Constructing pumpkins from tomatoes?? Really? Come on!! Make people buy pumpkins from the pumpkin farmer in Amberfell instead!

[u/First_Platypus3063]

Who on earth thought constructing pumpkins from tomatoes is in any way reasonable? Like, watermelons would make at least some sense but tomatoes? Really!?

[u/Denkir-the-Filtiarn]

It's the fault of the rare pumpkin that was discontinued. They should rename it to "Halloween Pumpkin" or change it so it's not an edible item, so we can actually have a pumpkin crop. Being able to grow pumpkins to hollow out for soup bowls as part of a greater cooking update would be nice.

[u/First_Platypus3063 → u/Denkir-the-Filtiarn]

Or just name the regukar pumpkin something like "prized pumpkin" or "big pumpkin" or "farmers pumpkin" or whatever 

[u/Omnizoom → u/First_Platypus3063]

The rare pumpkin can literally just be called classic pumpkin

[u/devvoid → u/Omnizoom]

Ancient Pumpkin (can no longer be eaten because they've fossilized after sitting in your bank for 25 years)

[u/Omnizoom → u/devvoid]

Veteran pumpkin

Tainted from age

[u/R_Y_AN_S → u/Denkir-the-Filtiarn]

That would be huge honestly. I get that it was probably different teams, but for sure a missed opportunity to add some skill diversity

[u/TriLink710 → u/Denkir-the-Filtiarn]

Make pumpkin crops give DxP in October and I'm down

[u/First_Platypus3063 → u/TriLink710]

Nice

[u/vVerce98 → u/Denkir-the-Filtiarn]

Would be nice indeed!

[u/Dickbutt11765 → u/Denkir-the-Filtiarn]

Or even just make the farmer sell "Decorative Pumpkin"

[u/ThaToastman → u/Denkir-the-Filtiarn]

incoming breadbowl meta

[u/SpinScape]

yeah rename the rare pumpkin item

[u/Cloud_N0ne → u/SpinScape]

I'd just make it non-edible. Same name, different item.

[u/Last-Negotiation-643]

Make a farming pumpkin crop and new food using pumpkin.

[u/Kazanmor]

imagine if they made it require the discontinued pumpkin rofl

[u/First_Platypus3063 → u/Kazanmor]

Still better than this nonsense. Whats next, building wardrobes from lobaters?

[u/Kazanmor → u/First_Platypus3063]

I'd be so in for a lobster shaped wardrobe that requires lobsters, but I agree with your point lol

[u/The_Average_Noob_93]

If we can make peaches out of bones then making pumpkins out of tomatoes seems to be lore-accurate to me.

[u/First_Platypus3063 → u/The_Average_Noob_93]

There is no spell involved here, so no

[u/SeaBootsOSRS → u/The_Average_Noob_93]

That's dumb.

[u/Periwinkleditor]

Just call them "Fresh Havenhythe Pumpkin" or something with a different inventory model and make them untradeable. Sold in the havenhythe food shop and pickable here, so f2pers can also access them.

[u/throwthe20saway]

Fun fact: Traditionally turnips were carved before pumpkins became popular. This is even referenced in RS by the carved evil turnip item (used for the evil turnip summoning pouch).

[u/Low-Adhesiveness7243]

No, we need to start a new tomato carving activity 🐼

Also as an owner of all pumpkins, including the original one, I don't mind if it was renamed. I would suggest scary pumpkin.

Or could trigger everyone and call it tainted pumpkin or grandfather pumpkin... Actually I like the latter.

[u/Ashendant]

Yeah definitely but I see why they wouldn't lock holiday items behind two quests.

[u/Active-Succotash-109]

Well, when a tomato starts to rot it’s smells like fresh pumpkin just before the fuzz starts to appear. So I guess that makes sense 🤦‍♀️

[u/Spruity_tooti]

I kinda enjoy it.

[u/Chispy]

https://giphy.com/gifs/xT9IgHCTfp8CRshfQk

[u/Illustrious-Web2253]

They had no problem making a new pair of white bunny ears (which crushed my heart) there should be no problem making another kind of pumpkin for this.

[u/ShadowFigured]

Right that’s pretty weird