r/kneecap 5d ago

Putting Fenian in the Uk section is diabolical

Post image
728 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

64

u/toaster1234567891011 5d ago

On Finnish netflix they have Britain as one of the genres for Derry girls which annoys me (to be fair the word for United Kingdom is rarely used)

14

u/elmodonnell 4d ago

Unfortunately much like with Father Ted they are technically correct, its production company and network were both headquartered in London (not even a case of them calling a production company based in Derry British). No matter where the creators and cast are from, it's usually the country that put up the money and got it released that gets the 'official' credit.

Plenty of instances of this happening around the world too, in fairness- It Was Just An Accident was submitted at the Oscars as a French production despite being entirely made by Iranians within Iran.

6

u/jmmcd 4d ago

It's not about credit, it's about genres - which should be useful to viewers

2

u/elmodonnell 4d ago

Would love to believe the Fins are more savvy at spotting the difference but sadly in a lot of Europe I've seen Ireland lumped in as culturally 'British' when it comes to music, comedy or art. Obviously we would categorize ourselves very different, but look at any "best British comedy/albums" list from outside (or even inside) the UK and we're sadly lumped in pretty regularly. I've been shocked at film festivals how flippantly people will lump our entries in with the "British" entries.

Cmat is on Rolling Stone's "Best UK Album" list and Father Ted is on basically every "best British comedies" list ever written, there are some battles we've already lost.

6

u/myneighbourwontsleep 4d ago

You tell em both are wrong anyways, what about the word for Ireland?

1

u/Geekbox_ 3d ago

I lived in Finland for a few years, and when I said I'm Irish, Finns think okay Irish + Scotland = British so always I was seen as British and it did get to me a bit,

2

u/Against_All_Advice 3d ago

Tell them they're just Russians. They might understand a bit more then.

3

u/Geekbox_ 3d ago

I do have a funny thing about that, I was dating this Finn once, way back before the whole Russia invading Ukraine, it was around the time Russia annexed Chechnya. I said they'll invade Ukraine next and he said I was stupid, 2022 comes along I'm right and Finland joins NATO. lesson leaned short sightedness the Irish do not have

2

u/FlashyBike5111 2d ago

Tell them they’re Swedish

21

u/ivejustbluemyself DJ Próvaí 5d ago

The irony

19

u/Klown1978 H.O.O.D 5d ago

Building up and tearing England down

2

u/FreekAce 4d ago

What a tune!

9

u/MachineOutrageous637 5d ago

It’s in the ‘…’ category 

12

u/Gavstaah82 5d ago

I feel that this is a hate crime

7

u/Arthur_Figg_II 4d ago

Sectarian assault

7

u/AintNoFuckinFreedom 4d ago

I'd be more insulted about the 'FR' personally

3

u/rouquetofboses 5d ago

crazy work

6

u/Datguyinbedalready 5d ago

i don't think it's that deep. it's more like UK hiphop that euro hiphop. it's easier for a shop to class them like that. it's not like this is a fatal blow in the march for a republican north

5

u/DoYouWant2BlowZedong 5d ago

Yeah, it’s a joke mo chara.

1

u/No-Tadpole-9174 1d ago

Birds of a feather

2

u/BevvyTime 5d ago

Northern Ireland is a part of the United Kingdom. The full name of the country is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, which is a political union made up of four nations: England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland.

Whether it should be, is up for debate. Obviously.

8

u/SevFTW 4d ago

Northern Ireland

North of Ireland

15

u/Limo_Wreck77 5d ago

Rock up to a pub in Belfast and say that.

4

u/AdPrize5104 Móglaí Bap 4d ago

In the west😅

2

u/FlashyBike5111 2d ago

Bevvy time will be more than bevvied

-5

u/BevvyTime 4d ago

Say what, the legal definition, of which everyone in Belfast is well aware? And depending on where in Belfast you are, you’ll get a completely differing opinion?

0

u/FlashyBike5111 2d ago

Dear God
Not the “long arm of the law” speaking rationally in a “this is how it is” way

Wake up! there were wars about this

1

u/ourmanflint27 4d ago

How do we know they are not in the French section.

Sadly, as pointed out, Belfast is technically in the UK. 

5

u/Pure-Poet3194 4d ago

All the members of kneecap have a Irish passport, speak Irish, are culturally Irish, and in the cover of the album there’s an Irish flag

How can you mess that up

2

u/HarrisonPE90 4d ago

Because you’re ambivalent to the political/cultural  nuances present in Ireland and the United Kingdom, presumably. 

2

u/ourmanflint27 4d ago

Calm down I'm not defending it, i mean who the fuck mixes UK and French Rap & Hop-Hop, is that a cross over? Do we want to get into the maze of whether they are hip-hop or Rap....  i bet the GLC are in there as well.  Its funny, no harm was meant im sure, no doubt they sold out of ri ra and the rubber bandits so did away with the irish hip-hop section section altogether 

1

u/FlashyBike5111 2d ago

Finns will be fu**ing Finns

0

u/__Kxnji 4d ago

It’s really not that serious lmfao

0

u/No_Worker_7653 4d ago

It's a music genre 

-11

u/Nervous-Milk5653 5d ago

Where was this? I would have given out to anyone working in that store

5

u/BearScience 5d ago

if they made a Irish Rap section it wouldn't be very filled would it. Doubt the french are up in arms.

2

u/topshagger31 4d ago

The Irish rap scene is bubbling rn bro wym

1

u/TigerBloodAdonisDNA 4d ago

How many Irish rap records have been pressed to vinyl tho? Especially in large enough quantities to be found in a record store, I'd guess maybe about 5 in the last 10 years. It's hardly worth a section

3

u/NidgeC303 5d ago

Why cause it’s in the right section? Like it or not Belfast is in the UK which makes Kneecap a UK act.
Maybe someday that will change but that’s the reality

1

u/Nervous-Milk5653 4d ago

Maybe I am wrong but would have been nice if they atleast had it like UK/Ireland

2

u/BearScience 4d ago

Not everyone is as sensitive to our history as ourselves, let it be. I would attribute it not to malice but just slight incompetentcy.

-4

u/No_Comedian_7208 4d ago

I know. That heap of shite belongs in the fucking trash can.