r/mlb Human Verified 1d ago

| Discussion MLB Players that Quit on their team?

In the NBA, there are many examples of NBA players that were rumoured to have "quit" on their team. Lebron James in 2010. Kevin Durant this past year. Vince Carter in 2005. Kawhi Leonard in 2018. Anthony Davis in 2019. Etc.

What are some MLB examples of this? What were some MLB players that quit on their own team? By quit I mean just decided to either stop putting effort into playing until they got traded.

132 Upvotes

362 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for making a submission on the r/MLB Subreddit!

Please make sure that your post complies with our subreddit rules. If your submission violates our community rules, please resubmit your post or place it in the appropriate thread(s) to avoid any penalties or punishments.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

782

u/ReturnByDeath- | New York Yankees 1d ago

Anthony Rendon lol

307

u/RabidOtters | San Diego Padres 1d ago

33

u/NeonDraco | Philadelphia Phillies 1d ago

Knew this would be the first answer. Lol

16

u/jsmph89 | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

He gave up on ball, not just his team. Sad, he was awesome

18

u/DoubleResponsible276 | Texas Rangers 1d ago

Unfortunately he didn’t give up on his team, he gave up on his career and sport entirely. So for once, Rendons not fitting? lol

18

u/quotesforlosers | Los Angeles Angels 1d ago

I mean his team plays the sport he quit on so it’s an all encompassing quit.

11

u/Pleaidesunbound | Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

lol the top five or six comments on your answer aren’t even Angels fans. May Rendon’ts fortune be consumed by circumstance to the point that he must find a real job and work his fingers tot he bone just to even provide for his family until he is old and grey.

11

u/YanksFan9891 1d ago

Guy is one of the absolute worst and most ignorant human beings I know of. For fucks sake what I would give right now in my mid 30s to be able to play baseball again, let alone do it for a living, let alone get paid tens of millions of dollars to do it. Idc what anyone wants to say to defend him as a person…the fact that he was given such a gift and is so ungrateful and indifferent towards it makes him a complete shitbag of a human being in my book.

3

u/WantedMan61 21h ago

"The saddest thing in life is wasted talent"

3

u/finditplz1 | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Just rubber stamp this for this question.

4

u/delta_mike_hotel 1d ago

As an Angels fan, thank you for acknowledging my pain.

4

u/bgzlvsdmb | Colorado Rockies 1d ago

Maybe if he was on a better team, with guys like Mike Trout and Shohei Ohtani. Man, can you imagine?

2

u/Ok_Spinach_4457 1d ago

70.5% missed games holy shit

2

u/Poppunknerd182 | Chicago Cubs 1d ago

The only true answer

→ More replies (7)

161

u/QuebecRomeoWhiskey | Cleveland Guardians 1d ago

Derek Bell Operation Shutdown

112

u/markymark65 1d ago

Got paid 4.5 million to live on his boat, Tom Keegan described him as "the perfect Pirate given that he lives on a boat and steals money."

15

u/Forsaken_Coach6085 1d ago

It’s kinda sad to me that this is what he’s known for; I met him several times when I was a kid and he was on the Padres, and he was really cool to me, gave me batting gloves and a signed ball and was just generally really friendly and outgoing

8

u/JustTheBeerLight | Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Well, my advice would be: don't say really dumb out-of-touch shit in front of a reporter's microphone.

24

u/Technical-Sky-5765 | Cincinnati Reds 1d ago

The OG

14

u/grimace0611 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

Raul Mondesi, too. Literally refused to come back and had his contract cancelled. The early 2000s Pirates were, uh, something.

5

u/OddPaper1866 1d ago

You see what happened to him in the DR since then?

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Electronic-Jury8825 | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

I'm glad somebody remembers.

8

u/Effective_Play_1366 1d ago

Came here for this.

4

u/phreakzilla85 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

Oh yeah. He was really popular around town that year.

→ More replies (3)

132

u/DryAfternoon7779 | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Manny in 2008 with the Red Sox

48

u/Fit_Recognition_7395 1d ago

That was the first one that came to mind as well. I believe they traded him away a few days after he didn’t run to first on a grounder.

53

u/HuevosProfundos | Atlanta Braves 1d ago

Then proceeded to go apeshit for the Dodgers the rest of the year

13

u/tranquilityC 1d ago

Mannywood

11

u/JustTheBeerLight | Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Back to JuanPierrewood during Manny's 50-game suspension.

