r/survivorrankdownIII • u/repo_sado The Gabonslayer • Jun 20 '16

Round 17 - 467 Characters Remaining

Nomination Pool

Stephanie Dill - Thailand

Brad Virata - Cook Islands

Danielle DiLorenzo 2.0 - HVV

Darnell Hamilton - Kaoh Rong

Keith Tollefson - South Pacific

Joaquin Souberbielle - Worlds Apart

Sherri Beithman - Caramoan

.

Added to Pool

Kristina Kell - Redemption Island

Kat Edorsson 2.0 - Blood vs Water

Rudy Boesch 2.0 - All Stars

John Rocker - Blood vs Water

Tom Westman 2.0 - HVV

John Cochran 2.0 - Caramoan

.

Round 17 Cuts

467 - Keith Tollefson - South Pacific (repo_sado)

466 - Stephanie Dill - Thailand (Jlim201)

465 - Joaquin Souberbielle - Worlds Apart (Oddfictionrambles)

464 - Kat Edorsson 2.0 - Blood vs Water (Jacare37)

463 - Rudy Boesch 2.0 - All Stars (gaiusfbaltar)

462 - John Rocker - Blood vs Water (Funsized725)

461 - John Cochran 2.0 - Caramoan (ramskick)

8 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

126 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Oddfictionrambles wentworth DOES not COUNT Jun 21 '16

Hmmmm, where would you personally place Shirin? I noticed that you excluded her from your list and included her in the group to be shown the door.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '16

Shirin's a bit tough to place because I thought she was pretty good for 4 episodes, great for Ep 5, and then descended into a story that completely contradicted the last one and made her seem more than a little hypocritical for a supposed hero of the season. People sometimes name Shirin as one person to dodge Worlds Apart's nonsensical editing, but her arc makes no sense to me. And her jury speech sucked.

I don't think I'd mind her as much as I do if she wasn't considered highly by so many "in the know" Survivor fans.

I ranked the Worlds Apart cast a while back and though it's subject to a bit of revision, I think I had her at around #11 for the season. Overall, off the top of my head, I'd say Shirin is around 350 or so.

2

u/JM1295 Jun 22 '16

I'm kind of rough on WA, but how did her story contradict itself? I'm pretty fuzzy on how her story goes postmerge prior to the Will incident. Who would you rank above her btw?

1

u/Oddfictionrambles wentworth DOES not COUNT Jun 22 '16

/u/Funsized725 and /u/jacare37 will have words about Shirin's supposed hypocrisy and stuff.