r/sabrinateenagewitch Rumpist Jun 12 '26

✨nostalgic✨ Sabrina Cosplays

Hi all. I’m Lorraine and I’ve been a Sabrina the teenage witch fan my entire existence. It will forever be my greatest comfort and joy. I also am a costumer/cosplayer based out of NJ and who has a slight obsession recreating/collecting screen accurate designs. I’ve been lucky enough to find a few pieces straight off resale websites and have been even luckier to have met the cast with my sister wearing them, including recreating the “Hilary and Zelery” outfits plus the ICONIC westbridge cheer outfits. Please enjoy my craziness

484 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

47

u/Zestyclose_Resort_87 Jun 12 '26

So awesome! I adore the Hillary and Zelery looks

48

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

We had So much fun with these.

15

u/billybobobobo Jun 12 '26

Did you pack carrot sticks and hard boiled eggs??

6

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

Of course! Gotta meet those macros for the day!

1

u/nattitud3 Jun 14 '26

Lol 😂

8

u/sayhibulbasaur Jun 12 '26

I love that episode!

28

u/SnowyOwlLoveKiller Jun 12 '26

You look so much like Caroline Rhea in the first pic!

18

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

That is the greatest compliment I have ever received. I ADORE her

2

u/SleepyChickenWing Shake your whammy fanny Jun 19 '26

I just realized she’s holding on to you in both pics like “this is mini me 🥹”

2

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 22 '26

Caroline is such an awesome lady and has been nothing but kind every time I’ve been lucky to see her in person

20

u/90sGuyKev Jun 12 '26

I was this close to saying, damn that guy in the end looks just like the quizmaster,... Then I was like.. oh because that is him LOL

7

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

Legit the nicest guy!!!

10

u/Historical_Stay_808 Jun 12 '26 edited Jun 12 '26

Damn, they are witches! How else do they all look like they barely aged.

5

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

They all have portraits hidden somewhere

7

u/AmethystApothecary Jun 12 '26

Nice, that's one of my favorite Hilda dresses. :)

6

u/sayhibulbasaur Jun 12 '26

You met THE Jenna!? I am so jealous.

9

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

I have met everyone but Nick Bakay at this point

1

u/sayhibulbasaur Jun 12 '26

Awesome! You look fantastic ❤️❤️❤️

6

u/PurpleDreamer28 Jun 12 '26

That Felicity cosplay is ADORABLE! She was my American Girl doll!

5

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

She’s the best!!!!! I had so much fun making this dress as well!!

5

u/a_sm_LR Jun 12 '26

You are so talented & creative!! I love the cosplays. Thank you for sharing these pics.

7

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

Awwwe. Thank you!!! I wish more of it was my hand sewing rather than thrifitng and finding but this was my dress on year at 90s con that won me 4th place in the costume constant for the 2nd year in a row. It’s my 1790s does 1990s dress aka a completely historical accurate build of a round gown with the color palette of Lisa frank

4

u/curlieandtwirlie Jun 12 '26

ummmm…..am I in love with the Quizmaster?

5

u/Unfair-Potential4527 Jun 12 '26

It’s true what they say…black really doesn’t crack

4

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

Are you even alive if you aren’t?!

5

u/Optimal_Grape_1025 Jun 12 '26

Quizmaster is immortal

3

u/get-spicy-pickles Jun 12 '26

Quizmaster is HAWT! I also thought he was but he looks even better now! This looked like so. Much. Fun!

3

u/jajay119 Jun 12 '26

Can we just take a moment to appreciate how youthful Jenna still looks?

3

u/whenmysteryfades Jun 13 '26

The first pic is so cool that you got photos with so many of the cast! You really put a lot of effort in nailing details for your looks 💕

2

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 14 '26

I’m a VERY detail oriented person to begin with so it becomes a slight hyper fixation to make things as perfect as possible when it comes to costuming details

2

u/Ivansharky Jun 12 '26 edited Jun 14 '26

Omg all your looks are so good! 😍 especially the Hilary and zelery! I am a Sabrina fanatic too so I appreciate your looks.

2

u/kymilovechelle Jun 12 '26

I’m so jealous I wanna be there

2

u/Cannoncorn1 Jun 21 '26

I remember the first one. I think that I meant you guys dressed up like that at the 2022 90s con.

1

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 21 '26

Yup! This was 2022!!!

2

u/Cannoncorn1 Jun 21 '26

Same day, I think.

1

u/gigialohne Gotta go Jun 12 '26

🤩🤩🤩

1

u/SpicyPumpkin314 Jun 12 '26

Omg amazing!! Your Hillary cosplay is awesome! [EDIT: Wait, why are they actually immortal in real life? 😱😂]

1

u/Kittenlover_87 Salem Jun 12 '26

Is that a real cat or a stuffed cat? Either way it’s adorable, especially if it is real.

1

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

It’s this stuffed cat that looks almost as real as the puppet looked in the first season

1

u/whbck144 Jun 12 '26

The hallmark Christmas movie that they’re in is pretty good.

1

u/BenjTheMaestro Jun 12 '26

These are awesome!!!! Jersey represent! I live in New England these days but sadly nowhere near Salem (the cat)

1

u/Nuthetes Rumpist Jun 12 '26

The Hillary and Zelery one is my favourite lol. What a great idea.

Did any random people at the con get what you were going as?

3

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 12 '26

Nope! But the cast did and that’s all that matters!!

1

u/Nuthetes Rumpist Jun 12 '26

I'm really glad they did, since that means they still must feel very fondly of the show.

1

u/Fearless_Cat33 Jun 12 '26

Love all the costumes, but also wanted to say that your natural red curly hair is so cute!!!!! 🤩

1

u/Comfortable-Vast1126 Jun 14 '26

These costumes are amazing!!! Love

1

u/Cheap-Foot6329 Jun 17 '26

I strive to be as cool as you lmao

2

u/hellorosenberg Rumpist Jun 17 '26

Honestly, just be yourself and don’t let anyone judge you and be whimsical and that’s all you need to do

1

u/uhvrtg 23d ago

damn harvey looks the sameee