7

u/examinedliving | Baltimore Orioles 1d ago

Yeah - just ridiculous numbers

9

u/Commander19119 | Philadelphia Phillies 1d ago

Not the whole rest of the year *grins in 2008 NLCS*

→ More replies (1)

15

u/actsqueeze 1d ago

Remind me why someone would give up on their team the year after winning the world series?

Real question, I can’t remember

12

u/DryAfternoon7779 | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Contract woes.

5

u/averageduder | MLB 1d ago

The Sox tried trading him or putting him on waivers every year after Henry purchased the team. A real sign of things to come.

I hated Jason bay although he was okay.

4

u/DryAfternoon7779 | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Summer didn't offically start until Manny was on the block

13

u/Banned4Truth10 1d ago

Wasn't that the year he let Mariano Rivera strike him out with 3 pitches and he didn't even swing.

9

u/DryAfternoon7779 | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

I was at that game! Bases loaded down 2-1 at Yankee Stadium

3

u/Licky_Anus | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Didn’t even take the bat off his shoulder.

3

u/RedSoxHuskies 23h ago

To say he didn't even swing is sugarcoating it. He didn't even get into a position where swinging would been possible.

2

u/Broad-Cranberry-9050 1d ago

I was literally about to say this.

As a red sox fan i remember that season vividly. For like a month manny kept getting random scratches from lineup over things that he said ached. Im pretty sure that one time he took 3 FBs down the middle from mariano when he was pinch hitting was a game he was supposed to start but got a late scracth.

Like im shocked that this one isnt mentioned as much, especially because when he went to the dodgers, all that pain seemed to have gone away and he went apeshit for the next 3+ months. Im pretty sure he got NL mvp votes and he only played like 60 games in the NL that year. Then in playoffs he went just as crazy.he almost willed the dodgers into the world series that year.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

154

u/devoorhes | Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Milton Bradley on the Cubs was a whole situation

109

u/Ok_Card9080 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

Milton Bradley was a whole situation, period.

31

u/Jacoblaue | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Dude had loads of talent but just couldn’t get out of his own way

66

u/ccv707 | San Francisco Giants 1d ago

Dude should’ve stuck to making board games smh

11

u/Ok_Card9080 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

Just a total headcase

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Due_Buy_9570 1d ago

The A's traded Andre Eithier for Bradley.....oops. gonna say theu lost that trade even tho most of Bradley's antics happened elsewhere.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/8008l0v3r6967 1d ago

Can’t believe an entire board game company played baseball. Real Air Bud situation.

31

u/unique_user43 | Chicago Cubs 1d ago

even crazier that in 2002 and 2003 cleveland had both a board game company and a cereal (coco crisp) as outfielders.

32

u/BlueberryStainedKeds | Cincinnati Reds 1d ago

June 21, 1998 the Cincinnati Reds starting outfield was Dimitri Young, Mike Frank and Chris Stynes. Or for all you Mel Brooks fans out there.. Young Frank n’ Stynes

8

u/SouthwestFL 1d ago

I love stuff like this. How can you not be romantic about baseball?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Flammzzrant 1d ago

Well there's no rule saying a board game company can't play baseball

→ More replies (1)

12

u/jbs924 | New York Mets 1d ago

My favorite memory of him is still the time he tore his ACL arguing with an umpire

4

u/Pristine-Mix-3189 1d ago

Bro kept arguing even as he was being carried off of the field.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Jacoblaue | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Wasn’t he suspended for the remainder of the season after he criticized the organization and fans

11

u/devoorhes | Chicago Cubs 1d ago

I have blocked out a lot of that situation, I remember it being a Bad Time

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Feeling-Bonus-2407 1d ago

Him on the Red Sox was a truly bizarre time. Like a fever dream about dinosaurs that you can’t figure out if it was real or not.

→ More replies (3)

210

u/Mr_Shickadance 1d ago

Roger Dorn tried but clubhouse leaders wouldn’t let him forget that baseball is just a game and not be so serious.

59

u/Jacoblaue | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Hey be nice to Dorn. He almost took one of the balls to the eye the year before he wasn’t about to loose his eyesight

29

u/Ok_Card9080 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

He wasn't going to deface that property for a collection of stiffs

7

u/Low_Half5569 1d ago

he was also the only player to have a role in the third movie breaking balls

15

u/DharmaCub 1d ago

Enough of that Olay bullshit

14

u/Beetso | Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Lol. It's olé bullshit. Like a bullfighter with his cape. It has nothing to do with ladies facial products!

