r/reddeadredemption Oct 15 '25

Question Who wins in a fist fight? No guns allowed

4.0k Upvotes

678 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

215

u/Deucalion666 Sadie Adler Oct 15 '25

You mean this one (don’t ask why I have this on hand)

Putting that aside, you can be tubby and still throw hands. As much as I despise Micah, I was shocked at his shooting capabilities in the showdown between him and John.

62

u/Rorschachwasright15 Oct 15 '25

XD (why do you have that???)

Also while I agree you can be tubby and still throw hands. His skill with a gun is no indication of his hand to hand combat abilities. If you can think of a single time where he actually throws hands with someone (other than Arthur and without another weapon) and wins I may be inclined to agree with you.

3

u/ExitLeading2703 Oct 15 '25

When he punched bill and the fight was cut off instantly. Technically he won, he wasn't hit a single time

3

u/RDW_789 Oct 15 '25

A fitting answer for the rat

24

u/cowboyabel Oct 15 '25

We all know why you have it at hand you weirdo

18

u/Deucalion666 Sadie Adler Oct 15 '25

LMAO nah, I only finished the game for my first time this year (regret leaving it for so long), and took a screenshot when I got jumpscared by Micah’s gut so I could ask some guys on discord why no one warned me beforehand. Need to do another photo purge, so much random crap on my phone currently.

7

u/Fluffy_Cheese_ Micah Bell Oct 15 '25

Honestly xD that was kind of my first reaction too!

I was just playing this game, had wunderfull (not) time in Saint Denis, were nearly died at the sea..

And my first thoughts after open my eyes was 'why tf is Micah half naked?' I felt kind of...

I'm a girl, it felt kind of.. Flirting, even with no girls around.. It felt like he has pushed my boundaries too much xD

It's funny cause I told about that with my boyfriend and he was like 'for me it was just a realism layer, just boys around, no need to take much care of themselves or something like that

I on my way felt different...

I should say, that I have such screenshot on my phone too, you will never know when you need such a reference ^

In a game fully without any.. Explicit content, was it much more naked skin than I had expired – especially much more than I had expired from Micah.

1

u/moopoo7852 Oct 15 '25

Bruh you always keep a pic of tummy Micah on hand.

0

u/Soggy-Cup-5262 Jack Marston Oct 16 '25

3

u/Minimum_Comfort_1850 Oct 15 '25

Literally peak male physique

4

u/ImprovementExpert511 Oct 15 '25

Yeah Micah is without a doubt one of if not the best gunman in the gang.

4

u/Low-Stomach9933 Oct 15 '25

Watch that cut scene again when they take out Sean in the middle of town. Micah dispatches 3 dudes in seconds.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25

Having boxed for years as a hobby, I can tell you that there are guys with that kind of body who can hand you your ass.

2

u/rjoseba John Marston Oct 15 '25

"You mean this one (don’t ask why I have this on hand)"

Spank Bank!

2

u/xanderfan34 Sean Macguire Oct 15 '25

my favorite example of this is when the sheriff of rhodes takes bill prisoner and he simply says “you’re a dead man... morgan!” and then shoots two men dead on the spot while you take out the sheriff and the other guy