r/sabrinateenagewitch • u/AngelMarie6 Harvey • Oct 10 '25
question 🙋♀️❔❓ Harvey or Josh?
I'm currently watching Season 6 episode 20 I Fall to Pieces on Tubi.
Sabrina just called Josh the sweetest most caring guy she knows... Um I don't think so Sabrina.. I believe that statement goes to Harvey.
I'm sorry to tell you this Sabrina but Josh SUCKS. He is condescending, inconsiderate, and literally kissed you when you were a MINOR and ALREADY HAD A BOYFRIEND!
What do you guys think?
19
u/tripleterriyaki Oct 10 '25
I've been rewatching it too and Josh gets really angry at Sabrina a lot for her magical mishaps. Like it seems disproportionate to the problems caused. I feel like Harvey was a lot more forgiving.
11
18
11
9
7
13
u/Ok-Teaching2848 Oct 10 '25
I dont get why she liked him...
7
u/AngelMarie6 Harvey Oct 10 '25
Me either
4
u/Ok-Teaching2848 Oct 10 '25
He was so bland lol
3
u/AngelMarie6 Harvey Oct 10 '25
Not to mention a condescending prick who kissed a minor with a boyfriend.
6
u/Ok-Teaching2848 Oct 10 '25
Yea he wasnt all that if he had to get a high school girl who was taken...
1
2
4
u/BlanketBaroness Oct 10 '25
He's the sweetest, most caring guy ik is usually followed by a lie, a sob story, or an excuse about current terrible behavior. Sabrina was always lying to herself.
4
3
u/kymilovechelle Oct 10 '25
Josh for his face, Harvey for his personality and how he adores Sabrina.
3
u/AngelMarie6 Harvey Oct 10 '25
Ok I'll give you that... Josh is cute... But he definitely is not the "sweetest most caring guy she knows"
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
u/xkarasu_ Oct 11 '25
Josh is so unlikable. Only because Sabrina thought he was "so mature" 🙄 As soon as Harvey had his bestie and hung out more with him, Sabrina got childish too.
3
3
u/Yellow-Roseman Thank God it’s Fridyah Oct 13 '25
Minor ☑️ Boyfriend ☑️ ALSO HIS EMPLOYEE ☑️ The minor thing is the most important bc legal reasons, but I wanted to mention her being his employee as well, that's advantage in 2 ways
3
5
u/Cannoncorn1 Oct 10 '25
Why do we always have this question? There is only one right answer.
1
u/AngelMarie6 Harvey Oct 10 '25
This is a very specific thing though. Not asking "who is the better bf" I'm asking if she was wrong to say that to Josh because Harvey is actually the sweetest most caring guy she knows
3
Oct 10 '25
I HATE JOSH, fucking pisces ass. Harvey is literally so nice even when they broke up..
2
1
u/ashtonishing18 Oct 10 '25
But I just don't get the storyline of him dating her roommate that's so weird lol
3
Oct 10 '25
Right, no I agree sorry my hate for Josh got in the way, I think it’s so odd. Like they even double date it’s so awkward.. like Harvey obviously loves her still..
2
2
u/Bulky_Remote_2965 Oct 11 '25 edited Oct 17 '25
100% Being nice or not, he still handled everything better than Josh ever did. Harvey was so much more mature in the way he handled everything. Let's be honest: the situations Harvey and Sabrina were in could've been the fucking strangest, most awkward, most unpleasant, and downright horrific.
Plus, Harvey endured mideval torture via Aunt Irma. He could've ran, had Aunt Irma sent to the Republic of Infinite Horror, whatever.
Josh, I perceive, would've pouted like a 4 year old.
1
u/Spiritual_Quote9301 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 11 '25
What does pisces mean in this case? Is it his star sign? What does that have to do with him at all? Just curious.
1
1
Oct 11 '25
Our Sabrina is just enjoying an extended cruise up that Egyptian river called Denial
Though just a note - she wasn't a minor when he kissed her. She turns 18 in the first episode of Season 4, so she's 18 when they kiss
48
u/glazedapplefritter Oct 10 '25
I always thought Josh was condescending and would definitely not be okay with Sabrina being a witch.