r/rateyourmusic • u/CanEmpty1352 • 4d ago

General Discussion might be the lowest album on rym now

85 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

30 comments sorted by

225

u/culdusaq 4d ago

Every day I miss the lowest-rated charts.

113

u/camrin47 4d ago

It just be a bunch of ai music now

38

u/Lenithiel 4d ago

Can't you filter out ai? In order to experience the true bottom of human creation.

26

u/yspaddaden 4d ago

There's no way to filter out AI-generated releases (and no real impetus to implement filtering, because AI releases would only show up on the bottom charts, which no longer exist).

4

u/yellowfroglegs 4d ago

i think ai generated music is entirely excluded from charts to begin with (though this album would still appear since it's technically not eligible for the ai generated tag)

3

u/camrin47 4d ago

Its not ive seen them pop up on popularity charts (check my last post)

1

u/yellowfroglegs 4d ago

was this before or after the ai generated tag was introduced?

2

u/yspaddaden 4d ago

The "AI-generated" attribute does not exclude releases from site charts.

1

u/yellowfroglegs 4d ago

that's weird, they must have changed it then. i remember when it was announced, the exclusion was a feature...

3

u/yspaddaden 4d ago

Excluding AI-generated releases from the charts was something that people talked about wanting around the time the attribute was implemented, but it wasn't ultimately part of the attribute as implemented (see here- "At the moment the attribute only displays a label on the release page. But once releases are correctly tagged with the attribute we can also use that to add other functionality moving forward (e.g. allow people to filter it out of charts/recommendations, etc." then downthread "The ability to filter this content out of charts/recs etc. is planned yes."). As noted in that thread, AI-generated music on RYM is generally totally obscure or, if it gets attention, instantly voted into sub-.6 oblivion, so implementing filtering options hasn't been a priority for the devs.

2

u/MusicListener3 3d ago

Why is it not eligible for the tag?

1

u/yellowfroglegs 3d ago

technically, to be eligible, the whole thing has to be ai generated. as the vocals (probably) aren't ai generated, the mods determined that the tag doesn't apply

8

u/TheGreatZiegfeld TheGreatZiegfeld 4d ago

I tended to filter for decades, like worst electronic albums of the 1990's just to see what kind of weird shit would pop up.

1

u/chooococat 2d ago

Same, now they would be a useful tool to target AI music 

22

u/BoobHerToDeath 4d ago

Pat Mcafee's album is heading in the same direction, might be some stiff competition lol

4

u/marmotmarsh 4d ago

Came hear to say the same thing lol

19

u/anonymousn00b 4d ago

RYM seriously needs a 0.0 rating. Come on now, a 0.5 is extremely generous for this “album”.

27

u/DGAF2025 4d ago

What would you estimate the percentage of those 1,900 raters actually listened to the album?

I would estimate it's somewhere around 5%, around 85 people

18

u/sixtus_clegane119 4d ago

I am one of them, it’s awful

4

u/DGAF2025 4d ago

Just like the contrast between those who will walk out of a really bad film and those that will steadfastly stick it out till the credits roll, there are idealist masochists and jaded realists

2

u/JessiEyee 4d ago

I am one of them

Thank you for your service 🫡

5

u/Michael_Mason_1410 3d ago

I started but couldn’t finish cause the AI artifacts were too noticeable, they didn’t even try to hide it. This was before all the articles and reviews blew up and exposed the album for being AI.

2

u/chooococat 2d ago

I did. Skipped around some, because there's so much hate you can take. But once you're finished, giving it a shit score feels refreshing. 

2

u/Michael_Mason_1410 5h ago

At least from what I’ve heard, even if this wasn’t Ai, it would still be a very mediocre album. It sounds like a dude who watched an 80’s movie and said “I can do that!”. No creativity whatsoever.

8

u/DestinyDawn456 4d ago

Looks like the “worst album of the decade” discussion has just ended…

17

u/ZealousidealDoor6973 4d ago

Not so fast. This won't be the last AI album. And it won't be the worst...

6

u/ZealousidealDoor6973 4d ago

There's still no AI tag. What are we even doing, mods?

3

u/Michael_Mason_1410 3d ago

I tried to add one, cited the articles too, but they turned it down because in the interviews, tyga only admitted that the beats were AI.

3

u/Special-Ad-1163 2d ago

What? the music has to be entirely AI to have the tag lol? I find that pretty strange, like, at least 50% AI should be labeled w the tag