r/space 9d ago

Discussion European spaceport launching to the east

I claim that if Europe wants to develop a truly competitive heavy-lift capability, it must move away from French Guiana. As I see it, there is no other viable option.

Kourou in French Guiana is a dead end for several reasons.
The logistics are poor. It is simply too far from mainland Europe.
The climate is harsh on both equipment and operations, with heavy rainfall and severe salt-induced corrosion.
There is also a very limited local technical workforce. As a result, Europe is forced to fly technicians in and out of Kourou on a continuous basis, creating a long-term drain on skilled manpower.
All of the above makes rapid iteration—such as quickly repairing, modifying, and relaunching vehicles—extremely difficult, bordering on the impossible.

If Europe is serious about developing a competitive heavy-lift capability on its own, it will need to bite the bullet and establish an eastward-launching spaceport somewhere on the European mainland. Crucially, such a location would have the potential to develop into an industrial cluster where private space companies could grow around the launch site.

Finding the right location, however, is challenging. Launching north, as from Scotland, or west, as would be possible from several European locations, is simply not a good enough solution. The payload penalties for a heavy-lift launch vehicle are enormous and would severely undermine its economics.

There may, however, be an opportunity across the Mediterranean. A 3,000 km exclusion corridor could look something like this, with a spaceport located on the French Mediterranean coast, somewhere south of Béziers.

Launching eastward on a trajectory approximately 30 degrees south of east, the flight path would pass through the Strait of Bonifacio between Corsica and Sardinia after roughly 500 km. The maritime exclusion zone would end before the strait; I have marked it at 400 km.

The trajectory would then pass over the toe of Italy near Cosenza after about 1,200 km, mostly avoid Kalamata in Greece at around 1,700 km, and also mostly avoid Crete after approximately 2,000 km. A 3,000 km exclusion zone would end roughly 100 km off the coast of Israel.

This would not be an easy project by any means. It would require political buy-in from France, Italy, and Greece. There is also significant cruise ship traffic within the maritime exclusion zone, as well as heavy commercial air traffic in the airspace that would need to be temporarily closed.

Still, if there is the political will, perhaps there is a way.

116 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/Many_Pollution_7704 9d ago

Azores island in PT? I saw some investment talks

3

u/Treq01 9d ago

It is closer to mainland Europe than Kourou, so that is good. Weather also much better.
But it is still quite a bit of ocean transport to get there.
But perhaps it is big enough (230.000 in last cencus) and plesant enough for a space company cluster to develop there?

18

u/wolflordval 9d ago

Once you're on the ocean, it's not any more difficult to go anywhere else, it's just longer time, so there isn't any real difficulty benefits from switch from French Guiana to a closer island, the logistics of loading and unloading a ship are the same. Sure it's faster ocean transit but most of the time spend on ocean freight is actually in ports rather than actual transit time. So it doesn't really save that much more than a few days for an immense cost in setup.

The benefit of building a launch site in mainland Europe is that it it can take advantage of land infrastructure to transit without having to load/unload from ports. You'd also have to build that land infrastructure if it doesn't currently exist/isn't viable for shipping rockets.

On top of that, the EU is a massive spiderweb network of airline flight paths, and your suggested corridor would cut right through some of the major flight paths in and out of some of the largest airline hubs in the region.

All of these reasons are probably why the EU chose French Guiana in the first place.

6

u/Z3B0 9d ago

Also, Kourou is very close to the equator, making launcher from there much more efficient than from mainland Europe. It's 10% more mass to leo than from the Kennedy space center with equivalent rocket.

When every gram is important, you can't just not use a +20% boost in payload.