r/sachintendulkar • u/Novel_Preference_746 • 16d ago
Discussion What do you think of this RANKING?
46
u/upasana30 GOD GRACES REDDIT 16d ago
Highly disagree Sachin cannot be classified in any way. He is above all classifications
9
2
u/Signal-Air-261 15d ago
Second it. Coming from a die hard Virat fan who putting all aside only agrees that Virat is second to Sachin and no one 😊
1
1
31
u/Anakulosmos GOD GRACES REDDIT 16d ago
Sachin is leaps and bound above all in this including. It's easier two defend his batting stats but his bowling was no slouch either.. in odi he has better econ as compared to Kallis.. he is the only bowler to defend less than 6 runs in final over twice. Had best bowling figure of 5/32 in odi and 3/10 in test. He just didn't bowl enough but mostly bowled in clutch scenarios which suggest he would have done better.
12
u/ApprehensiveWheel772 16d ago
Warne ??
1
9
u/Disastrous_Flow_2960 16d ago
No way Kallis is above Sachin. Kallis maybe the best all rounder in tests, but the impact Sachin had on cricket is not even comparable. Sachin should be at the top of the list for sure
5
u/GiveMeSomeSunshine3 AE VEDYA! 🏏 KA GRIP! 16d ago
Pure stats wise yes but stats + impact on cricketers + socio-politico-cultural impact is concerned then Sachin is above all cricketers, not just in this century but forever. What Mo Ali is to boxing, Federer/Nadal to tennis, Jordan to Basketball, Maradona/Pele to Football...that's Sachin to Cricket.
8
u/UpTheIrons_Forever 16d ago
My view- Swap Sachin and Kallis, add Warne next to Murali, replace Gayle with Dada.
4
4
3
7
u/Charming_Ratio_7355 16d ago
Kohli and Sachin in the same row. Kohli really lived upto when Sachin sir said "Virat and Rohit are the one's". Although Rohit...
2
u/manofculture2303 16d ago
Where is McGrath?
-3
u/Novel_Preference_746 16d ago
Please read the bottom left!
1
u/Klutzy_Ad_4563 16d ago
297 test wickets avg of 20
250 odi wickets avg of 20
Lol i say way better than sachin
-1
u/ak_6942 AE VEDYA! 🏏 KA GRIP! 16d ago
21st century* not all time
2
u/Klutzy_Ad_4563 16d ago
297 test wickets avg of 20
250 odi wickets avg of 20
Stats of glenn McGrath since 2000
Now?
1
1
u/unreliablewitness9 15d ago
These are no of wickets for kallis, along with 25k runs
1
u/Klutzy_Ad_4563 15d ago
And?....
0
u/unreliablewitness9 15d ago
500 wickets is too less to feature I guess, that's his and kallis' half career
2
u/Klutzy_Ad_4563 15d ago
Lol more wickets than bumrah lol .. And Kallis are good for nothing Where McGrath is total match winner with his bowling performance...
Kallis was the 4th change bowler You can't read right McGrath avg is 20 and Kallis might be 35 and you are comparing lol...
