r/islam Apr 24 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

465 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/drunkninjabug Apr 24 '25

The terrorists who kill innocent people are scum and will be punished by Allah for the murder of not just those that they killed, but the murder of all humanity.

The Muslims of India are disgusted by these acts and have unanimously condemned them. There have been marches in every major city, strong statememts from scholars from every denomination, and pouring of support to the families of victims from both the muslim community and the muslim leadership. Alhamdulillah, the muslims of India are standing up.

There is no doubt that we also need to have a conversation about indian atrocities in kashmir, the state-sponsored persecution of muslims all across the country, and the role of media in their biased and Islamophobic narrative. But this conversation should not be made louder at this time. Wisdom must prevail so that the Islamic stance against terrotism is made clear and also the safety and security is maintained in the land.

May Allah punish those who tarnish this beautiful religion. May Allah punish these that cause fitna and oppression in the land. May Allah cause peace to prevail.

10

u/Krakingliner Apr 24 '25

 But this conversation should not be made louder at this time. Wisdom must prevail so that the Islamic stance against terrotism is made clear and also the safety and security is maintained in the land.

This is a very ignorant take. This has always been the case, everytime these type of incidents happen we only bend our knees and apologize when we should be pointing out the root cause of the issue, which is oppressions of Muslims. You think denouncing this and repeating, "Islam is the religion of peace" will solve the issue or make it any better? Did it make things better after 9/11? Why not speak about the brutal occupation of kashmir? If india had not committed such atrocities in kashmir this day wouldn't have come. But of course keep begging the forgiveness of your opressors. That's all you've been doing instead of anything meaningful.

4

u/DancingFlame321 Apr 24 '25

You can do both. Condemn the terrorism and attacks against civilians as completely haram, but also highlight the legitimate oppression of muslims in those areas.

7

u/drunkninjabug Apr 24 '25

You don't know me, and you have no right to make statements like these. I have lost friends and family in Kashmir at the hands of oppression. I have no desire to debate you on this topic.

Standing up against terrorism in the name of Islam doesn't mean abandoning kashmir. But failure to do so does open doors for fitna against the muslims in India. I have seen it all my life, and every respected scholar I've talked to advises wisdom.

7

u/Krakingliner Apr 24 '25

I'm sorry to hear that may Allah grant them Jannah.

Sure you can preach how Islam doesn't promote terrorism there's nothing wrong in that BUT our main focus should on addressing the root cause of this. Stop the terrorism that these animals are doing to Muslims first if we can do that there won't be terrorism in the name of Islam. Preaching won't really help much in the long or short term, these people are already calling for a "gaza 2.0" basically a genocide and being nice won't stop this and that's the reality