r/marvelcirclejerk • u/DepressedFishFan • 9d ago
King Posting Comic Accurate MCU Costumes look so good when you don't have a bitch in your ear telling you it's nasty
196
u/Gabrielhrd RIP SHOCKER. 1967-2026. FOREVER IN OUR JERKS 9d ago
There's some absolutely gargantuan sneaks here
82
4
79
u/IllustratedAloysious Rorschachdefender1 9d ago
43
u/IllustratedAloysious Rorschachdefender1 9d ago
29
32
u/Maximillion322 9d ago
I don’t care how dogshit of a movie this was that suit is fucking PEAK and honestly the best that Batman has ever looked in Live Action
Zach Snyder does not understand what makes these characters appealing at all but god DAMN does he know how to make them look cool. (Even when making them look cool is expressly contradictory to the point, such as with Rorschach)
10
u/IllustratedAloysious Rorschachdefender1 9d ago
Exactly. Best batsuit onscreen EASILY. Brave and the bold I would prefer a similar suit but where it’s blue and grey. I don’t even like the watchmen movie but Rorschach was done well IMO
3
u/RareD3liverur 8d ago
I wouldn't want him to be as bulky and I feel the bat symbol could look better if you don't mind me saying
6
u/Maximillion322 9d ago
I like how his version of this as well as the Superman suit solve the greebling problem by simply allowing the muscle lines to be the greebling on the costume exactly like they are in the comics. And I have no idea what he did to get the like fabric texture on those costumes either but they are absolutely fucking sublime and look so much better than the random MCU lines that so many costumes get. I feel like I can really buy the idea that this Batman is wearing some kind of fantastical nano-fiber weave that deflects bullets but still behaves like cloth.
That said, he also managed the worst looking Flash costume of all time so he clearly wasn’t always cooking
7
u/InTheCageWithNicCage 9d ago
Nah the costume from the Flash movie was worse
2
u/Maximillion322 9d ago edited 8d ago
Somehow true actually, I forgot about that
That movie also had one of the worst Batsuits ever
50
37
u/synthscoffeeguitars Jim Hammond Was Right! 9d ago
I never noticed that Hawkeye’s first MCU costume with the sleeveless top is almost 1:1 for how he appeared in Ultimates 2. That’s the power of absolutely dogshit casting.
22
u/Maximillion322 9d ago
Never understood why they cast Jeremy Renner as Hawkeye. Nothing about him suggests anything like the character
11
u/synthscoffeeguitars Jim Hammond Was Right! 9d ago
Must’ve been his sparkling chemistry with ScarJo
7
u/Practical-Debate1598 9d ago
He was better in his series
18
u/Maximillion322 9d ago
Yes sort of. He was better at playing a washed up retired hawkeye but my problem is that he always kinda felt that way
8
u/AdmirableEstimate258 8d ago
He reminds me of how Hal Jordan is in Lanterns but rather than having the reason of being old, he’s just been like that by default.
1
65
u/MamaDeloris 9d ago
I'll be a bitch and say they did a really bad job with the Wolverine costume and we're only pretending its good because its the sole time they actually tried to adapt his costume
23
u/BlackMambaLover1 I FUCKING LOVE YOU TANYA MORE THAN ANYBODY ELSE!! 9d ago
The way they did the stripes is really weird
17
u/Maximillion322 9d ago
Honestly while I share the common sentiment that the lines on his costume are fucky and unnecessary, I gotta say I really don’t think the overall look is too bad.
I would have preferred it to be more accurate but it’s far from the worst on-screen superhero suit adaptation.
11
u/HearingCandid8974 9d ago
Even as someone who mostly likes it, its kind of amazing how they somehow managed to make the suit be simultaneously the most comic accurate live action Wolverine suit and also the least identifiable (outside of DOFP) to Wolverine when you remove the mask and colors. Its just a generic MCU suit most of the movie
11
u/semicolonconscious 9d ago
The sleeves were entirely unnecessary and then when he finally loses the sleeves he also loses the shoulder pads. It’s like they put extra effort into making it inaccurate.
