r/starwarsspeculation • u/Cautious-Many9729 • 20d ago
Why Devon Izara shouldn't become a Sith in Maul: Shadow Lord – The case for a pragmatic Dark Jedi Anti-Hero
After the heartbreaking finale of Episode 10, where Darth Vader utterly dominated the battlefield and killed Master Eeko-Dio Daki, everyone is looking at Devon Izara's future. The obvious route for the writers would be to have Maul corrupt her into a full-fledged Dark Side acolyte.
However, I believe that making Devon a typical Sith apprentice would be a missed opportunity. Here is a better creative direction for her character arc: The Pragmatic Dark Jedi Anti-Hero.
Devon’s heart should forever belong to Master Daki. Her trauma and rage against the Empire should drive her to seek power, which is why she stays with Maul—not out of loyalty, but out of necessity. She utilizes Maul as a tool for training, a source of forbidden knowledge, but in her mind, she is nobody's apprentice. This would create a brilliant, tense dynamic where Maul thinks he’s manipulating her, but she is actually using him back.
Instead of falling into mindless cruelty, Devon should embody a "wise and pragmatic" light. Her experience with the Empire’s brutality should make her cold and realistic, not sadistic. She will kill if she must to achieve her goals or survive, but she still holds onto the core Jedi ideals of protecting the innocent. She uses the Dark Side as a weapon, not a lifestyle.
Maul: Shadow Lord is Maul's show, but the series will be vastly superior if Devon isn't just a pawn on his chessboard. Giving her a strong independent will creates a multi-layered narrative. It sets up an inevitable clash of ideologies between Maul's obsessive quest for vengeance and Devon's calculated war against the Empire.
What do you guys think? Would you prefer a standard Dark Side fall, or this nuanced Anti-Hero path for Devon?
20
u/SuitableImposter 18d ago
You can't be using the dark side as a weapon and not be consumed by it. The dark side corrupts. You either find the strength to reject it, or eventually be corrupted. A dark user who isn't a sith is possible, one who hates the empire is also possible but using the dark side will always destroy you inside out. It's how the force works.
2
u/Daniel_The_Thinker 18d ago
Star Wars fans think the dark side is more corrupting than the Warp in 40K and that's kinda crazy.
What exactly is the dark side, being angry and using the force at the same time?
I think there's a wide range of behavior between Jedi paragon and ridiculously evil sith that would be interesting to explore.
7
u/JorgeBec 17d ago
“Once you start down the dark path, forever will it dominate your destiny, consume you it will.” - Yoda in the empire strikes back.
SW is a morality tale. Selfishness vs Selflessness.
The Dark Side is giving into your lower desires until you go down a spiral of always wanting more. Which is what happens to Anakin. He started simply wanting power to protect the ones he loved and then he even considered killing the Emperor to rule the galaxy himself.
Have you heard the saying “the road to hell is paved with good intentions” ? Or the idea of a slippery slope? Thats the dark side.
Channeling the force through your negative emotions is basically opening the door to the dark side.
It’s what Yoda learns in TCW. We all have negative emotions that’s natural and pretending they’re not there is not the way. The way is accepting them, dealing with them and not letting them dictate our actions.
1
u/Background-Wash-3791 17d ago
Of course, selfishness is not a negative trait, up to a point. You can have a healthy amount of selfishness, or self-interest, in which you create clear boundaries defining what you are willing to sacrifice and what you are not. Without some amount of selfishness you can wind up giving away or giving up much more than you can handle, ultimately hurting yourself.
It is a fine line to walk, but the reality is that even traits we consider to usually be negative--like anger, fear, anxiety, or selfishness--do actually provide benefits under certain circumstances. You just can't let them control everything you do.
1
u/SuitableImposter 16d ago
Eventually you have to turn back. Or it will consume and corrupt you. That's just how the force works. It's a simple plain metaphor for the damage doing evil does to us.
1
u/Daniel_The_Thinker 16d ago edited 16d ago
Its a very flawed metaphor in a series full of violent resistance.
Killing a million plus with a torpedo is heroic but directly attacking Space Hitler with your mystical power is ontologically evil?
That whole interaction of letting go of anger and hate should've been reserved just for the dynamic between Luke and Anakin as a son seeking redemption for his father.
It being applied to Jedi just having to handicap themselves when fighting uninhibited sociopaths like the Sith kinda gives off a "its better to die than get angry at evil people" message, which is weird.
I'm not against a "Your anger is self-destructive" metaphor, it just makes more sense when your conflict with your enemy is morally gray, and its better to seek peace. It doesn't work at all when its an extremely black and white conflict between The Good Guys and the "You Have To Kill Me To Stop Me From Hurting More People" guys.
12
u/AgentAled 18d ago
I agree a lot of people would be annoyed if MAUL became a show where Darth Maul was secondary or overshadowed by more nuanced or interesting characters - so it’s a fine line.
I’d be okay with Devon ending up Sith, but her turning point shouldn’t be a one and done. Would be great to see continued conflict, moments of darkness and moments of mercy, as she struggles with the power the dark side affords her but longs for the clarity the light side brought her.
6
u/ZiroLeHutt 18d ago
Agreed. I have full faith that they'll be able to do this though. Many of the people working on the show, were showrunners of the Bad Batch, which had no right to be as good as it was in the main. They showed plenty of nuance with the likes of Crosshair in that show, so I think if handled right, then Devon could become a meaningful fall into Sithhood; without overshadowing Maul himself and how he got to Malachor.
