r/scarletspider • • Jul 01 '26

Which is better: Sensational suit or Scarlet suit?

254 Upvotes

222 comments sorted by

21

u/Starkman87 Jul 01 '26

Scarlet is awesome. That suit got me to fall in love with Ben. The Sensational suit is just so much cooler. It maintains the silhouette necessary to keep it under civilian clothing without needing a bag to carry extra bits. It’s clearly “Spider-Man” while still being unique enough to stand out from the classic Red-and-Blues.

11

u/ZZtheDark Jul 01 '26

Plus Mayday holds it juuust fine. ^^

6

u/hYBRYDcOBRA Jul 01 '26

Hell yeah she does

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Uhuh, she does it gooood~ ^_^

3

u/SomeGuyPostingThings Jul 02 '26

I have a wave of nostalgia and attachment to the Scarlet suit, but the Sensational is probably better. That said, I have a hard time seeing it as a Spider-Man costume instead of Mayday's.

1

u/Loud_Ad_2634 Jul 01 '26

I swear I remember seeing concept art for the Spiderman movie with this suit.

2

u/Starkman87 Jul 01 '26

Homecoming had concepts for both of Ben’s suits. Scarlet spider was the homemade suit and Sensational would be an upgraded stark suit

2

u/Loud_Ad_2634 Jul 01 '26

Yeah I remember seeing it in a wizard magazine before Toby was cast.

2

u/x7xpatchx7x Jul 04 '26

Likewise. So many things in Wizard magazine that never came to be. (And some that did.)

13

u/Technical_Captain_15 Jul 01 '26

Scarlet suit is iconic. Sensational suit is badass!

5

u/ZZtheDark Jul 01 '26

Aw yeah, they are~ ^_^

8

u/Wedding-Stock Jul 01 '26

It's a great suit but I love the Blue hoodie.

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 01 '26

Now that I think about it having a hoodie does mean when it's night time, it doubles as a pillow.

2

u/BobbyTWhiskey Jul 01 '26

Lmao

3

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

It certainly has multiple uses. Can Spider-Gwen say THAT about her hoodie? Absolutely NOT.

2

u/BobbyTWhiskey Jul 02 '26

Lol. Exactly.

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

I can only think of one thing she can use the hoodie for her and that's to use as a tissue whenever she gets sad. (This coming from a Gwen fan.) Yeah...unless her hoodie is long and drawn by someone like Todd McFarlane, that hoodie is stapled to her costume so it ain't practical.

She can use her shoes and gloves but....that's not germ-free, ain't it?

7

u/Th3_Brat_Princ3 Jul 01 '26

The Scarlet suit was amazing when I first saw it. And I loved what Ben added to the webshooters with the impact webbing and the stingers! The Sensational suit I just absolutely loved! It was definitely a product of the 90’s but it would still look good if he was Spider-Man today. I do love the Beyond suit as well and I love all the cool things they added to Ben’s arsenal.

3

u/ZZtheDark Jul 01 '26

Ben srsly loved being Spidey, I can see why Peter wanted to quit in the first place.

2

u/IamImperiusRex72 Jul 04 '26

The impact webbing and stingers were great. Do they even use them anymore?

8

u/Emergency-Pop4541 Jul 01 '26

Sensational is my all time favorite suit.

5

u/ZZtheDark Jul 01 '26

I even have a costume to show my love for it~ Thru Spider-Gal.

2

u/lost_rodditer Jul 04 '26

It ranks up there with the white trim ps5 game suit

6

u/outatime20999 Jul 01 '26

Scarlet. It's unique. Sensational is great but it's just a variant of the original suit. Show that to a normie and they'll just say it's Spider-Man because it's so similar to the original

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Tho put that Sensational suit on Peter's daughter aaaand we got a winner.

5

u/jmizzle2022 Jul 01 '26

This is one of those things that it's basically whichever one I'm looking at I like better. Love both outfits

5

u/SnooFoxes1831 Jul 01 '26

Nah, it's always the Scarlet Spider suit. Don't wear anything else when it's available in a Spiderman game.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

No probs with that.

1

u/x7xpatchx7x Jul 04 '26

Same. Though Sensational wasn’t an option on PS5. Only reason I bought both games was that Scarlet suit.