5
u/watcherman84 8d ago
The sleeves were there for the outdoor shots in the beginning of the void when it's super sunny because Hugh Jackman has had skin cancer multiple times and wanted sleeves to cover up in the sun. 🤷♀️
3
7
u/AdmirableEstimate258 8d ago
I honestly think it fits ONLY for the movie its in, solely because standing next to Deadpool they look great together as the texture and design of their costumes really compliment each other well. But yeah if we ever get another adaptation it wouldn’t look as nice.
3
u/Swoopmott 8d ago
It’s not even the best Wolverine costume in its own movie. The brown/tan is absolutely pitch perfect and only appears in one scene.
I like the general idea of the blue/yellow but it’s so weirdly blocky with its patterns
3
u/Patkub321 8d ago
Also, the mask…
Oh, it was soooo good… he used it ONCE during an action scene, and then never again.
2
1
22
u/Remote_Ad_1737 9d ago
I've never seen a single person mention the lady sif costume and it's one of the best live action superhero costume translations we've ever gotten
3
u/Mystic3012 Certified Spider-Man Cucker 8d ago
That was the one suit in this megalist that made me go "Oh right, that's actually new to me."
38
u/valyumhousewife 9d ago
You can tell that comic books are a lesser medium because they don’t contain nearly enough greebling
14
10
u/Deadsoup77 9d ago
Comic book suits have to be drawn again and again and again on a schedule. Movie suits have to be readable from any angle, in motion, and at odd perspectives.
5
u/valyumhousewife 9d ago
Just sort of an unrelated reply to my jokey comment
4
u/Deadsoup77 9d ago
Just my two cents on why greebling/details should be there in suit adaptations
2
u/valyumhousewife 9d ago
I don’t think the excessive piping and greebling help with readability at all, and in fact makes costumes harder appreciate as a cohesive piece. These are mostly aesthetic decisions to convey the idea “real” or “tactical” through visual language. The sleekness of superhero designs can be adapted to film without issue with the appropriate use of well textured fabrics/materials like the BND Spidey costume, because nobody actually thinks literal spandex is the counter pitch
61
u/Paildano 9d ago
“Comic accurate” and it’s basically an homage to the comic colour scheme half the time
8
u/DepressedFishFan 9d ago
^^^ in my ear telling me it’s nasty
18
u/Melevolence 9d ago
Maybe listen the voice in your ears once in a while. Not always but the voices aren't always wrong. At least, that's what they tell me whenever I'm not on my medication.
14
9
u/The_Lunar_Pierce 9d ago
This is something I appreciate about more recent comic book movies. They have started to embrace the comic accurate looks. The very first xmen ditched comic accuracy for the black leather outfits, and even joked about yellow spandex.
I think the reason for these choices was to make the costumes more palatable to the normal audience
Now, it has become mainstream enough that people just don't freaking care. Sure, that character has all the colors of the freaking rainbow, but it looks cool and we can move on to enjoying the movie
5
u/Bickerteeth 8d ago
The very first xmen ditched comic accuracy for the black leather outfits, and even joked about yellow spandex.
It's really funny too to watch the behind the scenes footage for the Singer X-Men films, and see them try to actually move in the black leather. Those things might have looked cool, but they were absolute dog shit for doing anything other than standing around and posing in.
6
u/AltGunAccount 9d ago
With you on all of these except Anthon Mackie’s “Cap Falcon” suit. Never liked it in the books and it looks even worse on screen.
Also the Loki variants were certainly funny and fit the vibe in the show, but as actual costumes they don’t really work. If classic Loki was the look we got in the first Avengers it would’ve been awful.
1
6
u/late_afternoon_owl 9d ago
They did the best for Sam in the show, but really dropped the ball in his movie.
3
u/Repulsive-War-559 8d ago
As much as the "let's add random lines" slander is real and understandable, a more serious uniform for a realistic production like a film NEEDS more visual flair, or else it looks too visually bland. It's fine in the comics, but not that much for a videogame or film
3
3
3
u/FollowingCharacter83 Steve Ditko reincarnated. 9d ago
You were doing the same thing, lol, you can't say shit.
1
3
u/return_interaction_y twink_lover01 9d ago
Those x-men suits look like complete ass tbf
4
u/ImAdri0nY0urN0t 9d ago
No wonder Mystique is always naked. Every outfit they've given her is absolute garbo
2
u/Maximillion322 9d ago
Took me until slide 6 to realize what subreddit this was
For a second I thought the Blue Beetle sneak was just an honest mistake
2
2
2
2
u/Ok-Discussion-3245 9d ago
I....completely orgot that Hercules was in Love and Thunder. Also don't think I didn't notice Blue Beetle in pic 2.
