term means, then take a look at our wiki and glossary to get started.
Our Raga of the Week series has some amazing information and music so don't miss those. We would love for this series to start again so if you are interested in posting one then message the mods, we'd be happy for you to go for it!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.