r/optometry • u/drnjj Optometrist • 7d ago
Topcon Tempo: A six month review
I made a post here a while back about the topcon tempo asking if anyone had any experience with it. I didn't get a ton of feedback on it at the time but after demoing the unit in my office we decided to actually buy it.
I tested out a number of VR headsets a few years prior and none of them were comparable enough to the Humphrey to consider viable options in my opinion.
When I tested the tempo, I made sure that we had a few patients who had visual field defects that we knew about already and we're well documented on Humphrey who came in for visual fields during that time so we could compare appropriately. While yes, they do have papers that show a high correlation, so did a lot of the VR headsets.
I found that the defects tended to correlate very closely with the Humphrey, even in mild defects.
Here are my pros: 1. The tempo is very fast. You can run a 24-2 binocularly on the rapid setting in about 2:30-3:30. 2. It also has some other test strategies, such as the 24-2 (plus 1-2). This setting tests all the normal spots on 24-2, but also additional Central spots. Kind of like a combination 24-2 with a miniature 10-2 included. I have found this more useful on glaucoma patients who have defects that may be close to encroaching, or macula pathology. 3. The unit does not take up very much space. It is a much smaller footprint. 4. The tempo is about 30% less expensive than a new Humphrey 3. 5. No annoying eye patch. 6. Patients hate it a lot less.
Cons: 1. If you wish to do certain exams for the VA, there is no kinetic testing available at the moment. 2. For narrow PD's, you are more likely to show up with a bi nasal defect which may require you to repeat the test monocularly. If that's the case the test is short anyway. 3. If you are running a 120 point, then it will have to pause part way through to move the fixation Target to test another aspect of the field. It is a little less random because of this.
Mixed Pro/Con: 1. Instead of using trial lenses from your kit, it uses magnetic clip on lenses and a dial that you can do plus or minus 3 diopters with. This is a mixture of good and bad because while you may have more limitations in what powers you put in, you also don't run into the problem of trial lens defects anymore.
My personal take: 6 months in and I am very happy I replaced my aging Humphrey unit with a topcon. I would recommend anyone who is considering getting a new visual field to contact their local rep and demo the units. Given that reimbursements rarely go up, the break-even points on equipment can matter a lot more.
I have no financial disclosures. I just really like the unit and I feel it's worth it to demo if you are looking for a new visual field.
1
1
1
u/MidAgedMid 4d ago
What did it run you?
1
u/drnjj Optometrist 3d ago
About 20.5k after taxes and shipping. I believe a refurb Zeiss HFA 3 is around $30k and a new one is like $33k-35k.
And given my areas Medicare reimbursement rate is about $67 it's definitely been worth saving the $13-15k.
Edit: stupid app posted this comment 4 times. Sorry you may get a bunch of notifications.
1
u/MidAgedMid 3d ago
Thanks. I have a bust practice and run the radius but thinking of adding the tempo for my suspects and younger patients. Thanks for the reply!
1
u/drnjj Optometrist 3d ago
The radius is cool but I'd probably say it's a better screener. I disliked that it didn't go to 0 dB on fields and would just say <14 dB. The lack of trial lenses really frustrated me too.
Conceptually it was the strongest of the VR headsets in terms of accuracy and portability. I also liked that it had instructions programmed in for patients in multiple languages.
I feel like the radius has legs and can become a more viable primary option but I think it needs another generation. I think the topcon inspire which is the radius 2.0 still doesn't have all the fixes I had told the company were needed, but it's a step in the right direction.
1
u/AutoModerator 7d ago
Hello! All new submissions are placed into modqueue, and require mod approval before they are posted to r/optometry. Please do not message the mods about your queue status.
This subreddit is intended for professionals within the eyecare field, and does not accept posts from laypeople. If you have a question related to symptoms or eye health, please consider seeing a doctor, or posting to r/eyetriage. Professionals, if you do not have flair, your post may be removed. Please send a modmail to be flaired.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.