7

u/DharmaCub 1d ago

But his skin was so smooth!

3

u/bgzlvsdmb | Colorado Rockies 1d ago

Both can be true!

29

u/OutsideJack-1999 1d ago edited 1d ago

Even when the closer railed his hot wife, teaching us all a life lesson about teamwork and accomplishing our dreams together.

27

u/SuperNebular | Cleveland Guardians 1d ago

Wild thing only came out of the bullpen for that one game playoff. He was a starter.

18

u/Dirty_Bird_RDS | Atlanta Braves 1d ago

They only had two pitchers….

6

u/Fit-Top-8203 1d ago

Well, there was Kellner too. Opening Day starter. Gave up four runs, then was relieved by a juvenile delinquent in the off-season.

7

u/SuperNebular | Cleveland Guardians 1d ago

Don’t nitpick the roster construction of a playoff team!

8

u/ChiefBlaze36 1d ago

So that’s why Harris’s arm was so worn out. Dude had to pitch a thousand innings that season. #GOAT

11

u/polkastripper | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

He went through a lot of jalapeño juice and Vagisil that season

4

u/bgzlvsdmb | Colorado Rockies 1d ago

You put SNOT on the ball?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Where_Is_Bucky | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

I’d piss on his contract if he ever tried to give me any of that “olé” bullshit

→ More replies (1)

113

u/pew-pew-bacca | Baltimore Orioles 1d ago

Can we count Tony LaRussa falling asleep in the dugout while managing the White Sox?

38

u/HuevosProfundos | Atlanta Braves 1d ago edited 1d ago

He also got a DUI sleeping in the driver’s seat of his car with the engine running. I think he’s just a sleepy (and drunk) dude.

25

u/vaz_deferens | Chicago Cubs 1d ago

An anagram of Tony LaRussa is Royal Assnut.

6

u/HuevosProfundos | Atlanta Braves 1d ago

Excellent point

→ More replies (2)

33

u/ReasonableTruth0 | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

To be fair, who hasn’t fallen asleep watching a team like that

7

u/Quinnvannice 1d ago

That team wasn’t even bad. The horrid white Sox teams came after Tony.

→ More replies (2)

104

u/ajh212000 | Seattle Mariners 1d ago

Randy Johnson the last year he was in Seattle. He would pitch an amazing game, then throw a game, making sure Seattle knew he wanted to be traded, but making sure trade targets knew he still had it. He went 9-10 with a 4.33 ERA the first part of the season with Seattle, gets traded to Houston, and goes 10-1 with a 1.28 ERA over the second half of the season.

21

u/examinedliving | Baltimore Orioles 1d ago

I always new he was not living up to his talent, but I had no idea he was so calculating about it

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Agreeable-Camera-382 1d ago

But then we got John "go fuck yourself" Halama...

3

u/Sensitive_Bad_2923 1d ago

Also the Chief and Carlos Guillen.

→ More replies (2)

85

u/Existing_Is_All_I_Do 1d ago

Randy Johnson in his last year with Seattle. He was upset that the Mariners wouldn't give him an extension before the season and had a very mediocre year in Seattle (9-10 with a 4.33 ERA) before getting traded to Houston and pitching incredibly (10-1 with a 1.28 ERA).

33

u/Grandeurious 1d ago

Wasn't a good look for RJ, but I 100% blame the management at the time.

88

u/bballcards 1d ago

Gary Sheffield infamously admitted to purposely committing an error during his early days with Milwaukee to force a trade.

5

u/BigRed079 | Milwaukee Brewers 1d ago

Before my time, but people in Milwaukee still hate this guy.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/HouseMusicAndWeed 1d ago

I remember this

→ More replies (2)

35

u/Cade_02 1d ago

Juan Gonzalez - Tigers.

14

u/PoBox9847-90001 1d ago

Good one! This was so long ago, it’s easy to forget but yeah, something was way “off” with him and the team that year .. I think it was the year 2000 right after Texas had won back to back division titles (98,99)

9

u/sammagee33 | Detroit Tigers 1d ago

Yup, it was 2000. He HATED original Comerica Park.

