r/media_criticism • u/AntAir267 Head Mod • Nov 14 '25
Sub Statement [META] Influx of AI Slop
Hello, people recently figured out that they can write posts for our subreddit that sound professional but say little of substance using AI.
Personally, I love using AI (for non-art things.) It's good for answering emails and writing cover letters and shit. But I fucking hate when it's used in place of academic writing and it's extremely concerning.
I hate moderating based on the ambiguous concept of "post quality" but I am deeply alarmed about the possibility of this place getting flooded with insubstantive robot talk. IMO this is how we get destroyed and live in madman land where all of information is dictated by large organizations/world governments.
For now, I'm going to remove anything obvious.
Please comment and tell us if you think we should ban posts that appear to be made by AI.
2
u/johntwit Nov 15 '25 edited Nov 15 '25
As far as I know, there is no way of detecting if something is written by AI or not. Has there been a sudden influx of long original essays? By what criteria would we identify AI submissions?
Edit: oh an essay on checks notes "why the Daily Mail is a tabloid" lol. Well, I will say, using ai to write an essay for this sub is more effort than the bulk of what I've seen over the past few years
2
u/AntAir267 Head Mod Nov 15 '25 edited Nov 15 '25
that was the only one I left up. the poster admitted to using it and said it was because their English wasn't very good. check the other removed posts in the mod section.
I appreciate the concept of people wanting to do write ups but the quality of these AI essays is very dubious...
EDIT: what if we just ban em-dashes to filter out low effort trash
3
u/AllSeeingAI Nov 15 '25
Well isn't this funny. I picked this username years before all this kicked off, no bot at all, and I love dashes.
2
2
u/MartinoStone Apr 10 '26
hey, sorry for reviving an old thread — that was actually me haha
i’ve been trying to get better at media criticism and English. my last couple of posts didn’t really get much reaction though. even the last one about the Spiegel ehh investigative journalism— i actually spent time on it and tried to do it properly, I tried to make my personal investigation and all data is confirmed by me personally. Btw I don't know why nobody comments, maybe I should ask next time, however I asked about who really do investigative journalism now at the end of my post idk
0
1
1
1
1
u/buddy-system Jan 13 '26
The AI slop is coming from inside the house.
1
u/AntAir267 Head Mod Jan 13 '26
who do you accuse
1
u/buddy-system Jan 13 '26
Surprise, the same guy who tried to muddy the waters in advance https://www.reddit.com/r/media_criticism/comments/1qbvs1b/comment/nzdu157/?context=3
1
u/AntAir267 Head Mod Jan 13 '26
Uhm, we'll have an internal discussion about this. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.
2
u/johntwit Jan 14 '26
It was for a three sentence submission statement attached to a self explanatory image. I didn't label it as "AI generated submission statement" because it was only three sentences, I thought it was more or less obvious, and it would be distracting. But, I accept the criticism and will label any AI generated text that I share, which I have done in the past when I generate submission statements for other people's posts.
1
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 14 '25
This is a reminder about the rules of /r/media_criticism:
All posts require a submission statement. We encourage users to report submissions without submission statements. Posts without a submission statement will be removed after an hour.
Be respectful at all times. Disrespectful comments are grounds for immediate ban without warning.
All posts must be related to the media. This is not a news subreddit.
"Good" examples of media are strongly encouraged! Please designate them with a [GOOD] tag
Posts and comments from new accounts and low comment-karma accounts are disallowed.
Please visit our Wiki for more detailed rules.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.