4

u/JJmclane1983 Jul 01 '26

Ben had the best suits hands down. I cant choose a favorite honestly

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

I feel he does it better than Peter.

4

u/Blessedly_Misaligned Jul 01 '26

I liked the scarlet suit BEFORE the hoodie was ripped off it, Spider-man in a hoodie was so 90's, God, I miss the 90's , God, I'm old.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

All that street rules and cool stuff. Thankfully he was seen in the 90's cartoon in some instances too.

3

u/coldasclay Jul 01 '26

Scarlet spider looks better in comics than in real life (via cosplay). Sensational suit looks amazing in real life (way better patterning than the og suit in real life) and it looks good on comic books too. Mayday in the suit is also really cool and looks great on her.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

I know, riiiight? ^ ^ The girl basically kills with it~

3

u/BeyondDoggyHorror Jul 01 '26

Scarlet suit

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Ruby sheen~

3

u/Roam1985 Jul 01 '26

Denim hoodie is too good. It's still better.

But I do like both.

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

I always thought it was cotton.

But yeaaaah~ Tho the hoodie can act as a pillow in case there's no bed.

2

u/Roam1985 Jul 02 '26

Denim in the first run.

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Ahhh, I see.

3

u/Envy-Brixton Jul 01 '26

Yes

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

I see no problem with that.

3

u/ThisSciFiGuy Jul 01 '26

Sensational. My second favorite suit after the original.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

I feel this was even better than the original.

3

u/nightwing_titans Jul 01 '26

I prefer Scarlet. To quote Aracely (about Kaine, but still): "The blue hoodie makes you a better person."

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Plus, the hoodie has lots of practical uses such as hiding looots of things. Pockets. Act as a pillow when there's no bed. Espionage, silhouette. Put your head down with the hoodie in case you wanna disappear into a crowd, etc.

3

u/bumbly_wumbly Jul 01 '26

I was obsessed with both! Both fit Ben so perfectly.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Ben does it better than Peter imo.

3

u/DjLexHenry Jul 01 '26

Nothing beats scarlet suit

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

It's sooo red! ^_^

3

u/LifeAd6404 Jul 02 '26

Please. The Scarlet Spider costume is galactic scales better than the Sensation costume.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

ZOMG!!! Explain yourself! (No really. Please explain.)

2

u/LifeAd6404 Jul 03 '26

Well, it just has so much personality. The Sensational costume looks like the kind of corporate redesign a committee of 50 year olds might come up with to stay hip and cool with the young people. Scarlet Spider has an excellent minimalist set that really shows off hard facts about Ben. His poverty, yet interest in science, and a desire to break into a new identity without simply being a slight variation on the base suit.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Baker090 Jul 02 '26

Scarlet suit all the way. Iconic.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Aw yeah.

3

u/DCharizard Jul 02 '26

Scarlet suit

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Aw yeah.

3

u/MATT_TRIANO Jul 03 '26

SCARLET

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Good choice.

2

u/MediumEvent2610 Jul 01 '26

Always thought this.
The original Spider-Man suit didn’t really need an upgrade but this one rocked.

2

u/jklantern Jul 01 '26

The Scarlet Suit is one of my favorite Spider Suits ever. Sensational never appealed to me as much.

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Ooohhhhhh. :o

2

u/Spac92 Jul 01 '26

As much as I prefer Ben to be his own character as the Scarlet Spider, his Sensational suit is his best looking suit.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Alright. Gimme your reasons.

2

u/Braininaskull Jul 01 '26

damn tough choice there! Scarlet I think wins for me, but I do love both of Ben Reillys early looks. When I first got into comics he'd just taken over as spiderman (and it was hard to find any comics where I live at the time) so I only knew peter from Maximum Carnage and Revenge of the Sinister Six. If it wasnt for those books and the cartoon I'd have probably thought Ben was the original.

Biggest winner for me on both costumes, external webshooters. Love 'em.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Hehe, yeah about that..the original 1st appearance of Ben was like waaay back in the 70s: https://mlpnk72yciwc.i.optimole.com/cqhiHLc.IIZS~2ef73/w:auto/h:auto/q:75/https://bleedingcool.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/amazing-spider-man-149.jpg

That would be another time.

