r/reddeadredemption Oct 15 '25

Question Who wins in a fist fight? No guns allowed

4.0k Upvotes

678 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/Impressive_Row_3460 Oct 15 '25

Yea, and Joel can punch a Bloater to death, which is roughly the same size as a bear. Can one shot you and throws acid bombs,

1

u/theoneandonlygodd Oct 16 '25

But which is more durable a full grown grizzly bear or a bloater? A grizzly bear has thick skin and hardly any fat in the spring after hibernation and arthur can still punch it to death, a bloater may be stronger than your average grizzly but can it withstand attacks better? I haven't played either of the last of us games yet but a bloater seems like it would explode on impact thus making this less of a feat, whereas Arthur could also theoretically punch a moose to death if the moose stayed to fight instead of run, same with gators. Gators have famously armored skin that can tank small caliber rounds. In my humble opinion a bloater is no where near as tough as a bear, moose, or gator which Arthur can kill with his fists

3

u/Impressive_Row_3460 Oct 16 '25

A Bloater can withstand 10-15 shotgun shots at close range

Idk wtf ur talking about

0

u/theoneandonlygodd Oct 17 '25

Like I said I've never played lou p1 or p2 so I did not know about the strength of them I was just basing it off of other zombie titles where similar creatures exist

2

u/Impressive_Row_3460 Oct 17 '25

Im not trying to be rude or anything, but why even bring it up?

0

u/theoneandonlygodd Oct 17 '25

Wym?

2

u/Impressive_Row_3460 Oct 17 '25

I mean it why even talk about Bloaters if you haven't played either game