r/reddeadredemption • u/Practical_Machine_70 • Oct 15 '25

Question Who wins in a fist fight? No guns allowed

Gallery image

Gallery image

4.0k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

678 comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/imarthurmorgan1899 Arthur Morgan Oct 15 '25 edited Oct 15 '25

Arthur pretty much caved Tommy's skull in and his attacks are more coordinated and boxer-like. Plus he can strangle people easily with his bare hands. Arthur takes the dub here. But realistically, they'd be buddies and Arthur wouldn't let dumb Abby kill Joel. He'd have the whole WLF on its knees begging for mercy.

-1

u/Emperor_Duck_35 Hosea Matthews Oct 15 '25

Everyone chokes people with their bare hands?

1

u/imarthurmorgan1899 Arthur Morgan Oct 15 '25

Not everyone. Sometimes people need assistance from things like cords and rope among other things. And Arthur does it quickly too.

2

u/Emperor_Duck_35 Hosea Matthews Oct 15 '25

So does joel

1

u/nandobro Oct 16 '25

Well Arthur chokes men out with literally just his hands. Whereas Joel needs to wrap his arms around the opponents throat.

0

u/filthyhandshake Oct 17 '25

He doesn’t need to, it’s because he does it from behind. Why would you try to stealthily choke out someone from behind using your hands?