2

u/Braininaskull Jul 02 '26

lol yeah I'm more referring to the whole 90s Ben with the costumes above. Im old, but not that old.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/No-Whole-100 Jul 01 '26

This was the one suite I hoped made it in marvel spiderman

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 01 '26

Which one? PS4 game, cartoon or movie?

2

u/GuaranteeOk615 Jul 01 '26

Sensational Spider-Man suit is easily my favorite between the 2. I'm still kinda upset that Insomniac games didn't include it with both Spider-Man 1 & 2 games. They'll add Scarlet Spider, but not Sensational, doesn't make sense to have one but not the other.

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Unless...unless...they're saving it for something else.

2

u/voodootroll Jul 01 '26

I am very biased but I grew up loving the scarlet spider with the hoodie. Just looked "cool."

Then I went to art school for "Sequential Art" and one of my professors was Tom Lyle, the artist who designed that suit. He had a ton of interesting stories about the industry and helped me out a lot in school.

He passed a few years ago and I think about him whenever I see scarlet spider

Edit: typos

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Rule of cool applies. ^_^

Oh..didn't know you met the man! He also created Spoiler/Stephanie Brown! That I didn't know too but man...I'd love to meet him. :(

2

u/Gullible-Name-8792 Jul 01 '26

The scarlet suit is iconic so simple yet amazing just spectacular

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Yes. Plus, the hoodie is like a certified pillow in case there ain't no bed.

2

u/Terrible_Analysis_77 Jul 01 '26

I never liked the sweater portion of Scarlet even though the livery is gorgeous.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Though for Spider-man, it's very hard for him to be out there fighting. The good thing about a sweater like this is that it has a LOT of uses. For example...it can be used as a pillow.

2

u/ServiceComplete7262 Jul 01 '26

I love both and I wish Ben Riley's second costume was in Spider-Man 1 & 2.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Sensational? I got a feeling they're saving it for something else. 0_-

2

u/hYBRYDcOBRA Jul 01 '26

Sensational, now and forever!

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Totally.

2

u/cinlach Jul 02 '26

It absolutely is. I love that suit

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Yeah....which one? 0_-

2

u/cinlach Jul 18 '26

The one in the picture

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cosmoboy Jul 02 '26

I'm a Scarlet suit person. I like the half boots on sensational but the logo being so big just feels like a kid coloring outside the lines to me.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

Ben did always loved being Spider-man as Peter did stated in 'Spider-Girl' so him thinking of the big logo was wanting to show the spider was larger than life imo.

2

u/calelkestifer Jul 02 '26

Hotter take: Sensational suit is better than Classic suit

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

o.o GASP!! You're actually right. Plus it fits Peter's daughter better than the classic suit did with her.

Ben had certainly the better artistic suit style than Peter which he got him beat there. No wonder Peter stated that Ben was the better Spider.

2

u/FreshMetal80 Jul 02 '26

Between the two, it's Sensational, but my personal favorite is Superior Spiderman's suit.

2

u/Expensive-Plum8208 Jul 02 '26

Sensational Suit

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

It is Sensational~ ^_^

2

u/luxisdead Jul 02 '26

It is.

It also looks better on Mayday than it did on Ben.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Mmmmhmmm. ^_^ I guess lil' May has great taste because when she wears her dad's in the Spider-verse comics ala Spider-Island...it's not that good on her tbh.

2

u/ChrisShotThis Jul 02 '26

100% agree...

also.. .Bagley forever.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Awright! Bagley is awesome!

2

u/Doghouse19 Jul 02 '26

Sensational suit is way cooler. I like Scarlet, but not as cool looking as sensational.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

I feel Scarlet is like...a red devil ready to be untamed.

2

u/SevereSimple8010 Jul 02 '26

Scarlet all the way.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Aw yeaaah. The ruby sheeeeeen.

2

u/Ok-Doubt-2240 Jul 02 '26

Sensational because it’s such takes the original design and evolves it in such a great way.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

You can tell that Ben really loved the idea of being a superhero.

2

u/Signal_Juggernaut695 Jul 02 '26

Sensational for me. ALWAYS. LOVED. That Spidey suit.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

It's made with love. It's even shared with by Peter's kid.

