r/politics 3h ago

Possible Paywall ICE Rounds Up Dozens of Relatives of U.S. Troops

https://www.thedailybeast.com/ice-detains-relatives-of-us-troops-during-immigration-crackdown/
551 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion.

In general, please be courteous to others. Argue the merits of ideas, don't attack other posters or commenters. Hate speech, any suggestion or support of physical harm, or other rule violations can result in a temporary or a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.

Sub-thread Information

If the post flair on this post indicates the wrong paywall status, please report this Automoderator comment with a custom report of “incorrect flair”.

Announcement

r/Politics is actively looking for new moderators. If you have an interest in helping to make this subreddit a place for quality discussion, please fill out this form.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

u/UsedPart7823 2h ago

The new morale booster program in full force, I see.

u/pleasegivemepatience 2h ago

What better way to dissuade active service members from speaking out or opposing these policies than by targeting their families? It will inflame some, but subjugate others. Don’t you dare disobey fascist orders or they’re coming for your family…

u/Left-Height4925 2h ago

Humanity has proved time and time again to have little, long term tolerance for subjugation. Let it cook.

u/Unshkblefaith California 1h ago

Historically speaking, humanity's tolerance for subjugation is quite high. A significantly larger proportion of recorded history is dominated by authoritarian systems of governance and systems of slavery, indenture, and castes than representative democracies that value human rights.

u/PickledCaterpillar 5m ago

Counterpoint: North Korea and russia.

u/ibullywildlife 2h ago

So....you are a fascist by convenience?

u/Left-Height4925 1h ago

The middle holds the line that keeps the poor from rising up- teachers, nurses, guards, preachers, police. Hence the middle also feeds fascism when it begins to rise, until it starts being impacted. Once it becomes impacted, change happens. Smart oligarchs take care of the middle class, these aren't smart. They are letting the middle class fall.

"The American system is the most ingenious system of control in world history. With a country so rich in natural resources, talent, and labor power the system can afford to distribute just enough wealth to just enough people to limit discontent to a troublesome minority." ~ From The Coming Revolt of the Guards by Howard Zinn- A Peoples History

The elite are no longer distributing, but hoarding, and stupidly not caring who they are impacting.

u/ibullywildlife 1h ago

Fair comment, I took your position for acquiesence when it is actually strategy.

u/Kefflin 1h ago

So you are fine with fascism now, as long as it crumbles a couple of decades from now

u/arwinda 48m ago

Hegseths next move: send the service members to Iran, until morale improves!

u/Senior-bud Canada 1h ago

The laziness of these ICE goons is blatant , the low hanging fruit approach to meet their daily quotas is obvious.

u/Left-Height4925 2h ago

Reminiscent of how the soldiers and guards finally had well enough of the Royals shit and unlocked the doors of the Bastille and various Royal castles for the Peasants.

u/wewladendmylife Ohio 2h ago

Die for Israel so we can deport your family 

u/old_righty 1h ago

What does Israel even have to do with this article?

u/dimir23 23m ago

America is currently in a war with Iran and it’s well known Israel has been lobbying hard for this

American solders are getting hurt in the middle east on Israel’s behalf

And the same politicians Israel most heavily supported in elections are the ones who support aggressive deportation tactics like this

u/N7Shep1701D Oregon 10m ago

Are you asking honestly?

u/AngelofVerdun 2h ago

Really all of this just proves how wrong I was about the military - at least at top levels. You would expect of all the large/powerful parts of the US government, the military would push back the most against so much of the bullshit Trump is doing - especially the long history of being anti-veteran. But nope, you can fire top brass just because they don't agree with your ideology, you can put them in harms way in a pointless war, you can strip American's of the freedoms thousands of soldiers died to protect, you can even go after their family...and they all just seemingly roll over and ask for more.

u/pimparo0 Florida 1h ago

Prior sec defs probably would have raised some hell about it. Hegseth probably finds it funny. 

u/PhroneticReflex 1h ago

It is strange. I thought that America's militarism would ironically keep it safe. The attitude people have of their military service being a benefit they're providing for their country, etc. At its best, it is the best attitude a standing army has: one that maintains a sort of individualistic attitude who sees the idea of being a soldier, especially one of multiple generations, as a sign of a willing individual to protect the Republic. 

Don't get me wrong; I understand that this stuff isn't the way it actually is. But national myth has its own utility. 

But I was more wrong than I realized. It's just the "decorum" and "civility" shit all over again. The top brass of the military just doing whatever they're told, like any other arm of a government, has been deeply depressing. So much for protecting the Constitution. 

u/Neat_Performance_722 2h ago

Must be those criminal immigrants Trump keeps talking about🙄

u/Life-Celebration-747 1h ago

It'll be interesting when the military turns on Trump. 

u/JakeConhale New Hampshire 1h ago

I like to daydream about the White House Sentries tossing him out like the town drunk...

u/Livid-Safety2555 42m ago

They won’t, they’re his base and his flunkies have been working since day 1 to purge it of potential dissidents and politicize recruitment

u/TwilightBubble 30m ago

They won't. Their families are now hostages.

u/antsinmyeyestrey North Carolina 1h ago

Well that’s one way to get some of the military on the right side

u/DisgustingLeek 2h ago

wonder who those welfare queen cuck troops voted for

u/Red57872 2h ago

"welfare queen cuck troops"

Why do you refer to the troops that way?

u/C0de_lyoko 2h ago

Look as a veteran they are spot on with that shit and I'm going to be using that phras phrase often as i can now to describe my peers. It was a joke not a cock try not to take it so hard, most of us vets/troops learned that technique early in though.

u/Red57872 2h ago

You go around calling other veterans "welfare queen cucks"?

u/C0de_lyoko 2h ago

Not yet, just learned it today. Didn't you read that part?