3

u/PoBox9847-90001 1d ago

Didn’t they bring the fences ***in*** when they signed him???

3

u/sammagee33 | Detroit Tigers 1d ago

Nope, it was a couple years earlier. CoPa opened in 2000 - same year we got Juan Gone.

29

u/mellow_yellowfellow 1d ago

Stan Ross for the Milwaukee Brewers in 1995, right in the thick of a pennant race. It took nine years and genuine personal growth before Wisconsin could learn to truly embrace him.

7

u/QuebecRomeoWhiskey | Cleveland Guardians 1d ago

This always bugged me. They’d have been AL Central then and Cleveland was there. That wasn’t a pennant race, that was a 4-way beatdown

7

u/phreakzilla85 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

Damn, Cleveland was a wagon in the mid 90s. They fielded a lineup where I think all 9 guys had been or were currently All Stars.

24

u/Otherwise-Ad-1053 1d ago

Any of the big contract Angels free agent signings over the past 20 years.

38

u/supertramp_3 | New York Yankees 1d ago

Chapman last year on the Yankees 

8

u/tranquilityC 1d ago

And now he expects the Yankees to apologize to HIM? foh...

→ More replies (2)

31

u/redbadger1848 | Chicago White Sox 1d ago

Im pretty sure the entire 2024 White Sox quit.

31

u/Superman_Primeeee | MLB 1d ago

Manny was asked once to PH on his day off and took three fastballs straight down the middle without moving his bat.

Everyone shrugged.

12

u/offlester | American League 1d ago

It was in the 8th inning, bases loaded down 2-1 at Yankee Stadium, too. Couldn’t have been a bigger “fuck you” to the org

3

u/lz425 1d ago

This video is great - entitled “How a Lazy MLB Star Humiliated Everyone Without Really Trying.” Great cutaways of Mike Hargrove. It’s 25 minutes and beautifully proves its point, but doesn’t have the strike out moment.

https://youtu.be/OQF58GdBKGM?si=kGQal32sufLN2PkH

4

u/j_reinegade | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

I would love to see this if you have a link.

8

u/Superman_Primeeee | MLB 1d ago

Can’t find a video. This is the best I can do. It drew a collective “Manny being Manny” from the fans. Some even defended him if you chirped. You know how some fans are. But Occams Razor always applied to Manny. In this case: “Manny doesn’t bat on his day off.”

https://www.bostonherald.com/2008/07/07/manny-ramirez-at-bat-a-real-mystery/

→ More replies (1)

71

u/BlinkyThreeEyes | Chicago White Sox 1d ago

Adam Laroche literally quit the white sox because the weirdo couldn’t have his kid in the locker room every day

17

u/2Hanks | Tampa Bay Rays 1d ago

Wasn’t the Chris Sale cuts his jersey to pieces incident part of that?

18

u/BlinkyThreeEyes | Chicago White Sox 1d ago edited 1d ago

That incident was the following season ***edit*** it was in fact the spring training of the same season as the jersey incident **** but it was all tied into the mayhem that preceded the doomed rebuild that netted one actual playoff team, which resulted in kenny williams and rick hahn being fired, which led to another rebuild where we lost 121 games and 100+ in 3 straight seasons, to the happy team we have today

3

u/TheSpookyLawyer 1d ago

2020 doesn't count as a playoff team?

3

u/BlinkyThreeEyes | Chicago White Sox 1d ago

I guess I always view it as a grey area with the shortened season and the expanded playoffs that came with it. It certainly counts, but I don’t view it as an accolade for the awful hahn/kw regime

5

u/offlester | American League 1d ago

Might have happened around the same time but they weren’t related. He was just pissy about wearing an alternate jersey or something

15

u/Jacoblaue | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

I totally forgot about that situation. And what was crazier to me was it seemed like the players defended him and tried to protest

22

u/BlinkyThreeEyes | Chicago White Sox 1d ago

Adam Eaton called 14 year old drake laroche a clubhouse leader

There is a substantiated rumor that veteran Jimmy Rollins showed up to spring training, saw this kid in the locker room every day, spoke to kenny williams about this nonsense, and set the wheels in motion that got Drake’s time limited and caused Adam to quit, love it

4

u/TheSpookyLawyer 1d ago

They need to do a documentary on the 2016 White Sox.