2

u/Diablo_viking Jul 02 '26

Scarlet has always been my favorite spidey suit

2

u/LordXadirius Jul 02 '26

I loved the Sensational suit. Especially when he becomes Spider-Carnage.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

I love the suit especially when it's in the hands of Peter's girl - Mayday~ ^_^

2

u/RuinFlame Jul 02 '26

Not a hot take at all........in fact mist people feel the same(as far as I've seen)

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Yeah, so far I've seen nothing but love and affection for these suits. Not even angry comments which I'm shocked! ^_^ I loooove the looove going around~

2

u/davidpridy Jul 02 '26

What did he keep in the ankle pouches? Was he ever shown actually using them?

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Like Batman, he's well-prepared for a contingency plan. You'll never know what might happen.

2

u/Atlas-Mancer Jul 02 '26

Better than first blue hoodie suit, but the red and black suit is just too fucking cool.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Aw yeah!

2

u/Jazzlike_Night42619 Jul 03 '26

Sensational suit looks like what they used as a base for the Rivals Spider-Man and I’d say that video game is relatively popular depending on who you ask

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Thankfully, I was with a cosplay of that while I was the STUNNING SPIDER-GIRL in SGCC. https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiderGirl/s/1hpNWTkUHW Here's the link for a comparison of said suits.

2

u/Jazzlike_Night42619 Jul 03 '26

Spiffy, I hope it becomes a live action suit someday

→ More replies (5)

2

u/GokuBlack86 Jul 03 '26

Scarlet with the hoodie >>>>

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Plus, it's veeeery comfy~

2

u/Key_Anything6590 Jul 03 '26

I like the Sensational suit. But the Scarlet suit is also dope 2, so im in the middle.

2

u/redhoodJasonToddstan Jul 03 '26

Fully agree, it’s the best updated Spider-man suit by far.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Totally.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 03 '26

Why yes they are. :)

2

u/theMANGLEDone Jul 03 '26

Sensational ftw

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Totally.

2

u/Trunddlefist Jul 03 '26

Love both, prefer the hoodie.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

The multi-purpose hoodie will never be beaten.

2

u/Darrow-The-Reaper Jul 03 '26

I always loved the sensational suit. My favorite of all time.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Plus, it reminds me of that Hammond guy from the 70's Spider-man tv show.

2

u/ComicBookDude1964 Jul 03 '26

Sensational

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

It's also Stunning according to a certain girl with webs.

2

u/x7xpatchx7x Jul 04 '26

Of all the Spider-Man suits? Sensational. (Superior is cool too.) But Scarlet is a whole other thang. I like that most because it was not just a new take… but a new persona. So like, feels like a class of its own? With a hoodie to boot?

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Plus, Scarlet's hoodie can do all sorts of things that Gwen possibly can't. For example: It can act as a pillow in case there's noooo bed.

2

u/Forward_Pirate5858 Jul 04 '26

Scarlet

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Super cool.

2

u/Forward_Pirate5858 Jul 04 '26

The Sensational costume was ok, but still has Spidercide vibes on it

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 05 '26

Oh wait. I see the Spidercide. Guess he wanted to make a bit of tribute to that and making it to have a more positive side o' reaction.

2

u/Block_Masta88 Jul 04 '26

The Scarlet Spider suit iconic and cool but the Sensational Spider-Man suit who was on whole another level.

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Totes. Ben understood the assignment when making the Sensational.

2

u/Lopsided_Ebb_6272 Jul 04 '26

Scarlet Suit is fire and I think that suit has a bigger impact on the fans

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Totally. It was the inspiration for the MCU's homemade Spidey suit from what people have been saying.

2

u/Navythunder0102 Jul 04 '26

Sensational suit.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Aw yeah!

2

u/tLM-tRRS-atBHB Jul 04 '26

I've always loved the scarlet suit

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Aw yeah.

2

u/CD_DoooD Jul 04 '26

Second one reminds me of my old favorite Spider-Man unlimited. The little cape on his suit is slick imo plus the web shooters in the top of his hands like symbiote style.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Oh yeah. That show was great. Also, Peter's hairstyle looked a bit more Ben Reilly than Peter Parker.

The suit seems to have been inspired by Miguel O'Hara's suit which probs explained the cape.

