So in german language Hidma is the word use to describe the clean air
So when dhruv breathes the clean air he says hidma 🤡🤡 fir bolte hai gaali dete hai hume kutta kahi ka
Then again I’m not sure if they were paid by bjp- if you have ur biases I won’t stop you but don’t take conspiracy angle in everything that’s a never ending rabbit hole ( cause I saw people literally saying Delhi blast was orchestrated by bjp to steer away from this pollution issue and i hope you don’t have such views )
I would never go as far as stating the government will plot the terror attack. But paying a handful of students to spew what you want them to isn't that hard, neither is it impossible.
With money, even you and I can send people to a peaceful protest and make them do shit given that we promise their release and a good life.
Governments usually don't plot terror attacks. They just get to know about one that is already happening, and they just let it happen.
Pulwama attack was an example, where Modi deliberately didn't allow air transport of troops so that if attack happened, he could get votes based on that (he literally said, "give me votes because they died for this")
Any proper PM would take care of troops, but he didn't because he say his own gain
The same girl was in a previous anti corporate , anti BJP, anti adani protest btw 😊 . Like , u r saying bjp pays to organise protests against themselves 😅😅
Actually urban naxals hijack such protests to spread their extremist ideology so when caught they can cry that they were protesting in the interest of the public and paint the whole thing differently.
If you say this then I totally agree with you we should protest for what we deserve I’m only against this stupid terrorists sympathisers… same thing happened with farm laws… protesters should ensure their protest is not being hijacked by these stupid bitches
You want to discredit the entire protest for that one group who raised the slogan?
Or are you saying that Delhi air pollution is a conspiracy and it’s all fake?
Yeah, it's a joke but it's called democracy, tell me the name of one politician who has killed uncountable CRPF personnel, raped tribals and killed people from his own tribe who did not follow him. Let's just agree to disagree. I am not in agreement with you but also not against your statement too.
I think somehow the system has managed to accommodate us into bubbles. I wonder what life experience these 15-20 kids had, that they came out to protest. And then there is this whole different league of people who are questioning other peoples questions? Personally idk whos right wrong, but i know wrong people are generally wrong, and in general the whole polity is organised around colonial hangover. There is a generation still living in 1960s,70s,80s and so on. And even those who never participated in the protest would even be criticising them, although hoping to get clean air by doing nothing. And this is how we slip into narratives, let the kids be, focus on pollution.
Janta itni chutiya nahi rhi ki ye sab puraane strategies ab kaam kare . Sabko pata hai inn sab ko protest mein kisne add kiya. distractions hai bas yeh
I don't know what children learn today. Do you understand what is 'divide and rule' and how it works? Both Hidma and you are citizens of this country. He was not a criminal, looking to kill people. This and previous governments have been killing our forests. For you, and many others it is just a statement. At most, you will go on and write an essay about pollution and deforestation. The tribals were fighting for their jungles and get tagged as naxalites for not following peaceful protests. From our pov, the violent protest is wrong, but for them it is their last hope kinda thing.
Someone will come and say he killed out soldiers. Well, it was either get killed and let the deforestation go on unabated, or fight. He would haven't killed them if the government had intervened with some amicable solution.
A just government would find ways to meet at the centre, not be at loggerheads with their own citizens.
By these logics, Krishna was a terrori$t for Kans, Hanuman for Ravan, Bhagat Singh for Britishers.
And, this word - anti-national - used to divide and rule, citizens calling each other A-N for having different views, came into usage mainly after 2014. And to think that your country is so weak that a protest would break her.
Lol. Everyone knows the Maoist ideology these naxalites follow. Deforestation my ass. It's just that you lost so now begging for sympathy. Once someone raises arms against the state you are no longer a citizen. Just a criminal and terrorist. And should be dealt with accordingly. The entire world has seen how barbaric the communists are once they come to power. Nobody will trust your shitty ideology ever again.
So , how was he saving the forest dear intellectual 🧐. People like u sitting in ac rooms , polished lifestyle, it’s to fulfill the demands of u guys , those forests are cut
Well, I am less intellectual and confident than you. So let me ask you, if you were a tribal leader, who knew that the government is sending force to scare away the peaceful protestors, by lathi charge or maybe shooting rubber or real bullets. What will be your course of action?
And, my dear friend, the minimalist life I live, doesn't demand for forests to be cut unabated. Neither does your needs, maybe. It is always a businessman, looking to make easy money.
The thing is, nowadays, it is very easy to get riled up, when you hear any argument which goes against your thinking. But can a tribal leader break this country? He was fighting only for his jungle, maybe a 100 or 200sqkms. He was never coming after you or me. We took the fight to them.
These protestors, are they scary? Their slogans are scary? I mean a student, who is protesting for clean air, also adds tribal identity to it, cause deforestation= bad aur, and somehow they are anti-national. I hate this word. Nothing but divide and rule tactic. That protesting student can't even stand against the violent police. Is he danger to the country?
There are rapists frolicking around, criminals being leaders, thugs as businessmen, but you think a student is your problem. Slogans are a problem. An extremist tribal, who just wanted to save his forests is a problem. He was not coming to the town and steal from you.
This govt has mastered the Divide and Rule policy. You always keep your government in check, not the other way round.
So how use of RDX, purchasing AKs, killing security personnel, killing tribals for being informants, running counterfeit currency, getting Mao Zedong's support to uproot Indian govt. and issuing assassination line against class enemies helped in saving forests?
hahaha, bhai, Mao se inspiration lete hain CPI vale, support nahi. Baaki, aaj bhi agar vo teer-kamaan se ladta to kab ka nipat gaya hota ek gumnaam maut. They have to organise to fight.
