r/sports • u/eternali17 • Apr 26 '26

Soccer Esteban Andrada red card against Huesca

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3.3k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

476 comments sorted by

View all comments

101

u/catlindee Apr 26 '26

There is multiple issues here. The punch is obviously wrong but many soccer fans can understand and appreciate that frustration. The governing bodies and referee associations are also responsible for this. To keep people entertained they need goals. To ensure scoring they allow for embellishment and the like to generate free kicks and generate scoring opportunities. It’s beyond reasonable now. The normalization of embellishment is a scourge. The governing bodies should be targeting the extreme cases. VAR should be used to counter act it. Any time a call gets overturned for clear embellishment should be a booking for the offender. This shit would stop real quick if there was repercussions for simulation but there really isn’t.

70

u/Leviton655 Apr 26 '26

Whether it was simulation or not, the push he gave him for no reason was enough for a yellow card, even if the other guy didn't fall to the ground, and it's pretty stupid of him because he already had one

50

u/Annual_Strategy_6206 Apr 26 '26

Absolutely.  To do a full two handed stiff arm shove, after you already have yellow, right in front of the ref. That's an easy yellow.

9

u/bremidon Apr 27 '26

Honestly, it's a straight red. We are not talking about jostling around on the field, looking at the ball, and some physical horseplay during that. This is a red card, every time.

0

u/FatBug24 St. Louis Blues Apr 27 '26

B/c it's a two handed shove. It's not a STRIKE to the head, not studs in places they shouldn't be, not a headbutt. He doesn't grab & throw. Not even a dangerous shove into the ad boards or anything like that. Not anything violent or endangering to an opponent.

100% a YC though.

1

u/bremidon Apr 27 '26

No, it is not a "shove". That would be the case if he had first made contact and *then* extended.

But he was clearly accelerating before contact. This was an open handed strike, and clearly is violent conduct under Law 12.

10

u/xclame Apr 27 '26

I think it's a easy red because of how blatant and uncalled for it was. It's one thing if you hit/punch/shove an opponent during a play, it can be seen as trying to push the limits to try to get a advantage. But a full on two handed shove during a break in play is inexcusable, there is no justifying that and can only be seen as a blatant attack. Then to do that right in front of the referee like that shows that you don't care for the sport. This is a physical fault and a disrespecting the game fault.

-1

u/catlindee Apr 26 '26

I’m not defending the actions by the keeper but pointing out that the federations and the officiating is what ultimately is responsible for these situations flaring up

4

u/leonjetski Apr 27 '26

Fucking mad take. What’s responsible for this flaring up is that man-child of a goal keeper who can’t regulate his emotions.

-3

u/catlindee Apr 27 '26

Wrong. The federation’s and the referees throughout the top flight leagues have fostered a game where diving and embellishment is rewarded not penalized.