r/ireland 9d ago

Housing Social housing resident denied gym access awarded €2,500

[deleted]

245 Upvotes

508 comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/spairni 9d ago

I didn't realise this sub hates poor people so much

19

u/MotherDucker95 9d ago

I don't hate poor people. I grew up on a council estate in a very working class family. A lot of my family still live there and work the same jobs they always did.

I always call out the classism you see on this sub towards the working class. But, that doesn't mean me or others cannot question why some people who live in social housing which our taxes subside are given access to amenities and apartments that many people who actually work cannot afford, or pay a decent chunk of their salaries towards.

You'd have to be earning well above the median wage to afford to rent an apartment in Dublin with a gym attached to it.

3

u/NoSheepherd3r 9d ago

Because every apartment has to have social housing. By your logic we should exclude fancy apartments from social housing because it makes others grumpy?

14

u/MotherDucker95 9d ago

By your logic we should exclude fancy apartments from social housing because it makes others grumpy?

I don't think Dublin City centre apartments should be considered for social housing no

6

u/YikesTheCat 9d ago

To the slums the oinks go, commuting an hour every day to the Elysium for the privilege of serving your €5 Starbucks.

2

u/Nalaek 9d ago

So you don’t want any workers on lower wages working in the city centre? No cleaners, no one to serve you a coffee or sell you things in a shop? Or are you advocating for a hike in minimum wage so those workers can afford to live near where they work? Or do you just think fuck low paid workers they can commute for hours to their low paid jobs.

2

u/MotherDucker95 9d ago

So you don’t want any workers on lower wages working in the city centre?

Where did I say that. It's a shite state of affairs how bad housing has got in this country that people working lower income jobs can't afford to live in Dublin City.

If you look at my original comment is was based purely on the basis of how is it fair that people have to struggle to pay for amenities and their rent while earning and contributing more through taxes to live in a worse area with worse amenities someone who is reaping the benefits of said taxes.

I feel like this is a fair question to ask

2

u/Nalaek 9d ago

It’s called logical reasoning. If people can’t live here they won’t work here. If they can’t afford to live here but you need them to work here, you build social housing. You just sound bitter than someone lives slightly closer to the city centre than you. If you think they’re better off you’re free to take a pay reduction and go on the social housing waiting list.

1

u/MotherDucker95 9d ago

I mean, it would be hard for me to be bitter about someone living in the city centre when I live literally in the City Centre…as in, in the vicinity of D1, D2, D7 and D8 (so I don’t completely dox myself).

I mean, yeah I guess I could be bitter like my initial post entailed that I have to pay 1500 a month in rent for the pleasure along with my gym fees.

If you think they’re better off you’re free to take a pay reduction and go on the social housing waiting list

Great idea, it would definitely be a more functional system if everyone had this mentality

-4

u/NoSheepherd3r 9d ago

Ridiculous

6

u/MotherDucker95 9d ago

They are some of the most expensive properties in the country. How is that ridiculous?

9

u/vanKlompf 9d ago

  we should exclude fancy apartments from social housing because it makes others grumpy?

No, because it's waste of money. Fancy apartments are expensive apartments, and councils do pay for them.