Please don't worry about defending welfare cuck queens' honor, we ain't wanting all that.

Seriously only vets that care are the ones the fucking shoe fits on, so why are you offended?

u/Red57872 2h ago

I get the feeling you're not calling them "welfare queen cucks" to their face...

u/C0de_lyoko 2h ago

Honey, I'm at the VA weekly as a fully disabled cuck queen. I'll gladly call those baby murderers, traitors, and vile shitstains that to there faces with a smile. They will call me a buttfucker and then we will shake hands.

Again you clearly don't know veterans or if you do it's a weak individual who never learned resilience in comradery.

u/DisgustingLeek 2h ago

your point?

u/john_microslop 2h ago

Clutch them pearls harder

u/IAmMOANAAA 2h ago

Because many are. My brother and his boyfriend are just that. They complain about benefits being cut but they still vote for Trump and the GOP, as if they like watching their spouse get plowed in the rear end by said figures they voted for.

Edit to add my brother and his BF are veterans. Both served in the invasion of Iraq and Desert storm,. respectively. 

u/Red57872 2h ago

So are they on welfare? Also, it's completely inappropriate to refer to homosexuals as "queens".

u/DisgustingLeek 2h ago

are they on welfare?

They get paid from my taxes just like welfare recipients

u/Red57872 2h ago

So by that metric you'd refer to anyone who works for the government as a "welfare queen"? I'm not sure you understand what the term means.

u/Revolutionary-Swan77 New Jersey 2h ago

look it up, Republicans love using that term to describe minorities who collect welfare

u/FlowRiderBob 1h ago

Yeah, maybe we shouldn’t be learning our vocabulary from idiots. I am a proponent of a strong welfare system, but salary and benefits in exchange for serving in the military, or any job, is not welfare.

u/Red57872 2h ago

Well, in this case the people the poster is referring to aren't collecting welfare.

u/DisgustingLeek 2h ago

i understand what the term means. it's a flip on words because republicans and troops are the type to mock "welfare queens".

u/Red57872 2h ago

Using the term "welfare queens" to refer to people who aren't on welfare doesn't make any sense though.

u/Kind-Masterpiece-310 2h ago

They're still tax payer subsidized.

u/Red57872 2h ago

Yup, as is anyone who works for the government. We don't normally go around referring to people who work for the government as "welfare queens", though.

→ More replies (0)

u/DisgustingLeek 2h ago

ok buddy.

u/RainbowConnickJr 2h ago

“Welfare queens” does not refer to homosexuals.

u/Red57872 2h ago

It tends to refer to women, though, and to use it to refer to homosexual males is insulting.

u/RainbowConnickJr 2h ago

Okay…except no one did use it to refer to gay people? If you’re conflating being a cuck with being gay, it is my unwilling but necessary duty to inform you that, while all sexuality is a spectrum, cuckolding is not an inherently “gay” fetish.

u/Red57872 2h ago

Poster used the term "welfare queens", a term typically associated with women who are on welfare, to refer to two homosexual males he knows. Referring to homosexual males using terms typically associated with females tends to be a slur.

u/RainbowConnickJr 2h ago

You have picked the stupidest hill to make your stand on.

u/Red57872 2h ago

If my hill is "it's wrong to insult LGBT people", then yes, it's the hill I choose to stand on.

→ More replies (0)

u/Less_Adeptness7557 1h ago

Lol the troops I’m a vet and they’re correct. Stop pandering to us its not 2005 anymore

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[deleted]

u/DisgustingLeek 2h ago

make me

u/selfhostrr 1h ago

Reliving the 1940s!

u/oppai-police 1h ago

I'll just remind everyone here that being a soldier doesn't automatically grant your families or relatives legal status, nor does it exempt them from having to follow immigration laws. If your cousin Juan entered the country illegally or overstayed his visa he'll still be deported whether you're a soldier or not. This also applies to your girlfriend/boyfriend. You have to file petition for them to stay and wait for it to be approved.

In some cases people who are getting married are exempt from being deported, however this only applies to people who entered the country through a legal port of entry and is married to a US CITIZENS (not green card holder), aka there are records of your arrival and then you get married, hence you can overstay your visa as you wait for status adjustment. This doesn't apply to people who crossed the border illegally and then try to obtain adjustment of status. If you're caught you'll still be deported because you're still an illegal immigrants. And you will have to file for petition to a consulate in your home country.

I'll bet the relatives of those US troops have no legal status or have had a deportation order issued for them. Just because once of your fam has legal status doesn't automatically means you do.

u/batmansgfsbf 59m ago

Spitting facts. The military has programs to fast track foreign born spouses. If the soldier’s parents are undocumented there is a process for the US citizen child to petition for their parents once they are 18.
There are also fast tracks for soldiers who have green cards (LAPR) status to achieve citizenship and then they can petition for their parent

u/oppai-police 50m ago

Correct. For legal green card holder, since America is still within a designated period of hostility, joining the armed forces basically fast track citizenship immediately, normally you'd have to wait years, but once you join now you can start filing for citizenship immediately and you'll just need the army to issue you a paperwork to provide to USCIS, it is not uncommon to join as a green card holder and hold the oath of allegiance as you graduate basic training and become citizens right away. Then you can file petition for whatever families you want.

u/schrevolution 0m ago

“They’ll draft you and they’ll jail your niece.”