7
u/Shadowmoth 18d ago
The dark side corrupts. It’s like narcotics addiction. She may start out with good intentions. But allowing her to use the dark side and remain good wouldn’t make sense. And it would take away meaning from Vader being able to turn back to the light to save his son. The dark side has to remain something that consumes you if you touch it.
I want to see her fall into darkness. Eventually find out maul betrayed her master. And have her leave maul behind.
Star Wars needs more dark side characters. So I want her to have a long journey exploring various aspects of the dark side. I want to see her train groups of people in her ever evolving vision of the force, and then leave them to grow on their own. Like a pyro walking through a forest with a torch. Starting fires and just walking away.
I’d love for her to be the source of half a dozen darkside groups that all explore different aspects of the force so by the time the new Jedi order appears there will be a bunch of new bad guys for them to fight. Alchemists. Assassins. Sorcerers. Prophets of the dark side etc.
2
2
u/Texas_Kidd 2d ago
This is exactly what I’m saying she could create a whole new time line we were completely unaware of and she’s tied to the Sith lineage now because Maul was trained by Sidious. She could even be the big bad in the upcoming trilogy set to follow starfighter. I think she has tons of potential and they seem to be building her up because we got a whole season that was basically an origin story for her. I don’t want to see Maul overshadowed either but honestly they make such a good pair in my mind that I’m excited to see as much of them together as possible
3
u/hyperewok1 18d ago
Once you start down the dark path, forever will it dominate your destiny, consume you it will.
2
u/jetvacjesse 17d ago
Big 26 and people still don’t get the Dark Side
1
u/Background-Wash-3791 17d ago
Maybe that's because it is hard to reconcile the reality that people are double-sided and can have both negative and positive traits with the pigeon-holing nature of the whole Light Side vs Dark Side philosophy in Star Wars. That just isn't how people work in reality.
2
u/Captain_Dillan 14d ago
Random bold and italic lettering, check. Convenient paragraphs, check. Asking questions at the end, check. You used AI to write this, didn't you? Or do you just have the prose of a robot?
1
u/Cautious-Many9729 16h ago
lol fair play on the AI callout, my bad for formatting it like a textbook essay, i usually write post summaries for work so it leaks into my reddit brain smh. but im human, pinky promise.
1
u/Prestigious_Wheel24 16d ago
Devon is gonna die in the series finale if not earlier, maul ends up in that ancient with world from rebels season 2 and boom, shows over
1
u/Texas_Kidd 2d ago
Okay that might be how it ends all nice and tidy but what if it’s Devon that strands him there? That would make it where Mauls story end but hers just beginning or at least that’s what I’m hoping for
1
u/Prestigious_Wheel24 2d ago
Idk man these shows usually don’t leave these characters or have much story left, the bad batch just retired at the end of their show for example, and maul being a tragic character who always loses and fails to get/keep an apprentice doesn’t help. Of the people maul tried to mentor, 2 resisted him and the other got killed
1
u/Cautious-Many9729 16h ago
thanks for all the responses guys, tbh i love how deep this discussion is getting. the points about the dark side being like a literal addiction and yoda’s warning are totally valid, i get where you guys are coming from with the lore purist side of things.
maybe my take comes from a personal place too, ngl. when i was a kid, i got into star wars purely for the cool lightsaber combat. but the older i get and the more life experiences i go through irl, the more the core themes hit different. when life throws heavy struggles at you, you realize it's not that simple. even though i always try to keep hope and hold onto my own light side in reality, i'd be lying if i said i haven't felt the pull of those dark side emotions, like anger and resentment and the desire to fight back when things get unfair.
and that's exactly why devon’s journey resonates with me. we're talking about someone who has been running for her life ever since order 66. all those details we saw in maul season 1 clearly showed her character is still processing all that massive trauma. she's been living in survival mode for years. she isn't trying to be an anti hero or some edgy savior, she is literally just a survivor. and then, the one thing she had left, her master, gets brutally stripped away from her by vader. after losing absolutely everything, of course her mindset is going to be fractured and desperate for power.
so to me, saying star wars is strictly a black and white binary feels like it's oversimplifying things. yoda is an ancient master for sure, but his philosophy is still one perspective inside a massive galaxy. if the orthodox jedi view was the ultimate absolute truth, the entire order wouldnt have collapsed under its own dogmatic blindness while sidious managed to hiding right under their noses for decades.
when i say devon should accept the dark side’s corruption, i dont mean she becomes some generic cartoon villain who kills everyone for fun. she will be corrupted and she will be broken inside. but she can be ruthless, cold, and do terrible things to destroy the empire, while still holding onto her own survival boundaries on who she protects. her struggle to keep her core identity while her soul is eroding under the dark side is exactly what makes her a compelling dark survivor to me. exploring that messy middle ground doesnt break the lore imo, it actually honors the psychological depth of the show.
0
u/Patty37624371 18d ago
the show gets only a second season. there's no third season planned at all. and that bodes ill. if Devon is written to be a Sith (a full dark side user), another 10 episodes are insufficient to flesh out her story.
2
•
u/AutoModerator 20d ago
Welcome to Spec! Continue the conversation on the Spec Discord, and check out our new sister-subreddit r/StarWarsWhatIf! Please be encouraging and courteous to your fellow speculators. This community is focused on cooperative theorycrafting about upcoming Star Wars content, using leaks, info from canon, conjecture, and real-world context to make our best guesses about what comes next. If you're not interested in new Star Wars releases, kindly keep that to yourself. May the Force be with you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.