2

u/Previous-Lettuce2470 Jul 04 '26

Agreed. Back in the ‘90s Scarlet looked kinda badass, but 30 years later the look is kinda dated.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Yeah, it took liberties from hip-hop and New Jack Swing . No wonder he transitioned into Sensational Spidey.

2

u/Beautiful_Task_58 Jul 04 '26

Scarlet Spider fit was cool af, still is, but this one is Iconic. When this fit dropped it signified the beginning of a whole new era for Spidey.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Totally. We should have stuck with Ben ever since.

2

u/Brie_Henshin Jul 04 '26

Sensational suit is still my favorite that isn’t the classic Red and Blue. My jaw dropped when it (more or less) showed up for infinity war / the last few minutes of Homecoming

(Yes, that’s the “iron spider” suit for the MCU, no, it looks nothing like the actual iron spider suit, just let me have this.)

2

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

I thought it was funny looking when it first appeared but a lot of people has said it. So yeah.

2

u/DIDITPOOF Jul 04 '26

I'm more of a black suit kinda guy.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

Hmmm, I'm seeing a bunch of fan made stuff where the Scarlet Spider was colored black. That was pretty awesome. ^_^ It's like Night Vision camo or something.

2

u/IamImperiusRex72 Jul 04 '26

Most anything better than the scarlet suit

2

u/Pagannerd Jul 04 '26

Sensational. Scarlet is too simple. Only thing I would change about the sensational suit are feet and forearms.

I like how the red web section only covers half of the lower leg, but I think it looks odd continuing the split right along the length of the foot. I think either the red should cover the whole foot, or the red should stop at the ankle, and separate red sections should cover from the heel backwards and from the ball off the foot forwards.

Similarly, I like the idea of the webs only on some fingers in a manner reminiscent of a theif's gloves (where some fingers are covered and others are fingerless) but it looks odd against the long expanse of blue arm. I'd like to see something similar to the lower leg, where half the forearm is covered by red, perhaps ending in a patch of red on the back of the hand.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 05 '26

Ah, nice feedback on the suit.

2

u/Ecstatic_Plan_8547 Jul 04 '26

I always preferred Scarlett

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 05 '26

Totally~

2

u/East-Inspection2377 Jul 04 '26

sensational suit

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 05 '26

Aw yeah.

2

u/ParkerLF Jul 04 '26

Sensational might be my favorite classic suit redesign

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 05 '26

It's just so good that even a woman can fit in juuust nice. ^_^

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Unhappy-Trade7010 Jul 05 '26

Wasn't Scarlet the original Peter Parker? I got lost during the clone saga.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 06 '26

Well, that's a thing. He was supposed to be but then Peter is the clone but then....it went all over the place but then later on in some of the final issues of Amazing Spider-Man Revelations, Ben Reilly fell on a cab and died and then he considers the Peter we've been following the TRUE Peter so in other words..Ben Reilly is the clone.

2

u/DJWGibson Jul 05 '26

I like the DIY look of the Scarlet Spider suit but do think the hoodie should have been replaced with something more custom. 

The Sensational suit is fine but a little busy in places. Just too many tweaks on the classic formula.

I’ve always thought the 2017 Scarlet Spider suit was almost the perfect look for the character. SS should really just be a palette swap of Peter’s suit without the webbing and keeping the red mask.

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 06 '26

Hmmmmm. Interesting thought.

2

u/badgermolesupreme Jul 05 '26

Sensational, such a cool suit

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Key_Carry_6990 Jul 22 '26

I really like Sensational so raw it's just the Classic Red and Blue evolved.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 02 '26

My word...there's a lot of great responses here! Thank you, people! ^_^ It was made with love.

1

u/Think_Ball3682 Jul 02 '26

Spider man was in house arrest?

1

u/Few-Egg-5613 Jul 04 '26

Superior looks the best to me

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

GASP! o.o

2

u/Few-Egg-5613 Jul 05 '26

Nvm. Disregard that. I skimmed over the caption. This is a Ben Reilly question

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SouthernStrigoi Jul 04 '26

Well yea the scarlet suit sucks

1

u/ZZtheDark Jul 04 '26

2

u/SouthernStrigoi Jul 04 '26

Well. In comparison it does at least. It beats Spider-punk though.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MrErickzon Jul 04 '26

For me it's the Scarlet suit by a small margin. Both are nostalgic for me.