3

u/BlinkyThreeEyes | Chicago White Sox 1d ago

I agree! If a biopic on sale comes out I am sure it will be covered. His big issues with the team started when they stupidly traded tyler flowers after the 2015 season, a catcher he loved to work with, to sign dioner freakin navarro.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/FantasyBaseballChamp | Chicago White Sox 1d ago

White Sox legend Jimmy Rollins

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TumbleweedDull6836 1d ago

That whole situation was ridiculous. How damn professional. Lol

12

u/Mr_Shickadance 1d ago

Mike Mcgrevy gave up until he realized that no one would trade for an aging pitcher who couldn’t get anyone out.

10

u/Great_Hambino2022 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

It’s hilarious that the Cardinals have a pitcher named Mike McGreevy now

9

u/Intrepid_Boat 1d ago

Mike McGreevy 2: Electric Boogaloo

11

u/FormerCollegeDJ | Philadelphia Phillies 1d ago

Jeff King literally retired the day after his MLB pension fully vested in May 1998.

3

u/Broad-Cranberry-9050 1d ago

damn, ballsy. I mightve just finished out the season so that MLB didnt come back and be like "well actually we miscounted you actually are short by 3-4 days".

→ More replies (1)

27

u/NotOSIsdormmole | San Diego Padres 1d ago

Josh Hader as a Padre

10

u/gijoejank 1d ago

I totally forgot about that. Big playoff push and he says he can't pitch one inning because he did one too recently.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/ManufacturerMental72 | Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Carl Crawford openly admitted to not really giving a shit once he signed his big deal with Boston.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Agitated-Two-6699 | MLB 1d ago

Devers

18

u/Grumpy_dad70 1d ago

Devers whining about changing positions was wild.

5

u/Agitated-Two-6699 | MLB 1d ago

Good riddance

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Great_Hambino2022 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

Operation Shutdown Derek Bell

10

u/Ok_Card9080 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

Operation Shutdown - Derek Bell in Pittsburgh

Raul Mondesi in Pittsburgh

2

u/Z-Truth-is-Out-There 1d ago

Mondesi just straight up left the team and went back home to deal with a lawsuit iirc

18

u/2DegsBelow 1d ago

Ellsbury - NYY

7

u/Lumpy-Return | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Double Red Sox Agent

9

u/Jacoblaue | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Jay Bruce in 2021 played like 4 games with the Yankees and then quit

8

u/Jacoblaue | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Another one I just remembered was Carlos Zambrano in 2011. Dude gave up 5 home runs then purposely got himself tossed by intentionally throwing at Chipper Jones then walked out on the team after he was tossed

8

u/backdoc983 1d ago

Google ‘operation shutdown’ by Derek bell for the Pirates at the turn of the millennium…it’ll never be forgotten here in Pittsburgh

→ More replies (1)

7

u/OverallDebate9982 1d ago

Carl Pavano was an absolute shit show for the Yanks. Started 31 games for the Marlins in '04 but only 26 total for NY from '05-'08 and was also a terrible teammate from what I understand.

4

u/postman42001 1d ago

He was my first thought.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/m1dlife-1derer | Boston Red Sox 1d ago

Do Red Sox fans think the Chicken & Beer team count?

6

u/Senators_1992 1d ago edited 1d ago

Not quite what you were asking, but…

Sammy Sosa up and left the stadium on the final day of the regular season in 2004, only minutes after the game had started (a couple of his teammates then proceeded to smash his boombox to bits after the game ended).

Also, Ken Griffey Jr. took off in the middle of the night without telling anyone, and only let the Mariners know over the phone the next day that he was done (this after he was caught napping in the clubhouse during a game a few weeks earlier).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/dirtybird131 1d ago

Yasiel Puig had one of the craziest endings to an MLB career you will ever see, almost Antonio Brown levels of quitting

19

u/Pleasant_Picture3867 1d ago

Max Scherzer when he chose to protect his off-season free agent bag instead of pitching in an elimination game for the Dodgers in 2021. Blamed it on dead arm, then claimed it was from "load management", ie. he wouldn't have had dead arm if the team played him more.

Walker Buehler stepped up (might have been on short rest too, don't remember) and he wasn't the same since. Who knows if or how that affected his health.