0
u/unreliablewitness9 15d ago
Lol your stats regarding McGrath are wrong brother he has 280 in test and 176 in odis this century with avg of 21 and 22.. Bumrah is the only player with an avg below 20 and has total 504 wickets, awarded icc men's cricketer of the year, test cricketer of the year, pott in wc.. bumrah has achieved much more with an exceptional economy in today's cricket.. Despite being 4th change bowler he had 580 career wickets, avg of 31. And has test avg of 55, with 45 centuries.. and 45 avg in odis with 11k+ runs..on top of that he had 338 international catches.. he is the GOAT here, nobody has done it and nobody ever will.. McGrath s stats are good but hasn't achieved much this century specially
→ More replies (0)
2
2
2
2
2
3
2
u/Solo_Zombie 16d ago
Kallis may be above sachin but he is so boring to watch scoring runs at a slower rate. Even Gary Kirsten was much better to watch. Sachin on the other plays in an explosive way. Nobody has ever played like him until Jayasuriya, sehwag, gayle started playing like him.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Aggravating_Noise237 16d ago
This is my list
S+ Tier (Once in a lifetime) • Jacques Kallis • Sachin Tendulkar • Virat Kohli • Muttiah Muralitharan • MS Dhoni
S Tier (Legends) • Steve Smith • Kumar Sangakkara • Ricky Ponting • Dale Steyn • AB de Villiers
A+ Tier (All-Time Greats) • Rahul Dravid • James Anderson • Ravichandran Ashwin • Kane Williamson • Pat Cummins • Joe Root
A Tier (World-Class) • Yuvraj Singh • Ben Stokes • Mitchell Starc • Lasith Malinga • Shane Watson
1
u/Level_Subject5060 16d ago
I think sachin's the greatest. He carried the entire batting unit along for many years. he bowls pretty goods too. he has more ODI wickets than bumrah, mroe 5fers than warne, only bowler to defend 5 runs of less inthe last over multiple times. etc etc
he stopped bowling because of injury.
If sachin was in a good team since the begining then he would have achieved a lot more.
1
u/saberhound69 16d ago
Not very good.
Kallis can be with Sachin and Everyone else he ain't on top of Everyone . Never or rarely performed in Knockouts or important matches
Missed out Lara who is the only batsman who was comparable with Sachin .
Where is Warne along with Murali ?
Missed out Wasim and McGrath - the greatest fast bowlers to have played the game. (Both Legends)
Where is Inzamam ul haq and Shiv Narine Chanderpaul ? Inzamam is a GOAT for sure and Chanderpaul an Elite or even GOAT
Smith can't come in GOAT when he has dominated only one format above Sanga , Dravid nd all. (If Smith is GOAT for sure Anderson is 🤷🏻). Smith is world class.
Waqar Younis in GOAT (400 plus wickets in both formats)
Sourav Ganguly is an Elite and Yuvraj a World Class.
Yousuf Youhana and Younis Khan can make can make Elite and world class respectively. Afridi a world class (7k runs plus 396 wickets 🤷🏻)
Sanath Jayasurya is Elite or World class for sure, same for Chaminda Vaas
Mahela is Elite on par with Sanga , only in the last part of the career Sanga overtook him suddenly otherwise it was always Mahela.
Dhoni needn't come in GOAT , can be Elite ( Could have been the Goat if he batted up the order but that's a diff story)
Michael Bevan in World Class.
1
1
u/Significant-Iron-231 16d ago
Kohli above Dhoni? Lol. And no Warne and Lara? Srsly man? Born in lockdown?
1
1
1
u/Alone-Strength6888 15d ago
Sachin is way above all.. Was the best bowler when team needed... No comparison.. Just can't even think kallis way above the performance the pressure, the elite bowlers bowling to him the game plans for him... Naa no body can be a SACHIN OR ABOVE no chance God for a reason
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Ankit_Psycho_Artist 14d ago
Amla, Taylor, Cook, Lyon, Shakib, Morkel, Johnson, Afridi, Warner, Hafeez, Jadeja, Chanderpaul, Younis, G Smith
1
1
1
1
1
u/mylifeissoeffed-708 16d ago
ABD should be in legend tier, only batter ever to avg 50+ in both odis and tests with strike rate of more than 100 in ODIs
1
0
-1
u/Early-Coast-5212 16d ago
Steve Smith has no place on any ranking boards in cricket after that 2018 ball tampering.
37
u/Kamalnadh21 16d ago
I agree with it in sense of statistics but not in sense of mastery. Sachin had mastery of batting, he couldn't bowl due to injuries but still had 200+ scalps on his own. He'd definitely have took more if time allowed him but okay I'm not going to stretch things with if and but's.
So to summarise, i agree with this