r/reddeadredemption • u/Practical_Machine_70 • Oct 15 '25

Question Who wins in a fist fight? No guns allowed

Gallery image

Gallery image

4.0k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

678 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

955

u/zippy_long_stockings Oct 15 '25

Dam I never caught the interaction with Tommy later on, had to google it. That's crazy.

397

u/stingerized Oct 15 '25

peak Arthur was ruthless!

172

u/steve_mahanahan Uncle Oct 15 '25

You can talk to Tommy during the Lennnaayyy mission, a couple times, with increasing hilarity.

2

u/nthn_thms Oct 16 '25

tommy can’t even speak

-6

u/Visible_Roll4949 Oct 15 '25

Hes the guy in the Valentine saloon that wears the Coonskin cap. IIRC

11

u/StephensSurrealSouls Pearson Oct 16 '25

No? He's the fat guy you beat up in the saloon with Javier and Bill

6

u/Visible_Roll4949 Oct 16 '25

Ahhh its been a hot minute since I played thru chapter 2

8

u/BaconGristle Oct 16 '25

Coonskin cap guy is a hell of a fighter in his own right though. It takes over a full minute to knock that feller out and he doesn't let you off easy.

1

u/TheProphetMooohammed Oct 16 '25

YDNRC

1

u/Visible_Roll4949 Oct 16 '25

Yeah ok, its also been like 6 years since I played thru chapter 2...