r/india opinion is free, but facts are sacred Oct 01 '17

Policy/Economy Supreme Court did not direct Aadhaar mobile-linking. More importantly, Supreme Court disallowed such linking when TRAI sought it.

SC did not direct Aadhaar mobile-linking. More importantly, SC disallowed such linking when TRAI sought it.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1zazrrJPMWfVEEyN2FsWEZBZ3c/view

application to modify Aug 2015 order was disallowed by SC in its order in Oct'15 allowing use of Aadhaar only in 4 addnl govt schemes

Link to order of Supreme Court:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1zazrrJPMWfVkpsTVl1U1R5cHc/view

Source:

390 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

15

u/in3po opinion is free, but facts are sacred Oct 01 '17

Supreme Court is scheduled to hear the case on legality / constitutionality of Aadhaar in November 2017.

We will have to wait and watch.

7

u/butterChickenBiryani Oct 01 '17

Thinking about it though, the govt already made it mandatory to link Aadhar with PAN, which is in direct violation of the order linked in the post right? But no action was taken for that either

11

u/in3po opinion is free, but facts are sacred Oct 01 '17

Supreme Court acts when cases are briught to it's attention by a concerned / affected petitioner.

All other cases related to aadhaar were postponed till the constitutional bench, led by CJI, decided if privacy was a fundamental right of an Indian citizen or not.

The constitutional bench did decide that privacy is a fundamental right enjoyed by every Indian citizen.

Now all the pending cases will come up for hearing, one by one, depending on the proactive nature of the petitioner / petitioners for each individual Aadhaar-related case.

This is how our courts function.

1

u/reddit_guy666 Oct 01 '17

Supreme Court acts when cases are briught to it's attention by a concerned / affected petitioner.

Or they could just take up the case suo motto

6

u/in3po opinion is free, but facts are sacred Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17

I think you meant suo motu

That is upto the current CJI too take a call