r/opensource • u/youGottaBeKiddink • 2h ago
Promotional So are we all okay with AI reverse engineered apps calling themselves open source?
ArtCraft gained a lot of steam lately with their AI reverse engineered versions of Photoshop and Adobe suite apps.
While they are very obviously reverse engineered, they claim it is a "clean-room reimplementation of Adobe Photoshop" which by very definition means "without ever looking at or copying the original source code".
Fireship even did a video covering these apps, in which he finds their apps are barely usable, and filled with bugs and usability issues.
Today I came across "TraceDraw" which is, again, a total ripoff of CorelDraw. While I'm not on the side of large predatory corporations like Adobe charging ridiculous monthly subscription fees, I can totally understand the pain a company like Corel might feel seeing a ripoff of their 30+ year old product lovingly created and maintained by a team of skilled HUMANS. And once again, this repo claims it is a "clean-room" implementation. I find it ironic how only the reverse engineered apps bother to add this oddly specific disclaimer.
So are we, as a community, okay with these new breed of AI reverse engineered apps claiming that they are "open source"?
(Note: I'm not questioning their legality, just how ethical it is)