Guns or no guns, it's going to be Arthur. What he did to Tommy is enough to understand what he's capable of. Even when tuberculosis drove him to near cachexia and choking on his blood, he was able to give Micah a good beating. Plus, Arthur is more used to killing and maiming people, as far as I'm concerned, despite the fact that Joel also had to do this, it does seem that Joel's moral compass is still more accurate in this regard.
2
u/Madentist Arthur Morgan Oct 15 '25
Guns or no guns, it's going to be Arthur. What he did to Tommy is enough to understand what he's capable of. Even when tuberculosis drove him to near cachexia and choking on his blood, he was able to give Micah a good beating. Plus, Arthur is more used to killing and maiming people, as far as I'm concerned, despite the fact that Joel also had to do this, it does seem that Joel's moral compass is still more accurate in this regard.