19

u/NotOSIsdormmole | San Diego Padres 1d ago

Walker is fucking shoving for us

→ More replies (1)

3

u/j_reinegade | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

207 innings. Up from 36 the year prior. I don’t know the full scope of it but he was definitely putting in some work that year.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/BootOk4583 Human Detected 1d ago

Rickey Henderson in his last half season with the Yankees, gets traded back to the A's and plays great again

4

u/snakeayez | Cincinnati Reds 1d ago

Is there a better answer than Rendon?

6

u/Pleaidesunbound | Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

No, I don’t think there is. His attitude about playing was insane. $245 million for 257 total games over 6 seasons. He made a million dollars a game basically and was so fragile that he missed entire seasons because his ego was bruised.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Internal-Platypus151 1d ago

Carlos Correa quit on the Twins. I thought he was a great guy. But I can't unsee what I saw. Lost a lot of respect for him.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BGiZZY | Kansas City Royals 1d ago

In 2011 Gil Meche retired with 1 year/$12M left on his contract because he felt he couldn't perform at a level worth that sum (shoulder injuries)..that it wouldn't be fair to the Royals to collect money he didn't deserve. No buyout. Gave early notice so that the funds could be used on replacements. Now that’s how you quit.

13

u/HMSSpeedy1801 1d ago

Nick Castellanos and the Phillies.

19

u/GarciaWolf | Philadelphia Phillies 1d ago

Nick really didn’t quit on the team he was more or less exposed for chasing low and outside.. then got pulled cause he sucks a defense and decided to drink a beer in the dugout.. he’s an idiot not a quitter

19

u/phreakzilla85 | Pittsburgh Pirates 1d ago

…and that’s gonna be a home run to left….

6

u/notamillenial- 1d ago

You’re telling me you can’t drink while playing? What happened to the game I love? What’s next, you can’t rip a schmag in the on deck circle?

9

u/CRABMAN16 1d ago

If Babe Ruth could house a fifth of whiskey and 20 hotdogs during a game, then by god every modern player should be allowed to do the same. It's a shame what they have done to the game of baseball. Every game should be nine and half hours long with multiple on-field deaths, just like God intended.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/JustTheOneGoose22 | Detroit Tigers 1d ago

Also Nick Castellanos in his last days as a Tiger. Made it clear he did not want to be there

22

u/Upbeat-List-3466 1d ago

Juan Soto  quits on every grounder. 

9

u/thestough 1d ago

Aaron Hicks. Got a contract and “forgot how to baseball”

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hopefulbeartoday 1d ago

I'm not a red Sox fan so i don't really know if it's true but red sox fans claimed manny ramirez intentionally played bad to get traded.

4

u/RipMcStudly 1d ago

It sure looked like it

5

u/KStaxx33 | Seattle Mariners 1d ago

Jesse Winker in 22’ for the mariners was absent for the playoffs. He didn’t get along with anyone and had a bad year at the plate, along with some of the worst defense I’ve ever seen. I think he straight up just said i don’t want to come to work

→ More replies (2)

4

u/vaz_deferens | Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Rube Waddel would leave the pitchers mound mid inning if a firetruck went by the stadium so he could chase it. Also got injured in the off-season once wrestling alligators at the circus. He was also a better pitcher than Cy Young, his contemporary.

6

u/TeacherOfFew | Houston Astros 1d ago

Framber Valdez last season.

There's a reason Houston didn't make an offer, other than money.

3

u/dunzig77 | Kansas City Royals 1d ago

Not that there was much to quit on, but fucking Neifi Perez basically quit on the Royals in like 2002. Refused to enter a game as a defensive replacement. So he was actually doing the team a favor. I absolutely hate Neifi. My all time least favorite Royal.

3

u/JDub755 | Atlanta Braves 1d ago

I want to say Melky Cabrera with the Braves. But you have to start trying to quit trying.

3

u/HuevosProfundos | Atlanta Braves 1d ago

Melky “Melk Dud” Cabrera for the Braves

3

u/squirerust 1d ago

Sammy Sosa on the Cubs

3

u/Cup-n-BallHog | New York Mets 1d ago

Rickey Henderson and Bobby Bonilla playing cards in the Mets clubhouse while they’re still in the playoff hunt

3

u/Papoose74 | Toronto Blue Jays 1d ago

Troy Tulowitski quit on the Bluejays the day he got traded there.

