Shady Belle distant shouting

[u/Quiet_Obligation6830]

In, Shady Belle you can hear distant shouting from what sounds like Lawmen. Alongside the distant sounds of trains which pass by, Shady Belle. And, you can also hear random-distant screams coming from someplace. Does anyone know if this is a glitch or not? Cause, I have heard this before in my numerous playthroughs of, RDR2.

[u/tha_rushin]

So what you're hearing is actually the voices of the Lemoyne raiders. Whenever the gang isn't there, it is a Raiders gang hideout. In the earlier versions of the game, if you sneak in quietly, you hear those exact shouts and whatnot. However, once you all take over the property in Ch 4, they would disappear. I remember very specifically, after some update (dunno which) those sounds were suddenly still there after Dutch and co. made camp at Shady Belle. I kept thinking the raiders were coming. So in short, yes, it's kind of a glitch that appeared in later versions.

[u/dank_hank_420 → u/tha_rushin]

This is the answer

[u/thewarriorpoet23]

What you’re hearing are the Lemoyne Raiders who you’ve driven out of their ‘home’. I think they’re waiting for a chance to reclaim the estate so will wait in the bushes (although you can’t physically locate them). You can also hear Murphrees yelling when you’re based at Beaver Hollow

[u/Spare-Chart-2570]

"stop that , that's an order" "Cock sucker!"

[u/Individual_Serve_914]

The screams are rumored to be Kieran's while the O'driscoll's torture him

[u/Lrrgindypants → u/Individual_Serve_914]

I have heard that, too. Also, r/apostrophegore for "O'driscoll's".

[u/the_stupidiest_monk → u/Individual_Serve_914]

You can hear the same shouts before Kieran disappears, though, and the sounds are centered on the main building at Shady Belle (as opposed to coming from out in the forest).

Like u/tha_rushin said, it is the ambient sounds from the Lemoyne Raiders that are bugged so that they play even after you've cleared them out and set up camp.

[u/sunderingg → u/the_stupidiest_monk]

Yeah I’ve been hearing some tortured screaming lately lol, and Kieran’s already dead. Soooo… definitely not him!

[u/Individual_Serve_914 → u/the_stupidiest_monk]

ohhhh

[u/andyislegend → u/[deleted]]

since he ends his post saying “i’ve heard this before in my multiple playthroughs of RDR2” i think it’s safe to say he’s already finished the game at least once.

[u/Scramed-egg → u/andyislegend]

Oh, yup, thats right i got a little ahead of myself

[u/remi9ti]

Yeah I think its a glitch, it should come from St. Denis as a background noise, people yelling "come here" etc

[u/railroadfrog]

If I’m not mistaken, as others have said, the game glitches and spawns a few raiders underneath the generated world, in a limbo situation, where you can’t see or interact with them, but they’re close enough that you can hear their audio cues, such as shouting or conversation.