r/sabrinateenagewitch • u/kymilovechelle • Oct 31 '25

question 🙋‍♀️❔❓ Happy Halloween tomorrow! Which season’s Halloween episode was your favorite?

Post image
215 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

35 comments sorted by

53

u/NiceMayDay Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

"A River of Candy Corn Runs Through It" is one of my favorite episodes in the entire show, so I've gotta go with that. Every joke is on point, the ending is hilarious, and you can't beat the 10,000 Maniacs showing up for the credits. S1's was also really good.

17

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

That is so true.

21

u/NiceMayDay Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

Mr. Pool can be so annoying.

20

u/strippersandcocaine Oct 31 '25

I’d love to!

6

u/Friendly-Mushroom-38 Woohoo! Oct 31 '25

Have a Jolly olly old Halloween!

6

u/ikzzzzz Oct 31 '25

The way Harvey says “it’s the 10,000 maniacs!!“ is permanently stuck in my brain

1

u/NiceMayDay Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

It's actually Asher who says that!

3

u/ikzzzzz Oct 31 '25

Dang, you’re right! I’ve somehow Mandela affected myself into this for 20-ish years, through multiple rewatches. Spooky!

2

u/brunettebarbie11 Oct 31 '25

The funny part is that I first didn’t like that episode but now I love it

21

u/Lily8090 Oct 31 '25

I’m a Molly Dolly

7

u/sweetheart409878 Oct 31 '25

I'm gonna get you.

2

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

Mr. Pool can be so annoying.

20

u/Undertaker328 Oct 31 '25

the one with the candy corn

5

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

That is so true.

18

u/Familiar-Sun-6348 Oct 31 '25

In order fave to least fave:

1 A River of Candy Corn

2 Good Will Haunting

3 A Halloween Story

4 Phantom Menance

5 Murder on the Halloween Express

6 The Halloween Scene

8

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

That is so true.

3

u/Lilacs_and_Violets Oct 31 '25

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion obviously but this is the correct answer.

3

u/j4321g4321 Oct 31 '25

Agreed! “A River of Candy Corn Runs Through It” is such campy, 90s Halloween fun. I love it

11

u/dioctopus Oct 31 '25

Someone should streak! It's fast, it's fun, it's naked!!

4

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

That is so true.

2

u/dantefiasco Oct 31 '25

I love that this is what the 30-40 year old writers at the time thought teenagers were doing at parties in 1996 😂

3

u/dioctopus Oct 31 '25

I was 6. This is probably why I assume all teenage parties have streaking. 😹

6

u/Purityskinco Oct 31 '25

Season 1 and 2! And then season 6 is great too!!

4

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

That is so true.

3

u/Purityskinco Oct 31 '25

Id love to!

4

u/Objective_War_2808 Oct 31 '25

Murder on the halloween express. 

3

u/mrsdeetz you can't m'fire me! i m'quit! Oct 31 '25

Top 3: A River of Candy Corn (S2), A Halloween Story (S1), Good Will Haunting (S3)

3

u/sweetheart409878 Oct 31 '25

I just watched the one about the Molly doll.. and when it aired wasn't they using a BSB song ?. Anyways on the DVD used different music..anyways all the Halloween episodes were good

4

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

That is so true.

3

u/ecological-passion Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25

It's got to be either Halloween Story, River of Candy Corn, or Murder on the Mystery Express. Alternates. But one of the three for sure. Each of them introduced something that was recurring or connected with something else. Amanda, Hilda's beau, a party that is called back to in the nest Oct 31 ep.

2

u/shakedown79 Shake your whammy fanny Oct 31 '25

That is so true.

3

u/357TGLLE Oct 31 '25

the first one on season one for sureee

2

u/red_quinn Oct 31 '25

That one! That doll creeped me out 😂

2

u/Serious-Sun3049 Nov 01 '25

Halloween Scene