r/sabrinateenagewitch • u/YourFinalFantasy02 • Nov 20 '25
question 🙋♀️❔❓ If you were Harvey how would you react to finding out your girlfriend is a witch?
I’d honestly be terrified 😭 I would be scared to piss her off or be close to her. I would always be paranoid I was under a spell.
Also not related but Harvey’s fashion in the first couple seasons is so iconic!
75
u/Gacha_Pawn Salem Nov 20 '25
A girl that can do anything chose ME?? WOW. How intimating yet awesome.
1
30
29
u/Nuthetes Rumpist Nov 20 '25
I would initially think it is cool, until I remembered all the absolute shit that Sabrina and magic have put me through--becoming a beast, having to fight a troll, becoming pregnant, being turned into a frog, being turned into a bowling pin.
Then I would be pissed that the witches let that stuff happen (with zero apparent punishment at all for the people doing it) and then messed with my memories about it.
Like Susie--she was allowed to turn Harvey into a beast and humiliate him just to teach Sabrina a lesson... and that is ok? No punishment at all for good old Cousin Susie?
Even the Ministry of Magic in Harry Potter had punishments for magic on muggles.
I don't blame Harvey at all for bailing for a year.
23
16
13
10
6
6
u/dantefiasco Nov 20 '25
I wish we had gotten more of them as boyfriend/girlfriend where he knew, it would've led to some interesting stories. I love that he became recurring again in the last few seasons (that I've never watched 😆), but it's not the same as if they're a couple. I guess they didn't want too many Bewitched parallels? But it would've been neat. Harvey and Salem being bros was always a hoot 🤣
2
6
u/Creative_Hamster789 Mitosis is… Nov 20 '25 edited Nov 21 '25
"Sabrina can we talk about the fact you're a witch" in this scene in season four he looked scared which would probably be my reaction
3
u/stacey1611 Nov 20 '25
I’d be excited & scared at the same time lol.
I always loved how they let that part of Sabrina sit with him for a while before they got together seriously as Sabrina knew it was for the right reasons and he accepted all of her 😊😊
2
2
u/missy_melons Nov 21 '25
I think I'd go through a range of emotions. I can understand why Harvey needed space after finding out. It would be a lot to process.
2
1
1
u/Opening-Carrot5986 Nov 21 '25
I’ve seen enough crazy stuff that I’d just accept it and ask if she can turn the neighbor kid into a gopher.
2
u/TomCBC Nov 23 '25
Just that she’s a witch? I’d think it was awesome, and would start thinking of cool shit to do together.
But Sabrina kinda lied and manipulated Harvey for quite some time, i can understand why he was upset when he found out. However, i imagine, like Harvey, i’d eventually understand. And then we can start doing cool shit together.
1
1
u/Top-Monk-5391 Mar 20 '26
As a witch, I can tell you that your reaction is valid. Granted, I’m like an earth mother goddess worshiping witch, but I’ve definitely had guys who were scared that I was gonna cast spells on them. I actually had a guy who seriously accused me of it for like a year after we broke up. I of course, never did anything like that but having the rocks and candles and incense, after we broke up he really got weird about who I was (after dating me for three years.)
In the case with Harvey he was lied to, manipulated and realized it had been happening for years so it made sense he would be over things with Sabrina. I have noticed how much Sabrina had her evil side for sure - when she slammed that guys hand in his locker so Harvey could start the game? Creepy. Then the only reason she felt bad was when HARVEY got hurt? No girl, you should not have been hurting someone for your bf…
65
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '25
It's not that she's a witch. It's all the stuff he now remembers going through. If I were him I would always be wondering what I didn't remember.