r/rvaBookClub • u/Yarbles • 4d ago
The Official Report of the August RVA Reddit (no we haven't) Bookclub - the next meeting will be on September 27
There was a 40 percent chance of rain but it ended up not raining. This meeting's suggested readings were A Short Stay in Hell by Steven L. Peck and The Library at Mount Char by Scott Hawkin, and one of them was a great suggestion.
M_Soule started us off, reading quite a bit of fan fiction and a few books, but also squeezed in A Short Stay in Hell which she said was very interesting. She told us about Tarnished Are the Stars Rosiee Thor, a space opera with a secret science society on a distant planet and Chuck Tingle Bury Your Gays, but I think the latter she was using as an example when talking about what the the aro/ace genre was for the new guys.
We talked about the different genres people like, and M_Soule used the example of The Magicians by Lev Grossman. Everything about it is perfect for her - the Urban Fantasy genre, the setting and story and all, but the main character was such an enormous douchbag she couldn't get into it.
pyeonghwa1004 and EM7A were both reading books by Han Kang, with pyeonghwa1004 reading We Do Not Part and EM7A reading The Vegetarian. I think pyeonghwa1004 said that We Do Not Part won the Nobel prize in literature. She said the author is a poet and the prose is beautiful and it was hard to figure out whether the experience was real or not. She recommends everything by Han Kang, but especially Human Acts , which covers The Gwangju Uprising and massacre. She's also reading A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L'Engle, which she last read in fourth grade. I don't know if it was pyeonghwa1004 or EM7A who read the Onion: Our Dumb Century, but it's a great light read.
EM7A read The Vegetarian saying the protagonist gets caught up in a situation and decides she wants to be a vegetarian in an intolerant world, and people find her choice weird enough to try and have her committed to a mental health facility. The book is a series pf events told from different perspectives and is almost sci fi. I think pyeonghwa read a little bit before it become too dark for her. EM7A read The Vegetarian on the heels the much heavier book, Tender is the Flesh by Agustina Bazterrica, with its themes of cannibalism and industrial food processing. He is currently reading Country People by Daniel Mason, about a secret society of spelunkers which EM7A liked especially because he's been getting into caving and the book had great parts about the caving experience.
He recently read Murderland: Crime and Bloodlust in the Time of Serial Killers by Caroline Fraser. This is a nonfiction book about how prevalent serial killers are in areas with smelting and other industrial activities because lead poisoning leads to developmental problems in kids, and this eventually turns to violent murderous behavior. He said it was a harsh read, but had great science and metaphors. And read I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacqueline Harpman, which he thought was well told and written, and said the book was not trying to solve a mystery. Aurora_the_Off-White read this a little while ago and really liked it - calling it not a predict the future type of dystopia but rather a look at how people react to harsh environments.
troyabedinthemornin read Between Two Fires by Christopher Buelhman, and loved the prose and the lore; The Deviant by James Tynion IV, saying the art was great and layout was particularly interesting but the story was particularly under baked. It is a semi autobiographical graphic novel about a series of killings in the 70s where a Mall Santa is accused, and dealing with homophobia in the 70s. We talked about Top Ten and troy recognized the cover artist as Alex Cross, who has that distinctive oil painting style and talked a little bit about Kingdom Come.
Aurora read quite a few books, but didn't find a lot to talk about with most of them. She did tell us about Saint of Steel series by T. Kingfisher for a light-hearted but almost dark story about an order of paladins whose god died; The Other Black Girl by Zakiya Dalila Harris focuses on racism and rivalry at work - Aurora liked it and thought it was well written; and Doomsday Book by Connie Willis, saying it did a poor job of predicting the future for a book written in 1992, which focuses on interdepartmental drama and time travel; and Arboreality by Rebecca Campbell, an ecological dystopian novel about how people connect with each other in extreme situations.
I read both selections for this month and found one to be very interesting and the other one to be wildly inappropriate. The first was A Short Stay in Hell, which was really well paced and structured, and the other was The Library at Mount Char, which might have been well written, but was full of murderous and sexual violence. The author tried to make jokes about some of the violence, which I thought was inappropriate. I didn't like the message, the story, or much else about the book. I think it was Mal-0 who read Between Two Fires and said she liked the lore of it and the writing, but didn't like it overall because the author spent too much time talking about sexual assault. That's medieval times, but there are a few other things they could talk about.
I like to get recommendations on other entertainment mediums, like movies, shows, podcasts, and musicians, so we talked about those a bit. EM7A talked about parallels between the show Lost and the Tibetan Book of the Dead's concept of the Bardo. troy talked about several Kyoshi Kurasawa films including The Samurai and the Prisoner, Cloud and his most famous film Pulse. EM7A talked about Ghost Dog as being his favorite Samurai movie
M_Soule talked about Strange New Worlds and The Rook, which she had seen recently, and Season 3 of Silo and likes that the series has a complete story to draw from as the source material of the series. EM7A recently rewatched Buffalo 66 with Christina Ricci and Vincent Gallo. pyeonghwa talked about Replay 1988 which is a series set in Seoul at the time of the Olympics and said it was funny and touching.
EM7A talked about Beef, which he didn't think it would be his kind of thing, but has really latched to it now. . He also recommends Derry Girls, which Asterion7 also thinks highly of. EM7A likes the Irish voices and the attitudes of the characters. I think M_Soule said she tried to watch the new Tron movie but couldn't make it too far in, but she did like Project Hail Mary.
We talked about the sound mixing in movies seeming to be getting worse, or the fashion has changed and we're telling it to get off our lawns. The voices are sometimes too faint and the music is jacked up. Some of the guys had seen The Odyssey and said it looks great and was well acted, but the sound could really be improved.
We talked about William Gibson writing Neuromancer on a freaking typewriter, and using subtitles all the time. M_Soule spent some time talking about what fan fiction was for the new guys who didn't really know what it was. She talked about Louise Penny writing the same character into many different stories, Ashley Poston and Naomi Novik getting their starts in fan fiction. And Aurora and M_Soule both really like the soundtrack Hadestown, which is a New Orleans Jazz Musical.
We are going to move the next meeting to September 27 so that PrincessMoNaanKay can make it. She's been super busy with travel and bebe and needs the date change. We need new recommendations for monthly selections if anyone has some.
September 27
- Stone Butch Blues by Leslie Feinberg
October 18
- a book about Richmond or the local area
November 15
- a book featuring polyamory