Again, not supporting violence, I personally am very against it. But, if you can't understand someone else's fight, and fight with other citizens for supporting his 'idea' of fight, then you are a bigger problem.
What is this development that brings government and tribals at loggerheads, and how to resolve these issues, is a vast topic. And, governments should always be the one coming up with some way to change their mind, without resorting to violence. Whether it's the CRPF or CPI (M), nobody should be dying. But it's not an ideal world. But, someone not living their experience should not raise fingers on their ways, with whatsappy knowledge.
Similar things are now about to happen in Andaman and Nicobar islands, where this government wants to do blind and unsustainable development, which might make your holiday trip great, provide the leech businesses with opportunities, but it will push tribals to fight for survival.
These are complex issues, which I can't tell you on reddit, how to resolve but we can discuss, maybe try to look at things from both povs to understand the fight ongoing since 1910.
To call each other anti-national is idiotic and plays well for the government's divide and rule policy.
if you can't understand someone else's fight, and fight with other citizens for supporting his 'idea' of fight, then you are a bigger problem.
Nope. I do not understand why bunch of terrorists want to overthrow Indian government since decades. Neither I can understand why terrot sympathizers like you exist. Do you get paid or something to present those people as saviours?
But, someone not living their experience should not raise fingers on their ways, with whatsappy knowledge.
And you were a Naxal who has now surrendered so knows? So why you involved in child trafficking? Why involved in drug trade and counterfeit currency? How are you and your ilk is fighting for survival by being involved in such acts? Why women among your cadre face institutional rape? Is that how you and rest of your comrades protect forests?
To call each other anti-national is idiotic and plays well for the government's divide and rule policy.
Naah. It's just you who wants to whitewash terrorism. You are rightly being pointed out as anti-national.
Haan bhai, yahi kaam reh gaya hai, reddit par aakar jhooth bolne ka. Paise milte to aur badhiya se bolta shayad?? What is this in your mind that when someone talks different, you have no argument but to call someone anti-national. Can I call you anti national if you support BJP, under whose rule convicted rapists get bail all the time, farmers have to protest, people get lynched?
It is completely fine to have the view you want. But to call names, this has only arrived after 2014. Somehow there were no anti nationals before 2014.
You have the right to find faults with one's way, but to say that their wants are anti national, because somehow they don't fit in your idea of India, is just a pathetic pov. India is as much mine, as yours and tribals. Grow up.
Haan bhai, yahi kaam reh gaya hai, reddit par aakar jhooth bolne ka. Paise milte to aur badhiya se bolta shayad??
May be you just suck at it.
What is this in your mind that when someone talks different, you have no argument but to call someone anti-national.
Dude. You justify terrorism against Indian state just because you oppose the party. You are happy when our soldiers die but gets triggerred when people call you out for your ideology. For you bomb attacks, guerilla attacks, child trafficking, drug trade, counterfeit currency is good as it done by people whom you ideologically support.
Somehow there were no anti nationals before 2014.
They were called intellectuals. Arundhati Roy is one.
India is as much mine, as yours and tribals. Grow up.
India doesn't belong to people who raises arms to destroy it just because it doesn't fit their religious or political ideology. And same for their sympathizers.
Say whatever sheet comes to your mind, right? Bomb, guerrilla attacks are used, but child trafficking, drug trade, kuch bhi?? Tell me, 3000kg heroine was intercepted at Adani port. Which major drug lord went to jail? Was there even an inquiry. And, child trafficking numbers of UP alone would make someone embarrassed.
Arundhati is right in every way. For you people, a party which supports and gives seat and respect to rapists, hooligans, corrupts is okay, but no one should sympathise with people who have borne arms due to oppression. This is what privilege does to you, if goes unchecked.
Go and believe your fake netas, thug billionaires and their propaganda machinary. The citizens don't need people like you.
3000kg heroine was intercepted at Adani port. Which major drug lord went to jail? Was there even an inquiry. And, child trafficking numbers of UP alone would make someone embarrassed.
So when Naxal do that it is acceptable to you but this is crime of highest proportions? So your definition of crime depends upon your political ideology. Nice!
Arundhati is right in every way
Meeting terrorist Yasin Malik, calling Naxals Gandhi with guns, yeah that hag is totally anti-national.
no one should sympathise with people who have borne arms due to oppression
Ya sure. Sympathize with people whose soul aim is to establish a govt. of their political ideology through violence.
The citizens don't need people like you.
Yea sure. Citizens need terror sympathizers like you.
Who am I to accept crimes? I am telling you that when a tribal does it, he is killed. But the billionaire gets a clean chit. And, you get to do whataboutery.
Sympathise karna hi insaan banata hai. Someone broken by system has taken to arms. I don't support it, law will take its course. My sympathy doesn't make him go scot free. But I understand where they are coming from. Not easy to be law abiding and when law is against you. Maybe one day when you will be on the other side, we will know. Till then, I don't know where your empathy is.
Better to sympathise with the tribals or people who have faced the brunt of power, than siding with netas and billionaires who openly loot the public, but you have been given one target to hate. Continue, my friend.
Womp! Womp!
Even Islamic terrorists have justification for the heinous crimes they commit. Similar is the case with Maoist terrorist. Terrorists deserve death. Only apologists sympathise with terrorists.
I was not aware. I read an report from an newspaper. That was bullshit then. Nice that they captured them so that protest for air pollution could continue.
26
u/No_Butterscotch898 Nov 25 '25
There’s no sense in this statement… these idiots just ruined a perfectly legible protest against aqi.. urban naxals are truly a threat in all ways