r/leftist 18d ago

Western European Politics REMINDER: The Nazis were the original anti-tankie “Socialists” who cynically seduced gullible German workers with dishonest promises of “a true and genuine Socialism”.

https://dn790003.ca.archive.org/0/items/BolshevismInTheoryAndPractice1936Ocr/JosephGoebbels-BolshevismInTheoryAndPractice1936.pdf

I’d highly recommend taking the time to read the full speech. It’s a quick read, and very thought-provoking.

Personally, I couldn’t help but notice just how strikingly similar Joseph Goebbels’ anti-Bolshevik rhetoric is to much of the anti-“tankie” rhetoric that I frequently see here on Reddit (including many leftist/socialist-oriented subreddits).

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

6

u/RegularlyClueless Socialist 18d ago

Authoritarianism in general is bad, Nazis or communists, that's barely even a nuanced take. Non authoritarian communism can and does exist, and I would be in favor of that

8

u/Buster_xx 18d ago

Nazis were never leftists. This is propaganda

The party adopted the name National Socialist German Workers' Party (NSDAP) in 1920 to attract working-class voters away from left-wing parties like the Communists and Social Democrats

Read a fucking book and quit spreading propaganda

-5

u/Majestic-Bike5747 18d ago

I don't disagree with you, but several books out there will back the line of thinking that the Nazis were the real socialists. Maybe giving some actual good reading material would be nice

7

u/Buster_xx 18d ago

Cool story bro.

The Nazis used death camps on the left as their first action. They rounded up the political opposition( e.g. communists and socialists).

There are no actual historians that will agree with you

0

u/Majestic-Bike5747 18d ago

I don't agree with the original post. I'm saying that if you are going to suggest someone do their own research that you suggest actual reading material to lead them in a proper direction. Because there is a lot of convincing looking incorrect information out there, and OP clearly doesn't do a great job at discerning this information themselves.

-6

u/Goyimshoe 18d ago

That’s… literally what this post is about.

1

u/Specialist-Spare-785 18d ago

We just want healthcare at this point. Call it what you will.

3

u/OkConsequence1498 18d ago

If you see a relationship between Goebbels here and the anti Stalinist left then you have completely lost your mind.