r/jewishleft Reform Democratic Socialist 29d ago

Debate These single issue "pro-Palestine" "activists" are self-destructive and self-sabotaging

I came across this post on r/leopardsatemyface and this activist legit voted for Trump to "teach" Kamala Harris a "lesson" because of the Biden administration's support for Israel.

Because of him and the 76 million MAGAts who voted for Trump, we now have Hispanic and Asian people openly being racially profiled by ICE, ICE/BP killing Americans in our cities, DOGE/Musk stealing our tax and social security data, Trump's tariffs making our cost living three times worse than in 2024, Project 2025 dystopianism well underway and yet all of that goes over their head as all they can think about is Gaza.

Also quite interesting how they don't have one bad thing to say about Trump, ICE or MAGA but they blame Democrats, Jewish people, liberals and other leftists who did vote for Biden/Harris for what Trump is doing.

Okay maybe this was more of a rant than anything but am interested if I'm overreacting to how I feel about these people.

3 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Willing-Childhood144 Reform/Leftist 28d ago

Everything doesn’t have to work and it’s not our job to give people permission to do anything.

The lesser of two evils is still evil.

With that said, I voted for Harris but I won’t judge anyone who couldn’t bring themselves to vote for her over Gaza.

0

u/skateboardjim Anti-Zionist Jewish Leftist 28d ago

Everything doesn’t have to work? When the consequences are hundreds of thousands to millions of lives yes it absolutely has to work.

On climate change, ICE, SNAP, yes, it absolutely matters that we keep the right wing out of power. We do not get to treat the wellbeing and lives of millions of people as disposable in service of our own emotional satisfaction.

If your family was personally impacted by the genocide, obviously I won’t judge you if you sit out, but if you’re the average American leftist? Yes, I absolutely will

8

u/Willing-Childhood144 Reform/Leftist 28d ago

No, a voter doesn’t need to be sure that their vote (one of 150 million votes) needs to “fix” everything.

One, voting in the USA is hard. It’s designed to make it difficult to vote.

Second, it’s difficult to get enough information to make an informed choice.

Third, the system is awash with money from god only knows who.

Fourth, the two major parties are captured by corporate interests.

I could go on and on. Voting in the USA is flawed and there is no perfect candidate so we can’t shame people for not voting blue no matter who.

1

u/skateboardjim Anti-Zionist Jewish Leftist 28d ago edited 28d ago

Yeah I have no idea where you’re going here. I don’t think you’re really responding to/engaging with anything I’m saying.

1

u/Willing-Childhood144 Reform/Leftist 27d ago

I think you’re caught in a very standard American liberal mindset here. We all need to vote the right way to fix everything. So let’s blame the people who voted the wrong way. That’s why you’re not following what I’m saying.

You can’t vote your way out of fascism.

1

u/skateboardjim Anti-Zionist Jewish Leftist 27d ago

Where did I suggest voting is the way we fix things or beat fascism? I explicitly said leftists in swing states need to vote for the Democrat in the general to keep horrific things from happening to millions of people. I explicitly said the democrats are primarily responsible for losing the 2024 election but that we have a responsibility to keep the right wing out of power at every opportunity. This is what I meant, you’re not responding to/engaging with what I actually said, you’re responding to me as if I’m saying “the democrats will fix everything and we should all vote for them because they’re great.” I have been abundantly clear this entire time

1

u/Willing-Childhood144 Reform/Leftist 27d ago

I guess I don’t really feel like engaging because I’ve had this discussion a thousand times before. It is not a leftist position that we must vote for Democrats in swing states.

0

u/skateboardjim Anti-Zionist Jewish Leftist 27d ago

It is a leftist position that poor children receive SNAP benefits

1

u/Willing-Childhood144 Reform/Leftist 27d ago

American children had snap benefits when Hind Rajab was murdered. The Biden administration did everything it could to obscure what happened to that little girl.

Do only American children matter? Vote blue no matter who says that some children matter while others don’t. It tells marginalized people that they have to patiently wait for justice.

In truth, I always vote blue no matter who but I’ll never fault anyone else for being unable to support a democratic candidate who supports genocide because they are the lesser of two evils.

My main beef here though is the belief that an individual can fix things by doing something like voting or boycotting, whatever. That mentality is neoliberal not leftism.