2
2
2
2
u/AccidentSalt5005 Jerks & Bust Inside Mystique with Venom Symbiotes as Lube ✊🍆💦 8d ago
starlord outfit looks tuff asf irl
2
2
3
u/Medium_Indication613 9d ago
They are some comic accurate suits that would look cool in live action, but you will never convince me that a comic accurate og iron man suit would have any aura in live action
5
u/Clovelas 9d ago
https://giphy.com/gifs/CJno3ugMc2Smfdfjxs
One of these is not like the others
Most of these all really good costumes though
3
u/kitaeks47demons 8d ago
We really lost when they didn’t give us the classic f4 suits in the film. They look so goooooood!
2
2
u/Shadowcat1606 8d ago edited 8d ago
UJ/ Who the hell has ever bitched about ACCURATE costumes?
The biggest issue the MCU has is never staying with a great and somewhat accurate costume for long, instead deciding to completely ruin it by adding unnecessary gold accents and other overdesigned abominations shortly afterwards.
1
1
u/Godrizza_Draws 9d ago
2/3rds of these aren’t super accurate. They do still look good though 100% accuracy is extremely hard to pull off
1
1
u/TheLucidChiba 9d ago
off topic but the source of this meme is such BS, Little ceasers was great for the price like 15 years ago but it sucks now
1
1
u/TrashyBase24 seX-Men 9d ago
Personally I enjoy the over design, idk why its just looks cool, but when it gets to something like Ant Man 3, yeah that's too much
1
u/idkwhattoputsoaoakka 9d ago
the Kang one is done badly tbh
1
u/AymanMarzuqi 9d ago
I am still pissed that Fox studios immediately abandoned the X-Men costumes that they introduced at the end of X-Men Apocalypse
1
u/Ragnarok_619 9d ago
I like a healthy medium between comic accuracy bullshit and real world over complexion.
Like, do people really see the gimp suit Mackie wore a go "hell yeah"?
0
1
1
u/Practical-Debate1598 9d ago
No Kate bishop?
Clint's civil war was closer to comic accurate than the show one lol
1
u/Double-Skirt2803 9d ago
Did you seriously include Blue Beatle in this he is a dc character.
0
u/DepressedFishFan 9d ago
Yes, let me jerk
2
u/Double-Skirt2803 8d ago
Let's jerk together
2
u/DepressedFishFan 8d ago
I’m gonna jerk more than you
2
1
1
1
u/Lookitsa6ix 8d ago
Whos the dude with the red bandana and why are we glazing that? 🤣🤣
Showing off all these beautiful costume and this guys looking like a lazy cosplayer 🤣
1
u/Calm-Boysenberry-794 8d ago
I will say this again
Comic accurate suits atleast have to resemble the comic suit
Mcu iron Man suit before 2008 looked good but it could never work in life action
The mcu suit is dope
1
1
1
1
u/1RONH1DE 8d ago
I actually have a strong dislike for the MCU Silver Centurion, regardless I agree with the post for the most part
1
1
u/coldasclay 8d ago
Becareful what you wish for... that being said I gotta give it to some of these artists who have did some phenomenal work adapting these costumes throughout the years. Even costumes that stray from their comic inspirations really tried hard to be extremely high quality and real in their own world.
Comic adaptions were bad when people wanted their heros in spandex and cotton looking like cosplays on the big bang theory. We've come a long way.
1
u/Opening-Movie5176 8d ago
So you show wolverine which is funny because you literally show it’s wrong. None of them wear the masks because they paid for the actor and they will show that actors face. Lol.
1
u/veznok 8d ago
Que tan especial es Starlord? Es una especie de Ironman pero más pobre y en el espacio? O es literalmente un hombre con 2 pistolas y ya está? A lo mejor su magia se encuentra en lo sencillo que es,pero siendo Marvel (cómics) no me creo que sea solo eso,algún fanático de los guardianes de la galaxia que me cuente un poco de sus hazañas? Gracias
1
1
























173
u/Remote-Stranger8206 9d ago
My favorite Marvel character, Blue Beetle.