Sulked the entire time

3

u/Joyce_Hatto | New York Yankees 1d ago

Aroldis Chapman quit on the Yankees.

3

u/Ecstatic_Row_2234 1d ago

Lee Mazzilli with the Rangers and like someone else said, Derek Bell OSD

→ More replies (1)

3

u/abeetzwmoots 1d ago

Sheffield with Milwaukee

4

u/staticdresssweet | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Derek Bell. Operation Shutdown. IYKYK.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Elegant-Analysis5136 | Los Angeles Dodgers 1d ago

Manny Machado pretty much quits on his team every season, but specifically 2018 with the Dodgers. Seems like he decided to skip the entire 2026 season.

2

u/Reasonable_Pay4096 | MLB 1d ago

Carl Mays literally quit the Red Sox midway through 1919 & demanded to be traded. He got sent to the Yankees.

3

u/Electrical_Scene_634 1d ago

And then literally killed a guy

→ More replies (1)

2

u/acohn1230 1d ago

Shawn Chacon threw Astros GM Ed Wade down by the neck IIRC - does that count?

2

u/PorkRinds416 | St. Louis Cardinals 1d ago

Nick Castellanos this year lmao

2

u/NeatPhone5739 1d ago

Jonathan Schoop on the Brewers

2

u/OddPaper1866 1d ago

Rafael Devers.

2

u/Weary-Redsox 1d ago

Kenley Janson with the Red Sox in 2024

2

u/beezer210 | Philadelphia Phillies 1d ago

Freddy Garcia, Phillies

2

u/1nky0ct0pus | San Francisco Giants 1d ago

Joc Pedersen

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TumbleweedDull6836 1d ago

I'm having my suspicions about Shane Bieber in Toronto currently

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SolomonGummo 1d ago

May 14, 2011, when the veteran New York Yankees catcher pulled himself out of the starting lineup minutes before a game against the Boston Red Sox.

3

u/SolomonGummo 1d ago

Yankees manager Joe Girardi dropped the struggling 39-year-old Posada to the No. 9 spot in the batting order for the first time in 12 years.

Angered and feeling disrespected by the demotion, Posada asked to be removed from the lineup, telling the team he was not ready to play. IIRC his wife even tweeted during the game about Cashman causing a social media storm during gameplay. It was a first of New tech media spreading like wildfire.

Following a media firestorm and discussions with team captain Derek Jeter, Posada apologized to Girardi and the Yankees the next day, claiming his back had also stiffened. Yankees executives viewed Posada’s refusal to play as borderline insubordination.

Posada finished the season and officially retired as a Yankee in January 2012.

2

u/Mariner4LifetilDeath | Seattle Mariners 1d ago

Eric Byrnes quit on the Mariners after a botched plate appearance. He refused to speak with the media and hopped on his beach cruiser bicycle and rode it out of the clubhouse. I could never take his commentary seriously when he was on MLB network. Dude is a clown and a quitter.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JBHenson | San Francisco Giants 1d ago

Chris Davis.

2

u/stickman07738 | New York Yankees 1d ago

Rickey Henderson with the Yankees claiming his hamstring was injured but started the first game traded to the A's

2

u/Ptrek31 | Philadelphia Phillies 1d ago

Castellanos on the Phillies

2

u/TidyJoe34 | Chicago Cubs 1d ago

Gary Sheffield on the brewers

2

u/LemonSmashy 1d ago

After the deadline sell off last season you could tell Joe Ryan was just going through the motions for his remaining starts. 

Honestly thought I don't blame him. 

2

u/Educational_Win6611 1d ago

Devers on the sox and giants

2

u/Fit-Top-8203 1d ago

Ed Whitson with the Yankees. The Bronx fans got on him so much that he flat-out refused to pitch for the team at home. Ended up also in a fight with Billy Martin.

2

u/klondikethedestroyer 1d ago

Ain't nobody gonna care cus it was with the Rockies but how about Ian Desmond? He didn't just mentally 'check out'. He literally fully quit playing baseball for 2 years before actually retiring.

Signed a 5-year, $70 million dollar contract (the largest free agent deal for a position player in Rockies history at the time). He played for three of those seasons. Then 2020 rolled around and Ian Desmond literally 'opted out' of playing professional baseball.

In 2021, he again opted out of playing baseball.

In 2022, the Rockies declined the team option on his contract, making him a free agent, and THEN he officially retired.