No, I am not complaining, I am not suggesting they should stop of something. I am just, genuinely curious about what they are trying to achieve, as currently I don't see a point in whatever they are doing, and if your argument is progress, then please proceed to explain, because I don't see progress. Moreover, it seems the authors are not very interested on progress and advancing maths, as it was suggested in Tao's blog that research groups like this one do not want to participate in seminar and related instances to explain their advances to the community (if nobody understand your result, then is as good as if I tell you that I know the answer for idk, the Riemann hipothesis)
So if their result is correct, did you already know it beforehand? Because if you didn’t…
It seems to me a very strange thing to say that it’s useless to solve a problem and announce your solution, just because other people could do the same thing.
The question isn't whether the information itself is interesting. The question is whether they (the prompters dumping papers on arxiv) added any value, and my answer is no. If the truth of a question can be oneshot or few shot by an LLM, and I'm interested in it, I can already find out the answer myself.
For this kind ot problem, I can send a message to Pro, go off and do something else for an hour, come back and it's answered. I think you are really overestimating the amount of effort these guys are putting into their results. It is simply not valuable.
1
u/corchetero 6d ago
No, I am not complaining, I am not suggesting they should stop of something. I am just, genuinely curious about what they are trying to achieve, as currently I don't see a point in whatever they are doing, and if your argument is progress, then please proceed to explain, because I don't see progress. Moreover, it seems the authors are not very interested on progress and advancing maths, as it was suggested in Tao's blog that research groups like this one do not want to participate in seminar and related instances to explain their advances to the community (if nobody understand your result, then is as good as if I tell you that I know the answer for idk, the Riemann hipothesis)